5 ms·
Plans like this are based on envy and not reality. Private jets contribute a minimal amount of carbon emissions. Yes they are outsized compared to the emissions
by SoftTalker 3y ago
Plans like this are based on envy and not reality. Private jets contribute a minimal amount of carbon emissions. Yes they are outsized compared to the emissions per-passenger on a commercial jet. Yes the people who use them to fly to lunch should probably reflect on their choices. But they are not the low hanging fruit. Private jets also provide good jobs for pilots, mechanics, airport staff, as well as jobs for the people who build them, the people who build and program the avionics, the engines, etc.
- igor47 3y agoI hate the jobs argument. It's like saying, "we should keep the concentration camps open, what are all the guards going to do". Any antisocial/harmful activity will employ people to do it, that doesn't mean we should condone it. Even more -- our civilization has a certain amount of productive capacity. I'm not saying we can or should have a central state planner to determine how to allocate it, though tax policy is often aimed at steering it. But I do wish that those skilled mechanics and engineers who work on private jets or yachts or cruise ships (and the raw resources used in their construction) would go instead to, like, more housing and offshore wind and nuclear reactors etc...
- nh23423fefe 3y agoYou hate the jobs argument but made a nazi reference in the same paragraph?
- frodowtf 3y agoWhat is your counter argument here?
- nh23423fefe 3y agogood job pretending to care about rigor.
- foverzar 3y agoThat roping nazis into every discussion is a super cheap and intellectually lazy rhetorics.
- mikestew 3y agoI hate the jobs argument. Man, I hate to digress this much, but I've recently seen the absurd end result of this thinking. Local Redmond, WA city council incumbent candidate running this year said they would work to support local business that have been hard-hit by COVID, et al. This councilperson's solution: advocate for return-to-work policies. The implied outcome being that the returned-to-office workers will suddenly visit those businesses now that they're back in the office. (One can read my almost-a-direct quote on Carson's campaign website.) Well, at least we know who David Carson works for, and it ain't you.
- ecshafer 3y agoI am not local to redmond. But isn’t that town just dominated by Microsoft? And aren’t they going back to office regardless of what some town council member says one way or the other?
- mikestew 3y agoBut isn’t that town just dominated by Microsoft? Used to be, not so much now I don't think. Of my neighbors within a few houses of me: one Google (used to be MSFT), one Facebook, one game studio (who's games you might have heard of), Microsoft neighbors one house over, my Microsoft spouse, and me working at a small hardware company. But that's just anecdotal, and even if it's accurate, it's still a town that largely thinks of itself as a "Microsoft town" AFAICT. (Aside: good $DEITY, maybe my neighbors don't all work at Microsoft, but do any of them not work in software?) But you're on the right track, as I thought perhaps it was just an easy nod to the largest employer in town, and maybe it is. But the statement was so logically asinine that I'm not exactly sure what his intent was.
- tivert 3y ago> Well, at least we know who David Carson works for, and it ain't you. It's pretty rare to have a government that works only for you. Probably the only people to experience that are absolute monarchs and the like. David Carson has constituents, and some of them have interests different than yours. Welcome to democracy. As an aside: one of the irksome things about software engineers and other tech people is they frequently embrace the idea of "creative destruction," but I think that's mainly because they imagine themselves as the ones who will always be doing the destroying and reaping the benefits, instead of as the ones who will be destroyed.
- gochi 3y agoI generally agree, but I fear we do this every time with every topic. Everything isn't low hanging fruit, it's always something else somewhere else that should be changed. It's not the plastic bags it's the cow industry, it's not the cow industry it's the oil drills, it's not the oil drills it's the cars we drive, it's not the cars we drive it's the private jets celebs use, etc. At some point, we're all going to have to realize this is an insane way to solve issues and that we can't solve certain issues without making inconvenient adjustments.
- melling 3y agoPrivate jets are irrelevant. There aren’t enough to even matter. A hundred years of burning coal. Now that will cause some real global warming. Hard to believe we burn more coal now than ever. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/27/coal-consumption-hit-an-all-time-high-in-2022-iea-says.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/27/coal-consumption-hit-an-all-... Someone should do the math. If we had to guess, is 1 year of coal equivalent to 100 years of all of aviation?
- billiam 3y agoGuess who owns the companies that bought the governments that subsidize coal production for the last century and a half? These hand wavy arguments about scale ignore the fact that the superrich and their ability to capture governance and policy are the whole problem. Put a real carbon tax on their consumption and they will not "reflect on their choices" but could become more supportive of energy policies that don't doom their customers and themselves.
- phendrenad2 3y agoI don't think it's jealousy, I think most people just have no sense of relative scale, or they too easily accept their first instinct, and don't understand how hard it is to get a sense of relative scale.
- chung8123 3y agoThey should pay for their externalities just like everything else.
- lenkite 3y agoAll the rich folk who fly about on private jets should stop talking about climate change. If you can assure me that, then they can continue to fly. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/climate-change-private-jets-carbon-emissions-tax/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/climate-change-private-jets-car...
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> All the rich folk who fly about on private jets should stop talking about climate change. If you can assure me that, then they can continue to fly. A EU politican came by plane (first thought to be a private jet but turns out it was a commercial plane IIUC) to a climate change conference, then two streets before the place where the meeting was happening she hopped on a bicycle "because green"... Bicycle escorted by two SUVs. Ridiculous.
- LargoLasskhyfv 3y agoSeen that one too. The show must go on! Happened many times before, also, with different politicians in different countries. Anyways, the SUVs are for security. Have to be always at hand. Can you imagine being without them, in the public?
- LargoLasskhyfv 3y agoWhat?
- axpy 3y agoAre you referring to Theresa Ribiera(Spainish Minister) incident? Stop getting your news from tabloids. Records showed she was driven to the event. While being on a bike and followed by 2 SUV full of bodyguard seems ridiculous, there are sometime protocol to follow. She used a bike sharing service for the journey between her hotel and the conference venue. She and was also seen on a bike at another occasion on the same trip. If we can stop acting like offenced Virgin and spend time finding real solutions, that would be nice.
- wnc3141 3y agoMy view is that the role of government helps regulate maximizing value for society as a hole (wherein externalities are not reflected in private market transactions), which requires coordinating some form of collective action. The guiding principle of these decisions should be to redirect the value from a disproportionate harm to society toward ameliorating those harms. So infact the contribution to climate change from a private jet far outweighs that of a commercial jet. That is because few people are inducing great harm, rather than that carbon being more efficiently used across more people. So in exchange for inducing [x] amount of carbon, society gains nearly nothing from a private jet flight where as commercial moves vastly more people. Indeed there are also ethical considerations of using a private jet when there is a more efficient alternative (commercial), that could be taxed as a 'vice'. Lastly one day there may be a point where we need to ban these type of emissions wholesale rather than look at an efficiency basis.(Example: no amount of heroin is useful to society), but for carbon that conversation has not yet entered mainstream political discussions. (A hard cap on emissions would make flying only available to the very rich). Therefore it is both practical and just to tax private jet carbon. An observation: from interning at a firm adjacent to private aviation I noticed that there appears no upper bound the demand for private aviation. Even in the scenario where a tax does not change demand for private jet miles, it will at the very least provide funding for ameliorating the harms to society from the marginal production of carbon emissions.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoThat's not the right argument. The right argument is if there is a problem with something not reflected in the price of the product a reasonable approach is to tax the product to cover the externality and thnm STFU. The externality in this case is emissions so tax the emissions and STFU. There is no good argument for government to treat one emission differently than another, it matters not whether said emission comes from a kardashian private jet or public transit carrying nurses and doctors to provide charity healthcare. Tax the emission and STFU. The STFU part is very important because free markets are self regulating, which lets people making good capital allocations prosper and limits bad allocators and most of you are bad allocators, especially most of you government types and authoritarian types. Let the market run and be pleasantly surprised by the unforseen benefits that accrue to you. (Government should still aggressively break up monopoly and oligopoly but that is a different discussion of a corner case rather than this discussion of the core tenet of how the system functions so well.)
- hackeraccount 3y agoThat's probably the wrong argument. The right one is that private jets are a net productivity gain. Getting a person to a place more quickly then commercial is going to make all of us more wealthy. If we're all wealthier we can afford to do any number of different things.