3 ms·
Isn't the lack of recent precedent because most industries already have existing regulators? A new industry coming into existence isn't that common, and when it
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Isn't the lack of recent precedent because most industries already have existing regulators? A new industry coming into existence isn't that common, and when it does happen, I don't think this is actually unprecedented. AT&T was one of the big proponents of new regulation back when telephone companies were a recent development.
> that would simultaneously be less-burdensome than the status quo yet also cement incumbents' advantages
But that's classic regulatory capture. The industry gets the government to impose regulations that are wasteful and bureaucratic but can be navigated by a large organization with economies of scale, which allows regulators to appear as if they're doing something, but the rules don't prevent the incumbents from making a mint by consolidating the industry and charging monopoly rents or avoiding taxes paid by the middle class and smaller competitors etc.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> AT&T was one of the big proponents of new regulation back when telephone companies were a recent development AT&T wanted a regulator so it could scale like the railroads. The regulator wasn't to regulate AT&T, if I remember correctly, it was to regulate the states. (It backfired in the long run.) Broadly speaking, if you’re weak enough to need a regulator to guard your moat, you’re weak enough to be overpowered by the regulator. Regulatory capture, successful examples, at least, begin from a position of strength. Altman pitched doom and gloom and then, when the EU began reacting, seemed surprised that they weren’t permissive.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> The regulator wasn't to regulate AT&T, if I remember correctly, it was to regulate the states. It was to consolidate the regulation so they could focus on capturing the one federal regulator instead of 50 different state ones, sure. But you do that so that when the public starts clamoring for something to be done, you get to control what gets done, and do something that benefits the incumbents and not new entrants. > (It backfired in the long run.) It seems to me that it's still pretty hard to start a competing telephone company. I might be able to get some open source VoIP software running on a VM in one day. Now I want to offer WiFi calling plans. There is some domain name in the public DNS where phone numbers are subdomains that resolve to the IP address of its associated phone company so I know where to route calls, and I just go to some free government website to have some numbers routed to me so I can assign them to customers, right? No? > Broadly speaking, if you’re weak enough to need a regulator to guard your moat, you’re weak enough to be overpowered by the regulator. But the strength comes from the moat protected by regulations. The law inhibits competition, so you extract lots of rents from customers, so you have lots of money to influence regulators with. The regulators are the source of your power, but you and the rents you extract are the source of campaign funding, and they don't want to cut that off. Or worse, have it directed to the other party, if they can't actually bankrupt you before the next election cycle.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoDo you have a good source on the history of AT&T and the FCC?