8 ms·
>I still run an i7-3770k in my homelab ... The best part is that I got it at a university surplus sale for $60 If you don't care about energy efficiency or it'
by FirmwareBurner 3y ago
>I still run an i7-3770k in my homelab ... The best part is that I got it at a university surplus sale for $60
If you don't care about energy efficiency or it's dirt cheap where you live then that's fine, but FWIW a modern 12th gen Intel Alder-Lake N100 NUC clone with quad E-cores[1] will smoke that, at 180 Euros with a TDP of only 10W, and at EU energy prices, the energy savings will make up the extra cost.
I get and support the whole reuse/repair/recycle mantra, but just like with daily driving old cars, at some point it's worth letting them go and upgrading your daily driver to something new and efficient which you can also reuse/repair/recycle, as it's just not worth daily driving in 2023 anymore such old gas-guzzling tower PCs with old CPUs that consume ~95W just to offer less than half of the performance of a modern smartphone[2][3] except for bragging rights online on who has the oldest ruining CPU, or if you don't care about your energy usage.
For example, a modern CPU encoding/decoding a video stream would use way less power thanks to its newer video decoder/encoder hardware IP blocks than a very old CPU going on full blast to SW decode/encode the video stream. The differences can be staggering.
So, while the anecdatas of "lookatme, I'm still using an ancient CPU and it works great" are fun, there's a balance where you need to think how much of the environment and money would I be saving by keeping using very old hardware instead of throwing it away, and how much would I be saving by upgrading to something much more efficient and using that for longer with the same reuse/repair/recycle mantra, as at some point the balance always tips to the latter.
[1] https://www.amazon.de/-/en/gp/product/B0BWLV6CK4/ https://www.amazon.de/-/en/gp/product/B0BWLV6CK4/
[2] https://browser.geekbench.com/processors/intel-core-i7-3770k https://browser.geekbench.com/processors/intel-core-i7-3770k
[3] https://browser.geekbench.com/v6/cpu/2179368 https://browser.geekbench.com/v6/cpu/2179368
- supertrope 3y agoAt $0.12/kWh 1W 24/7/365 costs $1/year. Assuming you don't use sleep mode and/or wake on LAN dropping down from 50W to 10W will save $40/year. On the environmental virtue side electronics have embodied energy usage that can surpass the lifetime electrical consumption especially if the devices are not always on.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIf you read my comment again, I specifically singles out the EU energy proces because I knew North America has much cheaper electricity which is why I specified if you have cheap energy then it probably won't matter for you. And Europeans are definitely feeling the CoL increase.
- supertrope 3y agoRight. It seems paradoxical to save money by spending money on new machines. Versus low hanging fruit like turning off or sleeping unused nodes or taking a hard look at your computing footprint and downsizing.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIt's not paradoxical to buy a CPU that's 5x more efficient.
- throwawaylinux 3y agoWhether it is a net win for energy consumption entirely what you're using it for and how the entire power profile of the system looks, not just the CPU and not just at full power. If it uses as much or more power when busy and you're just using it to push more frames in a video game, you're probably not going to singlehandedly bring about the next ice age. Same if the low utilization system power is similar and you spend most of the time messing around on the internet or editing code occasionally punctuated by a compile job, even if that does run faster.
- userbinator 3y agoThe new crap is more user-hostile and loses backwards compatibility. I'm not enticed by efficiency or environmental virtue signaling. As the saying in the car enthusiast community goes: "It's not about the miles per gallon, it's the smiles per gallon."
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoIn what way is it user hostile? Backwards compatibility to what, MS-DOS? People usually complain about forward compatibility regarding TPM, never had any issues with backwards compatibility on the last chips. How is more money in your pocket virtue signaling?
- Tool_of_Society 3y agoMy i7-3770 system I mentioned in another post here pulls 100 watts from the wall with p95 and furmark running everything at 100%. When actually gaming it's usually under 90 watts.... My old fx6300 system though pulled +250 watts just existing lol. When I was running the stack of SFF business machines I was using vastly more power to cool the room than I was to power the machines.
- whalesalad 3y agoheh… next to this tower PC is a rack loaded with networking gear and 2x maxed out R720 machines with redundant 1100w power supplies. My electrical bill is around $100/mo.
- helf 3y ago[dead]
- Dalewyn 3y ago>old CPUs that consume ~100W Sandy Bridge consumes that much at full load, but that can also be said of current gen processors (which incidentally usually go even higher). At idle or low load, Sandy Bridge is plenty economical just sipping power. These aren't Pentium 4s which guzzle power like it's draining Texas of its all its oil even at idle. My Sandy Bridge i7 2700K is sipping 10W at idle/low load right now, and that's actually lower than my Alder Lake i7 12700K that's sipping 15W at idle/low load. At high loads they go up to 95W and 150W respectively, which still comes out in favor of Sandy Bridge.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>At idle or low load, Sandy Bridge is plenty economical just sipping power. "Sipping power" is a bit of an overstatement. Sure, at 35W idle, they were very lower for the time but modern <10nm monolithic die CPUs are way more economically than the older 32nm, 22nm, and 14nm CPUs though. That can't be argued. A 12th Gen quad core NUC CPU will use at full load what Sandy Bridge quad core uses at idle, while also getting better performance. There's just no comparison.
- vel0city 3y agoI've got an Ivy Bridge quad core system in my closet that my UPS states is currently using ~15W of power with a few HDDs in it and an extra NIC as well. 35W idle CPU usage is thoroughly incorrect.
- SomeRndName11 3y agoWhere do you get this number 35W from? My Ivy Bridge 3470 idles at 7 watt (cpu only). Most of energy is consumed by the monitor anyway (20-25 Watt) anyway, so the energy savings are minuscule.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Where do you get this number 35W from? A google search on benchmarks and tests.
- kiririn 3y agoHardware video encoding is a poor example as it is typically lower quality than software for a given bitrate
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoMaybe, but you get the point on energy efficiency though , no need to go into semantics of encoder quality as that was not the point, just an example off the top of my head that resonated with my anecdotes when i upgraded from a Core 2 Duo. Even with SW only workloads, just look at the geekbench scores I posted. If a 2W smartphone SoC can offer over 2x the performance of a 95W chip, then it's bit outdated and energy inefficient and maybe time to upgrade to something better and more energy efficient, unless you're tryin to compete in the "who has the most gas-guzzling terminal/youtube machine" competition.
- vel0city 3y ago> a 2W smartphone SoC can offer over 2x the performance of a 95W chip 2x performance in some very specific and narrow benchmark tasks.
- superkuh 3y agoExactly. If you have the latest and greatest mobile phone and 8GB (or 12GB) of LPDDR5 on a Snapdragon 8 Gen 2 soc you still only have 8.5 Gbps memory bandwith (max, less in actual phones running it at slower speeds). That's 1 GB/s. An ivy bridge i5 3570k has a memory bandwidth of 25 GB/s. Even an ancient Core 2 Duo has 5GB/s memory bandwidth at stock speeds. Phones are very bad at computing tasks outside of "watching video" "buying things online" and the like.
- kcb 3y agoSomething is really off with your calculations. High-end Snapdragon chips are running with at least 64-bit busses, combined with the clock speed advantages LPDDR5 should put it well ahead of any 128-bit DDR3 system. At least 50GB/s. The real reason phones are bad at computing tasks is they throttle when put under any sustained load.
- letrowekwel 3y agoYeah it all depends from how much you actually use the machine, My old i7 gaming system runs maybe 7 hours a week on average. I drive barely 10k kilometers a year with my old ICE car. Upgrading to a new gaming PC and Tesla would make neither economic or environmental sense.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoYes, that's exactly why I emphasized "daily driver" like 3-4 times in my argument. If you hava a gas guzzling gaming PC that you use rarely because your daily driver is an M1 or ARM tablet, then that inefficient PC doesn't make a difference. My point was only if these old PCs are daily driven on a daily basis as workhorse machines, then the lack of efficiency becomes an sensible issue.
- NullPrefix 3y agothe term daily driver says nothing about the overall distance. It only describes the frequency
- vladvasiliu 3y ago> For example, a modern CPU encoding/decoding a video stream would use way less power thanks to its newer video decoder/encoder hardware IP blocks than a very old CPU going on full blast to SW decode/encode the video stream. The differences can be staggering. Is that the case for Teams / Zoom & friends, which are what I'd expect to be the most common video decode/encode uses? I'm expecting my 11th gen i7 laptop to become airborne any day now, with the kind of noise it makes on Teams calls. Anecdotally, my personal zen3u laptop does seem to unload video decoding to the GPU when watching movies, but it still gets fairly warm. > If you don't care about energy efficiency or it's dirt cheap where you live then that's fine, but FWIW a modern 12th gen Intel Alder-Lake N100 NUC clone with quad E-cores[1] will smoke that On what do you base this? I've never tried the N100 NUC, but some i5 12th gen with 2 P cores and I forget how many E-cores in a laptop. Compiling Rust, it was comparable to my older gen laptop with the 11th gen i7. Now this is an "U" part in an ultra book, but it's barely faster than a 2013 MBP with an i7, which, if I'm not mistaken, is a 3rd gen core "H" part.
- tuatoru 3y ago> there's a balance where you need to think how much of the environment and money would I be saving by keeping using very old hardware instead of throwing it away, ... maybe? Think global. Making CPUs uses an amazing amount of power in making the metallurgical silicon, refining to poly silicon, refining it again to semiconductor grade, refining it again, and then the whole slice polish lithography chain. All of that is still coal powered. And the chemicals used, and the byproducts created in the chemical manufacture and use, and the amazing quantities of water that are used in the earlier steps of the chain. Unless you're getting your electricity by burning rainforests, it seems better for the environment to avoid causing new chips to be made, by continuing to use old ones.
- ComodoHacker 3y agoYour points are valid, but we also have to factor in the amount of electricity consumed by gen X chip vs gen X+1 chip to perform certain amount of computing during their lifetime.
- causality0 3y agoAlso don't forget the amount of energy required to deliver it to your house, and the fact that energy is probably more carbon-intensive than the energy powering your old CPU.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Unless you're getting your electricity by burning rainforests, it seems better for the environment to avoid causing new chips to be made, by continuing to use old ones. You're also paying for the extra electricity the old CPU uses out of your pocket, plus the extra time it takes to finish certain tasks, lowering your productivity loosing you money. If you value energy efficiency and productivity, you can upgrade and flip the old CPU on the second hand market to someone for whom the energy efficiency and productivity gains are less important than using an old cheap CPU instead of buying a new expesnive one. Win-win.
- Panzer04 3y agoThe price of a new processor readily embodies the energy used to create it (by a significant margin, because of all the other stuff that needs to be paid for by the price of the processor) It's a very safe bet that, assuming you do significant work with the processor, that a modern processor will more than make up for its inefficiency.