4 ms·
Or, a helpful drug that helps people in a risky situation.
by kstrauser 3y ago
Or, a helpful drug that helps people in a risky situation.
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- yieldcrv 3y agoI like how you start of with something substantiated, and then follow it with something fringe and unsubstantiated Please tell me you’re at least selling coffee mugs to your flock
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- yieldcrv 3y agoI'm actually curious about the AIDS one, which part is the lie out of curiosity? The existence of acquired immunodefiency from HIV? something else?
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- yieldcrv 3y agookay all that may have happened but HIV also causes AIDS in cases where there are no party drugs and poppers the t cell count lowers until your body isnt fighting anything anymore, due to the HIV virus’ continual rapid mutations
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- yieldcrv 3y agoImmunocompromised people die from opportunistic infections that don't normally cause illness at all. They would acquire immunocompromised status from HIV. Hence nobody would die "from AIDS", they would die from complications with the annual flu. They would be dead and still be HIV positive. That's why you haven't seen your goal because you have an unfalsifiable viewpoint where there is no competing information to alter your view because it is an impossible standard. AZT has bad side effects and is antiquated technology. Okay. Yes, there was a lot of hysteria in the 1980s and pharma companies aren’t held accountable for their role in that. There is also competing information that can be reproduced easily regarding HIV to immunocompromised status and opportunistic infections killing people. I would implore you to look at the things that are substantiated. In the 21st century, there are now drugs that keep your t-cell count high, such as PrEP. These aren't killing people and prevents progression to immunocompromised status, it also prevents spread of HIV. I'm sorry you'll never get to your resolution about drugs from the 1980s, but there is nothing to build upon with that information and you’re extrapolating from a position thats been a dead end for a long time, in comparison to what we can build upon with successfully protecting t-cells.
- xenadu02 3y agoAlmost none of what you've claimed is true. There was a large gap between discovery of HIV in human populations, including people getting AIDS and dying of trivial infections due to their immune systems being wiped out. Once people started looking deeper it was also discovered that it was far from a "gay" disease. All of this happened before a single human tried AZT for an HIV infection. Beyond all the scientific evidence we have real world Darwin Award trials: various HIV denialists infected with HIV have refused to take drugs to treat HIV and they have died. Others got very sick and were cured almost immediately after starting standard treatment. We also have numerous clinical cases of people with undiagnosed HIV infections getting sick from common bacterial/fungal infections, get diagnosed as HIV positive, start the standard drug regimen, and their problems go away. Not to mention SIV (the simian relative of HIV) causes an AIDS-like disease in some primate species which gives us both another line of direct evidence and almost certainly the original source of HIV. You're just plain wrong. We can squirt HIV in a dish and watch it kill the normally unkillable T cells. We know 100% what happens when your T cells collapse: your immune system stops working and some normally benign organism takes over your body then you die. We've sequenced HIV. We know how it mutates so rapidly. We know why it is able to attack T cells. There is no mystery and no need for conspiracy. All lines of evidence point to HIV as the culprit.
- kstrauser 3y agoOK, fine, I'll bite. How have they been lying about AIDS?
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- maxbond 3y agoAbsolutely amazing progress has been made in treating AIDS. There are medications available now that are able to reduce your viral load to below the limits of detection, you can live a reasonably normal life as someone HIV positive. A small number of people have even been cured. Discrimination within the medical profession is real and a problem, but I have to doubt the sincerity of your concern for marginalized people when you spread FUD like this. I am forced to conclude you have some bone to pick with the medical profession and are deploying marginalized people as ammunition. That's not cool. I'd appreciate it if you wouldn't do that.
- gillytech 3y ago[flagged]
- maxbond 3y agoYou've failed to demonstrate that this is authoritarian. And I haven't criticized you for criticizing the FDA. I've criticized you for defending your position with misinformation, and for deploying marginalized people as a smokescreen. If your best rebuttal is to put words in my mouth and frame my criticism as censorious, it's time to reevaluate. It's a form of motte-and-bailey argument, you've abandoned your position that no breakthroughs have been made in the treatment of HIV in order to defend something more vague and less falsifiable ("the FDA is authoritarian"). You can choose to either consider whether your position was flawed (my recommendation in this case) or to discard your arguments and find better ones, but if you can't defend your position, there's a problem with your argumentation.
- Madmallard 3y agoLikely far more of the former than the latter per medicine's track record in the last couple decades
- nobody9999 3y ago>Likely far more of the former than the latter per medicine's track record in the last couple decades I'd say that "medicine" has advanced quite a bit over the last few decades. Five year survival rates for cancers are up 40%[0] since 1975. AIDS treatments, when administered properly, extend the lives of infected persons by more than 500%[1] over those who don't receive such treatment. Advances in orthopaedic (especially arthroscopic surgery) and spinal surgery have completely transformed the quality-of-life of numerous folks I know -- including myself. And that's just a few things that "medicine" is getting right. How about developing and distributing a safe, effective vaccine for a a dangerous pathogen within a year of getting access to its genetic sequence, with several more to follow within 24 months? While there certainly are problems in the US pharmaceutical industry/regulatory environment which have caused incalculable harm to millions, "medicine" is more than the rapacious, incompetent scumbags in Big Pharma. However, the only way to reverse that is to fix the perverse incentives that rewards the singular pursuit of profit over the health and well-being of humans. There are a variety of ways to attempt such fixes, but it won't be easy to pull off, as there's a lot of money behind these folks. And more's the pity. But I'll say it again, "medicine" is more than just Big Pharma, insurance companies and healthcare conglomerates. Medicine has made our (mostly for those in the the "Global North", but also for many in the developing world too) lives demonstrably better in many, many ways. [0] https://progressreport.cancer.gov/after/survival https://progressreport.cancer.gov/after/survival [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27349729/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27349729/ Edit: Fixed subject/verb disagreement.
- Madmallard 3y agoI'd argue you're far more forgiving and optimistic than what's realistically happening with respect to ""medicine" is more than just Big Pharma, insurance companies and healthcare conglomerates" My experience with a semi-edge-of-medicine chronic condition has been absolutely atrocious nearly across the board and even with the absolute experts. And there's multifactorial reasons for it.