3 ms·
> this is an interesting result in philosophy of physics, not in physics. Yes. Although it has consequences. It's a demonstration that some physical variables
by Animats 3y ago
> this is an interesting result in philosophy of physics, not in physics.
Yes. Although it has consequences. It's a demonstration that some physical variables have to be quantized or probabilistic to avoid divide by zero errors in reality.
This becomes clear when you do idealized Newtonian physics with impulses.
An impulse is an infinite force applied over zero time with finite energy transfer. That's not something that can exist in the physical universe.
It's just asking for divide by zero problems. It's also why impulse-constraint physics engines for games have some rather strange semantics.
- Cushman 3y agoIndeed. Bittersweet consequences, I’ve always thought, since it implies we wasted centuries recording empirical data that didn’t add up, while pure logical coherence was pointing straight at quantization and a universal speed limit. Modern philosophers are (obviously?) most interested in how this historical fact should affect our handling of, say, our current best model for QG. That’s a fascinating thing for lay people to ponder, which is one reason I wish the context weren’t so opaque to HN. (I should caveat that I’m less familiar with the “history of philosophy of science” side of this— there may be a live debate as to whether this would obtain with the logic Newton himself had access to, for example.)