3 ms·
20 years isn’t that long. The point of patents is to quickly get secrets out into the public while still incentivizing people to make them known. In this case
by Retric 3y ago
20 years isn’t that long. The point of patents is to quickly get secrets out into the public while still incentivizing people to make them known.
In this case this tiny company doesn’t have the resources to optimize production and has failed for years. They might eventually receive outside funding and figure it out, but they could also fail without releasing their secrets as has happened a few times.
- mort96 3y ago[flagged]
- Retric 3y agoMany ways of getting around patents, and if they can’t companies still need to sell the stuff to profit here. So the world would get room temperature superconductors if it works. 20 years really isn’t that long and more importantly it doesn’t prevent doing research or building assembly lines or customers designing systems to use the stuff. Nobody could start building assembly lines today, so the difference isn’t even close to the full 20 years here. If LK-99 pains out they might profit from it for a decade or so while still actually manufacturing the stuff. But, the best case is companies perfecting their process and taking orders so they can start shipping on day 1 after it expires.
- dkqmduems 3y agoBy all means, close your eyes.
- codedokode 3y agoAs I understand, you don't have to disclose secrets when filing a patent. You can describe the process in general terms and omit important formulas, quantities of different materials etc.
- Retric 3y agoThe more you omit the less protection you receive. There’s many approaches to getting around patents and they generally work really well if you’re vague.
- wongarsu 3y agoRevealing secrets is kind of the entire point of the patent: you tell everyone how it's done, in return you get 20 years monopoly. US patents even have a "best mode" requirement where you have to describe the best way known to you right now, where many other countries allow you to describe an inferior version and still get full protection. In reality you can get patents granted that are somewhat vague. It's not like the patent office actually tests if the patent text is sufficient to replicate your invention.