3 ms·
Okay, but Android literally is a Linux distro, or family of distros perhaps. I'm happy to agree that we really need better terminology, but the answer is better
by yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago
Okay, but Android literally is a Linux distro, or family of distros perhaps. I'm happy to agree that we really need better terminology, but the answer is better terminology, not less precise terminology.
- "Linux" is bad because Android is Linux.
- "GNU/Linux" doesn't quite work because 1. ChromeOS is GNU/Linux and 2. Alpine isn't.
- "mainline Linux" is a thing we want, but still separate - I'd take Droidian with a hacked-up vendor kernel over a Pixel running an official Android image on mainline Linux any day.
The best I've been able to come up with is something like "user-controlled Linux" or "community OS" or even just "not Android", but I'd really prefer a better term.
- pjmlp 3y agoAndroid officially does not support Linux APIs for userspace. https://developer.android.com/ndk/guides/stable_apis https://developer.android.com/ndk/guides/stable_apis Applications deployed via Play Store might crash and burn by ignoring this fact, which is a reason why termux nowadays must be sideloaded.
- Adverblessly 3y ago> - "Linux" is bad because Android is Linux. If you are being precise, Android is not Linux (and neither is Debian for that matter). It is an operating system that uses the Linux kernel. > The best I've been able to come up with is something like "user-controlled Linux" or "community OS" or even just "not Android", but I'd really prefer a better term. Here is my proposal, we continue to call operating systems like those "Linux" and call operating systems like Android and ChromeOS "Operating systems that use the Linux kernel". No reason to give the common and useful definition an awkward name like "Community OS" just to allow the abberant cases to continue to reside within the "Linux" definition.
- fsflover 3y agoOr simply use the old term GNU/Linux wherever appropriate.
- fruitreunion1 3y agoWell, Alpine wouldn't fit that definition but is still a user-controlled Linux.
- linmob 3y agoOh yeah. I've landed on the (slightly weird) "GNU-like Mobile Linux".
- fruitreunion1 3y agoAnother term I've seen used is "traditional Linux distributions" as opposed to locked-down/less general purpose like Android and Chrome OS.