Both review and replication has their place. The mistake is treating researchers and the scientific community as a machine: "pull here, fill these forms, commen

Both review and replication has their place. The mistake is treating researchers and the scientific community as a machine: "pull here, fill these forms, comment this research, have a gold star" Let people review what they want, where they want, how they want. Let people replicate when they find interesting and motivating to work on.