3 ms·
Some comments I have on this post: > Worse yet, I know that Cloudflare knows I have those certificates. Why? Because it asked for them! Not really. Cloudflare
by jeroenhd 3y ago
Some comments I have on this post:
> Worse yet, I know that Cloudflare knows I have those certificates. Why? Because it asked for them!
Not really. Cloudflare notices your browser has TLS authentication available and asks you for it. That's really annoying, but part of the protocol spec. Your browser won't send this information unless you pick a certificate and hit OK.
Disable your ad blocker and you'll find that many trackers will also ask you to identify yourself this way. It's really annoying, browsers need to design better UX for this type of authentication.
> · MAC address of my machine that I have previously used to access this site
How does it gather your MAC address? Did you disable IPv6 Privacy Extensions? Unless the website is sitting behind the same switch as your computer or you run some kind of native application that sends the MAC address, websites can't read the MAC of your network interface. Enable the MAC randomisation that's present (sometimes even turned on by default!) in every modern OS if you consider the local switch or WiFi network to be a privacy risk.
> Will I be able to create and sync these passkeys myself?
Yes, assuming they follow the standard
> Can only certain types of software use passkeys? If so, who decides what software meets this standard?
I don't really understand the question. Any software supporting passkeys will be able to prompt you for generating or using a passkey.
> Will I only be able to generate passkeys on a device with specific hardware/software requirements like a TPM, DeviceCheck, or Integrity API?
According to the spec, keys can be stored in software no trouble. Websites and apps can ask for securely generated keys, but I don't think those are all that common. Hardware can also be faked relatively easily in most circumstances.
> Can I, at any time, export my passkeys from one service provider and switch to another provider?
Ask your service provider for export options. Most likely, you can't just dump the keys and import them elsewhere (that would defeat the point).
> If a passkey is invovled in a suspicious event, will that suspicious mark propogate to any other device that uses that same passkey? Do devices that contain suspicious passkeys also get marked as suspicious? If so, would that impact the ability of that device to access other independent websites?
That depends on the software using the key for authentication. Maybe?
- paradox460 3y agoI've seen the misconception a lot; people seem to think that random websites can grab your MAC like they can get your IP address.
- Ekaros 3y agoMAC is a weird thing, it is important for ethernet to work efficiently. But in actuality it only travels to about next router from machine...
- jeroenhd 3y agoWith WiFi, MAC addresses become more of an issue (as you're often scanning and roaming), but we have randomisation algorithms for that. The same was true for IPv6 for a while, but that too has been solved a long time ago. For a SLAAC client whose privacy extensions have been disabled for some reason, it's very much possible to figure out your MAC address. This may be a problem on old hardware that doesn't receive updates anymore!