4 ms·
There wouldn't be nearly as much outrage if he were merely being prosecuted in the UK, which as you demonstrate, is entirely feasible. If the UK has criminal la
by mindslight 15y ago
There wouldn't be nearly as much outrage if he were merely being prosecuted in the UK, which as you demonstrate, is entirely feasible. If the UK has criminal laws banning offensive free speech (and from what I know of the UK, they probably do), and a UK citizen posts 'Fuck Muhammad' specifically directed at Arabic countries, he should not be extradited to said countries to be tried for blasphemy.
- tptacek 15y agoFirst, I am happy that the US does not have laws against offensive speech. Second: your analogy is imperfect. The defendant isn't charged with violating a UK/US law in the UK. He's charged with violating it in the US. Two sets of judges apparently considered the jurisdictional issue here and both concluded that the harm alleged occurred in the United States, and that O'Dwyer should therefore be tried in the United States.
- njs12345 15y agoIf it could be showed that most of the harm had occurred in Saudi Arabia and the conduct was also criminal in the UK, then it would be very similar to this case (such an extradition would be blocked for other reasons, but the question of forum is essentially the same). It's likely that he would be found innocent if tried in the UK, which is why people are quite angry about it. No successful prosecutions have ever been brought in the UK in similar cases and the CPS wasn't going to prosecute him here.
- mindslight 15y agoIn my analogy, the majority of harm (and intended harm) also occurs in the Arabic countries - outrage, unrest, mental anguish. Of course a judge came up with legal justification, otherwise there would be no extradition. That justification just happens to be dead wrong for the sake of convenience.
- tptacek 15y agoI'm not sure you've supported the latter argument, of "political convenience", with evidence.
- mindslight 15y agoThat wasn't intended to be a well-formed argument, but okay, I edited and removed 'political' - the judge may indeed have been personally looking for the best way to assure punishment. But make no mistake, courts gradually widen the concept of jurisdiction out of convenience. A court inherently assumes that it will always reach the correct decision, so choosing to decide on an issue causes it little philosophical burden (meanwhile, saying that one's self is irrelevant to a situation requires some pretty well thought out framing and justification). As a result, another unlucky sap is put through agony - even if they end up prevailing years later.
- tptacek 15y agoIf this was some random guy who poked at a website, found SQL injection, told the company, and then the company looked at the logs and found out that the guy had dumped their whole database (in the course of seeing whether the SQLI actually worked) and had the guy prosecuted for the equivalent of felony computer fraud or misuse, I'd sympathize. That actually happened. This actually happened too. What happened here is not so sympathetic. If you pull down 6 figures off pirated first-run movies and get an ICE site takedown, maybe not so much with the "putting the exact site back up on a different TLD with a fuck-you to the police on it", eh?
- mindslight 15y agoSympathetic? Not so much. But when a future plaintiff is looking to cite precedent, most likely their court isn't going to say "In that previous case, that guy was obviously guilty of something, so that decision was possibly made out of expedience and we're not going to use it". In fact, I'll go out on a limb and argue that a majority of rule-of-law-preserving precedents must be made when the defendant is/appears guilty - for if they appeared innocent, a court would probably find this by easier means rather than spending much effort nitpicking the procedural issues!
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoThe analogy is better than that. If the location a crime occurs is determined by where the browser is at, the reading "F*ck Muhamad" in an Arab country should make you subject to their laws. Even if it's only on .sa domains (if the US can claim jurisdiction over .com, certainly Saudi Arabia can claim it over .sa), that is a hugely dangerous precedent. I would not be complaining about extradition to Sweden, since that is where their business was located, but citizens of the world should not be subject to the capricious laws of the United States, just because they went online. As a US citizen, this disgusts me.
- tptacek 15y agoThe "capricious law" you're referring to here is nearly identical in the UK. Personally, the "offensive speech" argument 'mindslight brought up doesn't so much make me question extradition so much as it disquiets me about the idea of "offensive speech" laws. You can't be extradited from the US for saying "Fuck $RELIGOUS_FIGURE" because saying "Fuck $RELIGIOUS_FIGURE" simply isn't a crime here. We got that one right; the UK got it wrong. Note that UK laws restricting speech have been fig leaves for other politically-motivated legal proceedings; people in the UK have tried (and failed) to exploit the UK's libel laws to punish US speech they disagreed with. It is not particularly controversial in either the US or UK legislatures that running a 6 figure business on pirated first-run movies shouldn't be legal. I realize that it's controversial on message boards, but a lot of things are controversial on message boards that turn out not to be in the "big room". It was also controversial on Hacker News and Reddit that Hans Reiser was convicted on "circumstantial evidence".
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoFor the record, when I refer to capricious laws, I'm discussing from the viewpoint of people outside the US who, even though they may be doing things legally in their country, are suddenly at the whim of the US government. Certainly, O'Dwyer should be subject to UK laws. I have no problem with his arrest. I have a problem with his extradition, which, given he could be prosecuted at home, one can only guess is happening because the penalties are so much more severe in the US. Why take an ounce of flesh when you can get a pound...and show the world which government is really in charge.
- Natsu 15y ago> alleged occurred in the United States, and that O'Dwyer should therefore be tried in the United States. It occurred on the internet, so it occurred everywhere, not just in the US or the UK, but in every place that accessed the internet. I see no more reason that he ought to be subject to US law than that web programmer ought to be subject to Iranian law. There is great danger in making us subject to every country's law, which is what this effectively does. Sure, they did it because the sentence is much harsher in the US, but that doesn't make things better. Or let me put this another way: if the US forces Canada to pass strong anti-circumvention laws (note: they have been lobbying for such) and those happen to somehow criminalize security research that you did, would you be happy to get shipped off to a foreign country over it?
- tptacek 15y agoI can't be shipped to a foreign country for circumventing copy protection because I don't do it commercially and do it exclusively for interoperability and security research, which are exceptions to the anti-circumvention laws we have in the US. On the other hand, Canadians for years flaunted a loophole in Canadian/US law to sell DirecTV circumvention hardware to US customers. Message board geeks the world over said, "those are just signals traveling through the air! Signals traveling through the air can't be anyone's property!" I guess I have a hard time arguing with that point, but I don't lose sleep over not taking those people seriously. Reminder: we're discussing a guy who made six figures running a website specifically designed and intended to get people to pirated first-run movies. Sorry, but the distinction between "links" and "actual media frames" is not an important one in UK law or US law. Nobody is being extradited for links on their Tumblr pages.
- Natsu 15y agoThose are only exceptions in the US. The USTR has been pushing other countries to make their laws even stronger than ours. Then they do the two-step and push to strengthen our laws to match. Please note that I'm not arguing that this is some kind of abuse of process. If anything, I'm worried because it's perfectly normal and that will make reform that much more difficult.
- quattrofan 15y agoThe problem is we have repeatedly had spineless and useless knee jerk Home Secretaries and Teresa May sadly is no different. If the US asks us to jump we merely ask "how high" and sell out our citizens rights.