4 ms·
OK, fine, I'll bite. How have they been lying about AIDS?
by kstrauser 3y ago
OK, fine, I'll bite. How have they been lying about AIDS?
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- maxbond 3y agoAbsolutely amazing progress has been made in treating AIDS. There are medications available now that are able to reduce your viral load to below the limits of detection, you can live a reasonably normal life as someone HIV positive. A small number of people have even been cured. Discrimination within the medical profession is real and a problem, but I have to doubt the sincerity of your concern for marginalized people when you spread FUD like this. I am forced to conclude you have some bone to pick with the medical profession and are deploying marginalized people as ammunition. That's not cool. I'd appreciate it if you wouldn't do that.
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- maxbond 3y agoYou've failed to demonstrate that this is authoritarian. And I haven't criticized you for criticizing the FDA. I've criticized you for defending your position with misinformation, and for deploying marginalized people as a smokescreen. If your best rebuttal is to put words in my mouth and frame my criticism as censorious, it's time to reevaluate. It's a form of motte-and-bailey argument, you've abandoned your position that no breakthroughs have been made in the treatment of HIV in order to defend something more vague and less falsifiable ("the FDA is authoritarian"). You can choose to either consider whether your position was flawed (my recommendation in this case) or to discard your arguments and find better ones, but if you can't defend your position, there's a problem with your argumentation.
- gillytech 3y agoMarginalized people? What are you talking about? The first cases of AIDS was identified in homosexuals. That's a fact. My position is not that there have been no breakthroughs in the treatment of HIV at all. My argument is that HIV does not cause AIDS. When you don't have empirical evidence to support your fake claim that HIV causes aids then yeah, you need to go authoritarian. Hence endless government and para-government agencies dictating truth through biased and hopelessly flawed studies. When your argument is built on BS you need to argue at the upper levels and never look at the foundation.
- dna_polymerase 3y agoYou used the r-word. You come here with claims that go against the status quo and provide zero evidence to support your claims. Just admit it, you don't like gay people. No need for this idiotic 'AIDS is fake' charade.
- maxbond 3y agoThis is too far a leap, that haven't said anything overtly homophobic. It's likely they aren't homophobic, who knows. When we make leaps like this we risk the conversation devolving into something where the germane criticisms are lost. It's a lot easier to critique their position and rhetoric than to interrogate the content of their soul, and they will always have the home court advantage there. I'm not the rhetoric police, but that is my advice.
- gillytech 3y agoYou got it exactly right. Simply stating a fact is not an attack on anyone. In any scientific inquiry one needs to consider all the similarities and differences in the data. Most notably, if HIV is spread through sexual contact, why was it most prevalent in gay men of a particular lifestyle in a particular place? If it were straight white Amish people that it was attacking, I would say the same thing. Not that it matters, but my sister is gay and I am going to be in her wedding this October. I have a much more nuanced understanding of homosexuality as my twin falls into this category.
- kstrauser 3y agoFor anyone else following along, all of the above is factually wrong. Emtricitabine/tenofovir is used to treat and prevent HIV infections, and is on WHO's list of essential medicines. Literally millions of people are using it to control their HIV infections and prevent it from developing into AIDS. It can be bought on online pharmacies for $15 per month, so it's not exactly a trillion dollar drug. It's 100% certain that HIV causes AIDS. This is uncontroversial. It's true that scientists continue to learn more about how it infects humans and causes disease. This is why treatments are so much more effective than they use to be. There are 2 other known human disease causing retroviruses, HTLV-I and HTLV-II: https://www.health.state.mn.us/diseases/retrovirus/index.html https://www.health.state.mn.us/diseases/retrovirus/index.htm.... The person is quoting conspiracy theory talking points that are known, provably, untrue.