3 ms·
Assuming they dont just have the same name but are intentionally impersonating you - sounds like fraud, false advertising or identity theft [ianal]
by bawolff 3y ago
Assuming they dont just have the same name but are intentionally impersonating you - sounds like fraud, false advertising or identity theft [ianal]
- thaumasiotes 3y agoThe example book just has the same name. It should be defensible; you can write under any name you want. Amazon itself is the entity attributing the book to the more famous Jane Friedman. This is a case where the "impersonator" appears to be legally fine and Amazon is on questionable ground.
- qiqitori 3y agoYou can write under any name you want, depending on your intent. If your intent is to deceive, you probably can't. Here's an example of a literary forgery (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literary_forgery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Literary_forgery) where the author ended up in prison: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler_Diaries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler_Diaries ... But it would probably take some digging to see what particular action he was had for.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoHe stated outright that the author of the diaries was the same Adolf Hitler who led the Nazi party, and sold the diaries for over a million deutschmarks on that assurance. It's not very complex.
- theptip 3y ago> At the very least, if you look at my author profile on Amazon, these junk books don’t appear. It sounds like maybe this is not happening? If they are just appearing under the search for “AuthorName” I am not sure there really is a problem with Amazon’s system. IANAL, perhaps Amazon still has some liability if an author is using a fraudulent pen name for books they submit.
- Pxtl 3y agoAmazon's software is odd here. If I click on the name on a real Jane Friedman book, it does not include the fake books... But this is not commutative. If I click on the name on a fake Jane Friedman book, it lists out a mix of real and fake books. For example, this is a blank notebook on Amazon Canada that a seller has stuck her all-lowercase name upon. If I click the author name on the listing, I'm taken to an author search page that intermingles it with her real books.[1] That strongly implies Amazon asserting they're one and the same. Knowing that in the reverse this does not hold tells me that this us probably an unconsidered edge-case and not intentional design. But still, Amazon is, in that search, saying "oh you're looking for more jane friedman (lowercase) here's Jane Friedman (title case)" which implies they're the same person. I'd call that a software bug... but now that Friedman has informed them, they can't plead ignorance of the bug. [1] https://www.amazon.ca/NOTEBOOK-Notebook-journal-jane-friedman/dp/B0B3S8F9WR/ref=mp_s_a_1_7?crid=3PFG9OPWVLR2E&keywords=jane+friedman&qid=1691462538&sprefix=jane+friedman%2Caps%2C174&sr=8-7 https://www.amazon.ca/NOTEBOOK-Notebook-journal-jane-friedma...
- another-dave 3y agoyeah I think what you really need is for Amazon to have a Wikipedia style 'disambiguation' page. Then they can link them but make it obvious that they're two (or more) different people and results for person A aren't related to person B: > Showing 1-1 books for Dr Spock: > * Baby and Child Care > > Search instead for: > > * Mr Spock (10 albums)
- thaumasiotes 3y agoAmazon's identification is a train wreck. Most books have links on the page to what is, by Amazon's description, the kindle version of the same book. Quite often, that link goes to the kindle version of an unrelated book.
- theptip 3y agoGood analysis. It seems in the inauthentic case on the product page they are just linking “jane friedman” to a search page for that term. Wonder if there is a way of setting up a merchant account with just a label/DBA vs an extra step of claiming an author account. Agreed it does seem like a bug.
- kelnos 3y ago> you can write under any name you want. Sort of. Publishing under a pseudonym is fine, but most US states have laws that prevent you from using someone else's name and likeness without their permission.