4 ms·
Person A, a waitress at Dennys, making about $8-10/hour with high deductible health care. Person B, an auto worker at GM, making $30-40/hour with zero deductib
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
Person A, a waitress at Dennys, making about $8-10/hour with high deductible health care.
Person B, an auto worker at GM, making $30-40/hour with zero deductible health care.
[edit: see response to this post, auto worker gets $73/hour.]
The bailout: tax person A in order to help person B, with 3 large corporations taking a cut of the proceeds. Does this make any sense?
Incidentally, the original poster did not describe union workers as either lazy or overpaid.
[edit: forgot to mention, it's actually very likely that the waitress does not pay taxes at all. So more realistically, the waitress should be replaced by someone in the $20/hour neighborhood.]
- mattmaroon 18y agoThe problem is that person A doesn't pay any taxes. You're certainly taxing some people to pay for it, but it's not person A. Also, the idea behind bailouts like this is that they are a loan. Ideally the government is profiting from this sort of thing, especially when you consider the overall economic impact of laying off thousands of GM employees, or allowing thousands of pensions to swirl down the drain. I'm against the bailout, but it's overly simplistic and entirely useless (not to mention just plain incorrect) to say that it's morally wrong because someone at Denny's doesn't have health care.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoHeh, I noticed that (and edited my post to reflect it), apparently while you were writing your post. However, there are plenty of people who make less money than auto workers who do pay taxes. One reason the bailout is morally wrong is that it is a regressive tax. It takes from the (relatively) poor and gives to the (relatively) rich.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWell, a very high % of taxes come from either businesses or people who make more than the average GM worker. Plus a $25 billion dollar loan to GM isn't the same thing, from the taxpayers perspective, as giving them $25 billion. Presumably it will be paid back with interest. Of course, it won't get as much interest as people could earn investing their own money in the private sector, or they'd all be buying GM bonds already, but the actual loss is orders of magnitude less than $25 billion. I don't think there's a lot of moral hazard there in terms of taking from the poor and giving to GM workers. The real issue is whether it's better for everyone involved than just allowing them to restructure in bankruptcy. I can't see how the answer to that could be yes.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoWhy do you think GM will survive long enough to pay us back?
- mattmaroon 18y agoI don't unless the loan comes with conditions ensuring that, which is why I'm against it. I'm just pointing out that the issue isn't as simple as its being made to sound.
- ensignavenger 18y agoAre you saying that it is morally wrong to take money from relatively rich people to give to relatively poor, but not the other way around? I think any (Government) wealth redistribution is morally wrong, but that's just my 2 cents!
- mattmaroon 18y agoGovernment cannot exist without redistributing wealth. You've been listening to too many Palin rallies. Every time a government changes tax rates, wealth gets redistributed. Every time it builds a school or a road, wealth is redistributed. Every economic policy redistributes wealth. I hope the I just redistributed your 2 cents :)
- astine 18y agoI think that he means explicit wealth redistribution. If government uses your tax money to to finance the police system, sure it is moving wealth around, but a healthy police is necessary for a free society and functioning economy, so in the end, everyone benefits. This is different from just taking from one group and giving to another.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWell, if the government takes some tax money and uses that to prop up an industry that directly or indirectly employs 6 million people, that too helps everyone. Those people while employed buy things, pay taxes, don't create an oversupply of workers that lowers wages for everyone, etc. It's not as cut and dry as some Robinhoodesque vision of taking taxes from some and giving to another, which McCain and Palin wanted you to believe. It's quite possible that the $25 billion loaned will not only return the taxpayers more than $25 billion directly, but also create a net positive economic impact of more than that.
- astine 18y agothat too helps everyone - no it doesn't; not in the long run. I honestly don't know what McCain & Palin have been saying about this (nor do I care) but corporate welfare undermines accountability at the corporate level. Accountability is absolutely essential to functioning of the market and handouts such as these have been undermining the US auto industry since the fifties. This is a very large part of the reason that they are in trouble today. If we are concerned about the employees, we should just give them the money directly, but giving the money to the corporate execs is essentially rewarding bad behavior and staving off the inevitable. Corporate handouts are like stimulants for the economy; they provide a short-term high, but they will be followed by a corresponding low and the longer you prolong treatment, the longer and more powerful the low. BTW a labor surplus isn't necessarily so bad a thing; employment for the sake of employment is almost as bad an economic policy as corporate welfare (It's one of the more obvious failures of the New Deal.) and if the big three are no longer profitable, that is what this bailout amounts to.
- ckinnan 18y agoActually the average UAW salary is around $73 an hour. But the executives are far worse and totally undeserving of any taxpayer help: "While Uncle Sam debates a $25 billion rescue for the country's automakers, some 9,000 GM managers continue to enjoy one of the industry's best perks - a new car every six months for $250 a month, with repairs and insurance included. And they can write off gas on their expenses." http://www.nypost.com/seven/11182008/news/politics/gm_honchos_easy_perking_139245.htm http://www.nypost.com/seven/11182008/news/politics/gm_honcho...
- jmtulloss 18y agoCan you site that $73/hour wage? A cursory glance around the internet indicated something around $30/hr as of last year. The only places I saw $73 were other forums, but maybe they all have a common, legit source.
- rms 18y agoI believe that $73/hour number includes all executive pay and obviously is an average chosen to misrepresent information. The average assembly line worker wage (and the median wage) is closer to $30.
- Prrometheus 18y agoI have seen the $73/hr number cited as non-executive compensation. That's total compensation, not just wages, which covers the cost of benefits and the like. edit: This has some links: http://mjperry.blogspot.com/2008/11/should-we-really-bail-out-7320-per-hour.html http://mjperry.blogspot.com/2008/11/should-we-really-bail-ou...
- mdasen 18y agoI cannot say what the previous person was referencing, but NPR has a great comparison of GM and Toyota at http://www.npr.org/news/specials/gmvstoyota/ http://www.npr.org/news/specials/gmvstoyota/ If you read the list, it looks like you're both (partially) correct. The average hourly salary for non-skilled assembly-line workers is a little over $31. However, GM's labor cost per hour exceeds $73/hour for those workers. So, in terms of GM's costs, it's over $73/hour. I'm guessing the UAW has structured it in a way that benefits the employees, but I can't imagine what benefits would be worth more than my salary. Seems to me like more in salary and less in benefits would appeal to me more.
- crabapple 18y agowhat about person C - a nonunion honda plant employee. he has beaten the competition fair and square, and now he must subsidize them. perversely, the harder he works, the more money he can potentially contribute to a government underwriting his competition.
- ensignavenger 18y agoPerson A might very well pay taxes, if they are a single individual with no children. They don't pay a lot of income tax, but they likely do pay some.
- newsycaccount 18y agoThe education person A's kids get along with the disproportionate share of SS/medicare benefits they get already mean they net gain from the tax system. So it is hardly fair to say: >The bailout: tax person A in order to help person B At least pick a person A who is net-net being taxed.