4 ms·
There are many factors. The minivan itself is dying, and it's almost a "perfect" car for many use cases - can hold 8, can get car-like mileage, can hold as much
by bombcar 3y ago
There are many factors. The minivan itself is dying, and it's almost a "perfect" car for many use cases - can hold 8, can get car-like mileage, can hold as much as an SUV, is easier to get into.
But they're dying because people ain't buying, because the costs are so high and those with the money to buy new vehicles don't like them.
There is NOTHING preventing small SUVs that hold 5 people and cargo, get really good mileage, and are cheap(ish) - but they don't exist used because they don't exist new.
(It's sad, because I'm buying a new minivan, and I could not make the PHEV Pacifica make sense no matter how I finagled the financial numbers, the Sienna is simply unavailable at reasonable trim levels, and nobody makes an EV minivan.)
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoMinivans are mostly dying because the designs all look like they came from junior designers who hope to one day grow up and work on a real car. Not that it's their fault. They manufacture these things on set platforms and none of them do any justice to the shape of the vehicle.
- bombcar 3y agoThey're half-heartedly trying - the Kia Carnival kind of looks like an SUV from a decent distance. The Toyota Highlander is just a minivan with SUV doors.
- jhawk28 3y agoVW is coming out with the EV. Honda and Toyota are the only minivans worth buying, but good luck finding anything.
- bombcar 3y agoKia's coming in fast and is what we went with. Everyone's promising hybrid and EV but that doesn't help when the baby arrives sooner than the vehicle can ship. Honda's really dated now and needs a strong refresh. Toyota's king of the market and it shows they know, I wish someone would light a fire under them a bit.
- oezi 3y agoHow about the VW Id Buzz?
- bombcar 3y agoIt's hard to load the kids into a render :D Once it's available, that might be very nice. I was supremely disappointed that the Transit full-size van is NOT available in passenger in the EV version. Might have almost stretched the budget for that.
- fla 3y agoThe VW Multivan Hybrid is great! The electric range is quite small (60km I think?) compared to a full EV but still sufficient for some daily trips. And smaller batteries charges fast.
- wonderwonder 3y agoI'm quite interested in looking at this when it comes out in the US. Not sure I want a car payment but I'll take a look. It looks fun
- mwbajor 3y ago"There is NOTHING preventing small SUVs that hold 5 people and cargo, get really good mileage, and are cheap(ish) - but they don't exist used because they don't exist new." I have a chevy silverado with a crew cab. I put my 6 family members in it regularly. I get 20-25mpg on the highway because the engine shuts down 4 cylinders when I'm cruising. I have had hondas, toyotas, BMWs and I have to say in my opinion, american full-size trucks are the greatest cars on the road today in terms of trading-off size, efficiency, reliability, range, price (maybe not now) etc. I never thought of myself as a "truck guy" until I got one. Its a hard pill for many to swallow.
- bombcar 3y agoThe truck market in the USA is pretty darn competitive, and people don't buy them because of "penis issues" as many seem to think. If they sold the six door version, I might go with one, but you can't load tiny kids in the front bench. https://www.kingseriespickup.com https://www.kingseriespickup.com is a bit beyond me :D They're damn usable vehicles, especially if you consider the entire market from the Maverick up to the super-duty. Someone should do the math on the environmental aspects of one largish vehicle for a family vs a largish + smaller (e.g, when does the fuel savings of the smaller finally out run the cost of acquiring said smaller).
- tomtheelder 3y ago20-25 miles highway is absolutely appalling. Like shockingly terrible. A conventional ICE minivan would get 10-15 extra mpg with additional room for passengers, and would cost less. A reasonably sized hybrid would easily get double the mileage. In my opinion, full size trucks are the absolute worst vehicles on the road in terms of those trade offs. You get pitiful gas mileage, a tiny cab, high prices, and the thing is absolutely massive despite most folks only generally using a tiny portion of it at a time. IMO the only justifiable reason to drive a pickup is if you tow or carry extremely volumes of stuff on a near daily basis.
- bombcar 3y agoI'm not sure what ICE minivans you're thinking of, except maybe the Sienna? > The Carnival matched its EPA combined rating during its stay with us, averaging 22 mpg. https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a38417315/2022-kia-carnival-reliability-maintenance/ https://www.caranddriver.com/reviews/a38417315/2022-kia-carn... > No matter which trim you select, the 2023 Honda Odyssey mpg will be 19 city/28 highway/22 combined. These are not 10-15 extra. Maybe 5-10 extra. The Sienna might pull 15 extra.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> There is NOTHING preventing small SUVs that hold 5 people and cargo, get really good mileage, and are cheap(ish) Like the RAV-4 Hybrid, Ford Escape Hybrid & Plug-in Hybrid, etc., yes. > but they don't exist used because they don't exist new. Except they do exist, both new and used.
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoYeah and a new RAV-4 delivery date is 2-3 YEARS after you put a deposit down and the used market is in a stranglehold by the dealerships.
- frumper 3y agoMost carmakers don't sell most of their new cars on the order it and it shows up model. They send to dealers and you buy them. Our local dealer has 2 on the lot right now. I live in a small city surrounded by much larger ones. We don't have some exceptional line on new Toyotas.
- bombcar 3y agoHave you gone in to buy one? They often show as "available" on the website but have been spoken for months/years ago. I was in line for a Sienna for 20 months before I finally bailed.
- frumper 3y agoI drive by the dealer everyday. 2 currently there. Personally, I've found dealers don't honor lines. One salesman told me that when they got the car I was looking for in stock they start calling people and the first person to physically show up AND sign the sales papers gets it. I ordered a Tesla after that experience.
- bombcar 3y agoYeah, dealers are notorious for "whatever gets me my cash". You could find those RAV4s here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12fx6j51iiA7q1Wm3keDun6jOlMwK5ZOf/edit?pli=1#gid=23203374 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12fx6j51iiA7q1Wm3keDu... (or the hybrid or prime) if you were bored. Often the manufacturers allocate vehicles to dealers on somewhat of a random lottery, so if you need one fast you're often best traveling to the dealer that's as far away from a big city as possible.
- caconym_ 3y ago> There is NOTHING preventing small SUVs that hold 5 people and cargo, get really good mileage, and are cheap(ish) - but they don't exist used because they don't exist new. How much cargo you want? I think the mid-size sector favorites (CR-V, RAV4, etc.) come pretty close to this, especially if you are willing to use a cargo box.
- bombcar 3y agoThe RAV4 looks big to me (almost minivan sized?) - but I see it's shorter than the Camry at least. I'm thinking of something more akin to the old hatchbacks, but that may be getting close. (Comparing the RAV4 to the Camry really shows the Camry's weaknesses, it's a bigger car with less room).
- caconym_ 3y agoBoth are IIUC substantially smaller than the typical minivan, and the recent CR-V redesign especially looks bigger than it is. Honda also has the HR-V, which is a smaller crossover thing with much stronger classic hatchback vibes; not sure if Toyota sells anything similar.
- wonderwonder 3y agoI got my Sienna about 3 years ago. 21k miles and paid $20k cash for it. It's got 40k miles now but seems like it's easily going to cruise for another 125k miles. I'll drive it until the kids are done with school so probably another 7 years. I work from home and the kids school is 3 blocks away so only real driving is to vacations. Besides the "cool factor" it's really the perfect vehicle.
- bombcar 3y agoYou got it at the perfect time, now they're impossible to find and cost $60k if you DO find one available.
- wonderwonder 3y agoyup, I really hit the jackpot on that. Timing wise, it cost me ~5k on my trade in but it was well worth it in the long run.