3 ms·
That's the bullshit part of the article. Cement in an uncontrolled environment is not going to work as a capacitor, even if it works in a controlled environment
by Animats 3y ago
That's the bullshit part of the article. Cement in an uncontrolled environment is not going to work as a capacitor, even if it works in a controlled environment. Some water will get in. There's expansion and contraction as temperature changes, which causes cracking. The road battery idea belongs in the same category as the road and sidewalk generator idea [1][2], which, in the end, was just an advertising stunt.[3]
The paper jumps directly from showing a tiny effect in a tiny sample to changing the world. This seems to be a disease of battery-related articles.
Also, cement is not the same as concrete. Concrete contains cement as a binder, but is mostly sand and rock. It also absorbs water, which is kind of a problem for a capacitor.
[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0306261917311108 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03062...
[2] https://cait.rutgers.edu/generating-power-every-time-you-hit-the-road/ https://cait.rutgers.edu/generating-power-every-time-you-hit...
[3] https://www.archdaily.com/911965/sidewalks-that-generate-energy-through-the-steps https://www.archdaily.com/911965/sidewalks-that-generate-ene...
- internetter 3y agoTouché. I guess I'm cautiously optimistic that it can scale (goodness we need good news), but you bring up plenty of valid points. Thanks for putting me in my place.
- rewmie 3y ago> Cement in an uncontrolled environment is not going to work as a capacitor, even if it works in a controlled environment. Some water will get in. Concrete always has water. It's part of it's composition. What exactly led you to believe it doesn't? Also, there's a technology that can turn concrete waterproof which is called paint. In harsh environments it's also mundate to coat rebar with epoxy paints to protect against corrosion. > There's expansion and contraction as temperature changes, which causes cracking. Thermal stress in monolithic structures does not cause cracking. At best, it can happen in hyper static structures when thermal strain imposes displacements beyond design limits. This is countered by using technologies such as prestress. What can cause cracking in concrete is delamination from frosting, where water penetrating through pores expands and detaches concrete blades at the surface. This is prevented by applying a technology called paint. I saw nothing in your comment that put into question the usage of concrete-based super capacitors. You pointed to known failure modes that are addressed in a very mundane way.