3 ms·
> Canada’s “housing crisis” is a permanent state of affairs that harms people in, or in need of, rental housing; roughly one-third of the country’s households.
by ggm 3y ago
> Canada’s “housing crisis” is a permanent state of affairs that harms people in, or in need of, rental housing; roughly one-third of the country’s households.
and
> A housing system that serves all but one group is not in a state of crisis; it is one based on structural inequality and economic exploitation.
I think my point here is the lack of common understanding of what "crisis" means and a belief the linguistic narrow interpretation is "this is not a crisis" because its a systemic failure in design and goals.
Well, "capitalism is in crisis" has been a catch-cry of the left for 80+ years and remains true, despite a lot of shareholder value being made along the way.
There obviously is a massive underlying problem around affordable homes. The article is trying to draw focus to it but I find the "its not a crisis" thing somewhat small as a hook to hang it on. If you're young, or fleeing DV, it's a crisis indeed.
The phrase which comes to mind is "permanent crisis" which I went looking for, and indeed it's been a thing for a very long time.
So no. I disagree. Housing IS in crisis, it's a permanent persisting crisis, which advantages the investor side at the expense of social well being at large.
And if like me you are at the end of your mortgage and working life, you have almost certainly been complicit in this crisis, a fight of the old against the young. We mortgaged the 60s and 70s against the future, and now the future is impoverished.
- semiquaver 3y agoRight. The obvious counterpoint is the now commonly used term “climate crisis”. The danger has been obvious for years yet has been largely unaddressed because of structural aspects of the global economy and society. That lack of adequate response doesn’t mean global warming isn’t a crisis!
- ggm 3y agoI am of course guilty of fighting a second or third order issue trench war here because the primary issue is the housing crisis, or whatever we want to call it.
- 6510 3y agoEnglish is not my first language but the dictionary states a crisis is: a time of intense difficulty or danger. a time when a difficult or important decision must be made. However, it comes from from Greek krisis ‘decision’, from krinein ‘decide’. It seems you can have your crisis the way you like it :) The housing decision was to have it be unaffordable. But it is only a permanent crisis if it was decided to be that way. I do like the article, the point still stands. I do doubt if it is a road to a solution. I would try a different angle. If rents grow to match income then salaries must grow to match rent. There should be people out there who pay salaries and don't like how expensive that already is. People who spend 1/3 of their income on rent would welcome a 5% pay cut in exchange for 30% lower rent. In the supermarket I ran into the big boss from the firm I rent from. I did a funny monologue: My rent is well below average in this city but I still managed to pay 3 times the 2010 market value of the property, the price at which you offered to sell it to me but I couldn't afford. Not much was done over the years, a paint job, some plumbing, no real expenses were made. I'm not the first tenant, before me people paid 2-5 times the 2010 value(?) Now the property value has gone up dramatically. This means you've made even more money, much more! Then you send me a letter that argues you are increasing my rent because you've made so much money. Every year you want one more week of my salary because you've made so much money. I also know you have a giant waiting list while you are selling houses rather than building them. I get it, if earnings grow beyond a point you may no longer mix social housing with private housing projects. This will make your job much more complicated and the transition comes with considerable costs you are not looking forwards to. I have great idea, you are not obligated to increase my rent every year. You could sell fewer houses, own more property and have more renters. You see where I'm going with this? >points finger< Then I walked away not waiting for an answer. The next year the standard letter said my rent would go up by 0%.