3 ms·
You can balance a grand action to the point that a landing fly would have a good chance to produce a tone. You don't want it that light though: your fingers bru
by jacquesm 3y ago
You can balance a grand action to the point that a landing fly would have a good chance to produce a tone. You don't want it that light though: your fingers brushing the keys would already cause them to move, a bit of resistance works.
There are extremes, a famous concert pianist (for the life of me I can't remember which one) for instance had his piano set for super light touch, so light that others found his instrument(s) unplayable. And on the other end there is the mechanical church organ, with keys so heavy that playing anything at all turns into a physical work-out. Talk about 'strong fingers required', you need to be in top physical shape for that.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoThat light action for pianos sounds interesting, but I replied[1] to your other comment so maybe we should keep the discussion on that thread. As for organs on the other hand, I used to play a Victorian frankenstein^W 'hybrid' tracker organ in my local church (sadly now closed). The keys on that poor organ were certainly a work-out for the fingers, and of course got stiffer the more stops that were pulled out. I personally believe that it is valuable to maintain these now-rare tracker organs for their historical merit - they were arguably the most complex machines ever created before the electronic digital computer took that title. However, when it comes to music, I'm not a purist: there is nothing about the stiffness of the keys inherent to the sound of a pipe organ, so I'm all for pneumatic control. Electronic keys also work well if care is taken to reduce the overall latency, as witness by the success of the Wurlitzer theatre organs. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37054825 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37054825 [2]: 'Hybrid' this instance means an original nineteenth-century tracker mechanism, combined with a 20th century blower and an electronic organ invisibly integrated into the instrument. Actually, not so invisibly, as it frequently malfunctioned. There is also record of a pneumatic action somewhere, but I haven't located it myself.
- jacquesm 3y agoI played the organ in Liepaja, it was amazing. I'd move there if I could just to help keep it in shape. And yes, those should be preserved, there isn't all that many of them left. And organ component manufacturers are going out of business as well (Laukhuff, recently :( ). Ah, I've found the pianist: it's Horowitz (I mistakenly thought it was Rubinstein), read here for some fascinating bits of piano lore: https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php?topic=20859.0 https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php?topic=20859.0