5 ms·
Sync Gear: How World War I Fighters Avoided Damaging Their Own Propellers
- ortusdux 3y agoReminds me of Intermeshing-rotor helicopters https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermeshing-rotor_helicopter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intermeshing-rotor_helicopter
- littlestymaar 3y agoTangentially related: you may wonder why they didn't use a pusher propeller[1] in the first place. After all, if the propeller is behind you, then you don't have an issue shooting in front of you, so why didn't they do it? It's because a pusher propeller stabilizes the plane a lot, when you start turning, the propeller applies a force that want to bring it back to its original direction, whereas the puller propeller have the opposite effect, making them much more maneuverable, which is the most important factor in a dogfight. See this excellent Twitter thread if you want to know more about the mechanical properties of both designs: https://nitter.42l.fr/F22124509/status/1538990570684784645#m https://nitter.42l.fr/F22124509/status/1538990570684784645#m [1]: a pusher propeller is behind the plane, “pushing” it instead of the more common “puller propeller” located in front. For examples of pusher propeller designs, look at popular UCAVs out there, like MQ-9 Reaper and Bayraktar TB2.
- vwcx 3y agoThanks, that thread is an excellent discussion of the differences. I had never considered the exhaust contamination of the propeller feed air in a pusher design.
- jfk13 3y agoIndeed, some pushers were used early in WW1; e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Aircraft_Factory_F.E.2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Aircraft_Factory_F.E.2 But as you say, the puller turned out to be superior.
- knodi123 3y agoWhy not both? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dornier_Do_335 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dornier_Do_335
- fsckboy 3y ago> making them much more maneuverable, which is the most important factor in a dogfight as an example problem in statistics class in grad school, we showed that the intuition that maneuverability is most important in a dogfight is incorrect, that it's speed (fly in, take a few shots, zoom away, lather rinse repeat) and that's why WWII fighters were so designed of course, all else being equal, maneuverability is good, but all else is not equal, there are aerodynamic tradeoffs
- littlestymaar 3y agoNote that WWI and WWII offered a very different fighting environment for pilots, so what's true in one environment doesn't necessarily apply to the other (especially since for WWII fighters, the ability to intercept and shoot down enemy bombers was a very important design consideration). I'd be curious to learn more about your statistics example though.
- fsckboy 3y agoit was a problem set type question, with details obscured to avoid our preconceptions, then the true picture revealed afterward; thus, no way of looking up that source. In any event, the data was from WWI and the point was that using their own data they drew the wrong conclusions for their theater based on having plotted it wrong. Had they basically transposed some axes (but counterintuitively to the way they were thinking) the correct trendlines popped right out. We had another similar problem based on the shuttle Challenger o-ring failure/temperature data, given to us as racing car blown engines. The point of these exercises was to learn to focus on the data statistically/analytically and not by eyeballing presentations, and the obscuring/revealing of the truth was to drive home the point that "lives can depend on this".
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y ago"Speed is Life."
- WalterBright 3y agoThe Fokker triplane was so agile that it could turn around almost on a dime and face whoever was chasing it.
- NamTaf 3y agoSpitballing here, but I wonder whether the relatively unsophisticated understanding of aerodynamics meant controlling for clean, laminar air behind the plane was much too difficult? E: perhaps reading your linked thread before making this comment would’ve been wise of me :)
- numpad0 3y agoI'm sure this is mentioned somewhere in that link, but I wonder if it has more to do with that it's easier to build, maintain and fly a front-heavy tractor with short nose, singular tail and shortest driveshaft possible, than about all the airflow considerations.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe article doesn't really say much about this, but it's an interesting topic. There were several ways these kind of systems were implemented, using mechanical linkages, hydraulics, or electrically using solenoids. Animation of a mechanical link system: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1OxWxYAGlc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1OxWxYAGlc Hydraulic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Oh1pLl1--Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Oh1pLl1--Y
- joshstrange 3y agoThe article was pretty sparse on how it was done technically and the video completely skips over it. It just shows slow motion of it working but (and I skipped around a tiny bit but I think I got all the actual talking, there is only so much slow motion of the same thing over and over I can stand) never actually explains the mechanism. Sidenote, I'm sure they took all the needed safety precautions but it sure seemed like they were standing in front of the gun barrel in a few shots which made me super anxious. I knew nothing was going to happen (since it was posted on YouTube) but it just felt felt dangerous.
- fsckboy 3y ago> I'm sure they took all the needed safety precautions no they didn't, one of the most prominent advocates working on this problem was killed by a ricochet. let me see if I can find it...
- sakjur 3y agoI think the comment you’re replying to refers to the Slow Mo Guys when they did their experiment and hopefully you’re talking about the aviation engineers during the war and not YouTubers. I’d be interesting to hear more about the advocate you’re talking about, early-in-field professionals are so often fascinating.
- WJW 3y agoIt's just a lever holding back the firing pin until the propellor is past a certain point even if the trigger is actuated. One of those brilliant inventions that is trivial if you know the secret but very tricky to discover if you don't.
- __loam 3y agoWe should celebrate simple elegance more than rampant complexity.
- alanbernstein 3y ago
- nescioquid 3y agoSerious question: why not just move the guns so they do not shoot through the props? I've always assumed there was a reason for it that required solving the engineering problem in the first place. But now I wonder whether it was just simply easier to invent the 'sync gear' than deal with whatever problems ensue from moving the guns. > Sync gear, also known as an interrupter or gun synchronizer, was developed during World War I to ensure that... Was the sync gear an application or adaptation of an existing technique?
- triceratops 3y agoMy guess: it's easier for the pilot to aim a gun that he's sitting directly behind. If the guns were mounted under the wings or whatever, it would be much harder.
- throwbadubadu 3y agoMuch easier aiming if its at the center (like no ""focal point""), and then the early ones also had only one, balance! But both uneducated guesses. focal point: not sure if its the right term here, what I mean is: If you put the guns far to the side and still let them shoot straight you have drastically reduced the chance to hit a plane flying in front. And if you point them inwards you have only one good distance (where bullets cross, like focal point) where you hit well.
- psunavy03 3y agoBecause if the gun is mounted on the centerline of the aircraft, it's more natural for the pilot to aim. Also, you can fire out to the full range of the ammunition. Guns mounted on the wings had to be canted inward so that their pattern of fire intersects at some distance in front of the aircraft, so you only get the full firepower of all your guns at or around that specific range. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_harmonisation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_harmonisation
- WalterBright 3y agoGuns mounted on the wings will increase the roll moment of inertia, making the airplane less agile.
- sn41 3y agoThe French aviator, Roland Garros (the stadium for the French open tennis is named after him) also made contributions to this problem, but not via a sync mechanism, but rather a deflector: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roland_Garros_(aviator) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roland_Garros_(aviator)
- fellowniusmonk 3y agoThe deflector solution is probably my favorite, people hardly believe it when you tell them.
- magicalhippo 3y agoSomewhat unrelated but for those interested in early war plane history and haven't stumbled over it already, Greg's[1] YouTube channel is awesome. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/@GregsAirplanesandAutomobiles https://www.youtube.com/@GregsAirplanesandAutomobiles