6 ms·
>how does WEI make it _impossible_ for attesters to return higher entropy information? It isn't impossible, but doing so would violate users privacy which isn'
by charcircuit 3y ago
>how does WEI make it _impossible_ for attesters to return higher entropy information?
It isn't impossible, but doing so would violate users privacy which isn't the goal of the proposal. You don't need WEI to violate people's privacy.
>False, this is an explicit design goal: "Allow web servers to evaluate the authenticity of the device and honest representation of the software stack and the traffic from the device."
That statement means that the site would learn that for example the server can trust that the user is using Chrome on windows. A feature of Chrome is that it's possible to spoof your user agent.
>Seeing a message that says "Sorry, this website is only accessible by browsers that support WEI" is very intrusive.
This can apply to anyone API. It's happened for WebGPU. It's blocking users is not a goal of the API.
>no website is going to trust your attestation service. This is equivalent to saying "Just create your own CA".
It is possible to create your own CA. How do you think things like Lets Encrypt came into existence. Trust is hard to earn. That doesn't mean that it is impossible to get people to trust you.
>No, the physical analog is "lying", which isn't illegal in most situations
I agree, but WEI is meant to be used in situations where lying should be illegal.
- zb3 3y ago> but WEI is meant to be used in situations where lying should be illegal. But here I once again have to point out that in practice this will look very different. The practical effect is that if someone installs LineageOS or even AOSP to get rid of Google spyware and preinstalled bloatware, then these attestation checks will fail and that user will not be able to use apps that are necessary in practice. The question is whether this is really a "side effect" or just the actual goal.
- hot_gril 3y agoThe actual goal is probably that Google and others prevent ad-blocking. WEI itself is not meant as a fingerprint, but with unblockable ads comes unblockable tracking (not that I personally care about tracking). Like, look at YouTube on iPhones, they blocked background playback in the app and even got Apple to block it in Safari in iOS update 10. They don't need WEI to keep the vast majority of users away from obscure alternative OSes, but as a side effect those would be impacted.
- charcircuit 3y agoYouTube contractually must pay extra when people play music in the background. It's why it's a premium only feature.
- hot_gril 3y agoRight, and they'll want to enforce things like this on desktop too.