4 ms·
The article states it's a Samsung phone, almost certainly a Galaxy S variant by market share. All Samsung phones I know honor a pre-bootloader protocol (access
by ajross 15y ago
The article states it's a Samsung phone, almost certainly a Galaxy S variant by market share. All Samsung phones I know honor a pre-bootloader protocol (accessible by a leaked tool named "Odin" or its reverse-engineered open source equivalent "Heimdall"). This can read out the contents of all partitions without ever running a Linux kernel. The mountable filesystems are all readable just fine on the host.
The FBI's forensics people are idiots, basically. They have what they want already, they never needed the PIN code.
- joshAg 15y agodon't forget that they have strict requirements they have to follow for the data gathered from their forensics to be admissible as evidence.
- ajross 15y agoIf those requirements are sane, then a non-invasive raw dump of the flash using only factory-installed firmware is surely more compliant.
- rprasad 15y agoCost-benefit analysis: spend a few hours trying to translate a raw flash dump into a readable format (in addition to the normal forensic work of looking at the phone's drive's contents), or spend <1hr to see whether a pro forma subpoena makes all that work unneccessary? This isn't a high-priority case, so the FBI will always go with the cheaper, quicker option.
- ajross 15y agoGood grief: "mount -o loop raw_flash_dump /where/ever". I weep for the state of things that straightforward tasks like this seem "hard" not just to yahoos at the FBI but even to Javascript jockeys who frankly should know better. Going to court harder than spending half an hour to dump the phone? Really?