4 ms·
"WHEREAS, NightOwl app enables Users to share internet traffic by modifying their device’s network settings to be used as a gateway for internet traffic. Additi
by kstrauser 3y ago
"WHEREAS, NightOwl app enables Users to share internet traffic by modifying their device’s network settings to be used as a gateway for internet traffic. Additionally, the User’s device acts as a gateway for NightOwl app’s Clients, including companies that specialize in web and market research, SEO, brand protection, content delivery, cybersecurity, etc."
Fuck that with a chainsaw. Burn it. Burn it with fire.
- barbazoo 3y agoI guess "modifying their device’s network settings" is already covered under whatever permissions we had to give it to perform the original task of switching on/off dark mode? That's a bummer. Would be nice if app permissions were more granular if that's the case.
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoAnd this is the risk that operating system developers run when you take away features or you don't develop features that your userbase wants. Look at the amount of Start Menu modifiers there are out there for Windows. All because Microsoft keeps on changing the start menu. Why? I don't know. I just want to get rid of the Recommended section, but I'm not allowed to.
- qwerpy 3y agoLast night I got a notification that advertised Game Pass to me. I angrily clicked on manage notifications and there’s a notification source called “Suggested” that somehow was turned on. That was the last straw for me. I go through so much diligence setting up my browser’s ad block, only for the OS to bypass all that. For now “Suggested” is turned off and I disabled all notifications for good measure, but I don’t know how much longer Windows will allow that. I don’t intend to find out.
- crazygringo 3y agoSo, usually I associate super-shady things with hiding the fact that they're super-shady. I'm thankful, but also genuinely curious, why they put this explicitly in their TOS. It just kind of seems to be like the kind of person/org who would implement this shady stuff in the first place, would also actively hide that they're doing it. Is there a legal reason that protects NightOwl by explicitly putting it in the TOS? E.g. does this prevent them from being sued for any of it, where they could have been successfully sued otherwise? Like it's technically do to all this shady stuff but only as long as it's in your TOS?
- runlaszlorun 3y agoI’m no lawyer but my guess is that the bar is so low for what’s actually legal- and no one generally reads these EULA’s- that it’s easier just to have it in there.
- sublinear 3y agoThe bar is intentionally low "for what's actually legal". You really don't want the government interfering with the implementation details and business models of software products. That's a really bad road to go down. The problem is really a lack of inspiration for both the dev and user. In this case someone made a trivial tool and didn't know how else to monetize it than being a scumbag and exploiting social norms and good will. The user also decided to use something that's dumb and not worth risking making any agreement with any entity at all. Situations like this are where free software excels. Things that are inconsequential in premise should stay that way in practice.
- sublinear 3y agoI'm not a lawyer, but the terms of service are an agreement with the user, so yes. They're not hiding anything because then they'd get sued. If they didn't disclose "this shady stuff" then the user can try to resolve their dispute via remedies stipulated elsewhere. Really there are several ways they could have gone about writing this agreement. This is probably the simplest for everyone. This is also how the bigger orgs write their agreements. They state their intent and you have to agree or fuck off. The badly written agreements (what you were expecting) are less honest and try to explicitly have the user waive some rights entirely including any remedies in or out of court, but those can usually be deemed unenforceable because they violate established rights and precedent rulings.
- dingosity 3y ago[flagged]
- kstrauser 3y agoSelling ads is one thing. Selling my Internet connection, which violates the ToS of most ISPs, is a vastly different situation.
- dingosity 3y agoHow So? I mean, NightOwl doesn't have an arrangement with your ISP, they have an arrangement with you. I'm not sure your ISP is going to delete your account because you didn't know some app was doing something shady. If the standard is every app user has to know what each app does under the hood, then there's going to be a lot of people who won't be able to match that standard.
- dylan604 3y agoare you kidding? of course they will. back in the early days of the interwebs, it was not unheard of to have the ISP block your account when your machine got hacked from malware and used your box/connection as a SPAM server. From they, consumer ISPs just block that port. They've also added terms about not running servers on the consumer connection. While your server would have to be using a lot of bandwidth to get noticed, it is part of their terms that you agree to. So yes, they will absolutely suspend your account until they are satisfied the usage is in alignment with their expectations.
- tayiorrobinson 3y agoTheir TOS essentially just says "Don't use the app" > NightOwl app cannot be held responsible in any circumstances for Shared traffic fees or any other costs the User may incur in accordance with agreements with their internet service provider. The Application use might be prohibited or restricted by the User's service provider or applicable laws. The Application may not be compatible with all service providers' policies and regulations. The User should confirm the ability to use the Application with their service provider.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoName and shame the developers and the company.
- tpoacher 3y ago> "enables" it's not a violation of your freedoms and privacy, it's an opportunity! /s