5 ms·
Suppose you don't have enough money to buy real estate right now but you have enough to rent an apartment. If you don't want to be homeless, from whom do you ac
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
Suppose you don't have enough money to buy real estate right now but you have enough to rent an apartment. If you don't want to be homeless, from whom do you acquire a lease?
- th0ma5 3y agoIf rent was illegal, you would buy.
- readthenotes1 3y agoBuy what? If rent were illegal, there would be far less housing because most people cannot (or will not) save enough capital to create or buy their own.
- th0ma5 3y agoYou need to challenge your assumptions more, why couldn't you just make single family dwellings illegal in high demand areas? And have the state in charge of housing? Unless you mean to argue about current laws and situations, the main point of these discussions and this post is that they are not working.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe existing problem is that multi-family dwellings are illegal in many high demand areas. Otherwise it would be highly profitable to build them there. If you fix that you don't need to do anything else. Putting the state in charge of housing is the cause of the existing problem. They become captured by landlords, or favor higher property values because they increase property tax revenues. What you need is some constitutional restraint on local zoning rules.
- th0ma5 3y agoWhy isn't more regulation the answer? If children misbehave at school we don't give them more freedom. There are widely published opinions that state this just makes landlords richer and housing rarer to further deregulate.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIn general competitive pressure makes things better. If you can choose between two things that are similar but one costs less, you can save money. If they cost the same but one is better, you can choose the better one. The easier it is for you to switch, the less the provider can get away with before you do. Governments have weak competitive pressure. You have to uproot your whole life and move to another jurisdiction. When you vote, you're making a choice about every issue under the sun at once and it's impossible to change your vote on only one issue by itself. You can also easily end up "represented" by the candidate you voted against. As a result they're extremely inefficient by default and should only be used when the alternative is catastrophic. This is doubly true in markets that could be competitive, because the incumbents have the incentive to use the government to reduce competition so they make more money. The obviously relevant example is zoning rules that restrict housing supply. It's critical to not allow that to happen, or to undo it when it already has. Trying to cancel it out with even more regulations is just another opportunity for incumbents to sneak in some new way of screwing you. When you screw up a market this badly, people get desperate and angry and start proposing all kinds of aggressive "solutions" because they fail to understand the cause of the problem but want something done about it. The most ridiculous of these are generally filtered out, but the ones that make it through are the ones that don't work or make it worse because those are the ones the incumbents fight the least. You have to fight the cause of the problem, which is a government captured by land owners imposing rules that make housing more expensive. The solution is to remove those rules. > There are widely published opinions that state this just makes landlords richer and housing rarer to further deregulate. One of the main reasons "deregulation" has a bad name is that its purpose is to increase competition and lower prices, which is exactly the thing the incumbents don't want, so instead they propose a "compromise" that prevents exactly the thing you're trying to get. For example, suppose you have two rules. One says that new housing construction is utterly prohibited, the other says that all rental properties must have working plumbing. In a competitive market the second rule is inefficient because all it really does is prohibit anyone from offering a storage unit with no plumbing. There would be enough apartments with running water that nobody would have any reason to consider one that didn't. But in a market where increasing the housing supply is inhibited, there are more tenants than rental units and that allows abusive slumlords to find tenants willing to live under such conditions. Much "deregulation" is the corruption in which you only remove the second rule and not the first, which of course makes things worse, because the first one is the one that matters and the second one is just an inefficient attempt to mitigate the damage. Increase the housing supply until rents go down. Accept no substitutes.
- pandaman 3y ago>The existing problem is that multi-family dwellings are illegal in many high demand areas This is technically correct but the areas mentioned are the size of a block or a subdivision so it's hardly the limiting factor. You can build high rise apartments in any big city and multi-family anywhere. The reason prices on housing go up is that it costs a lot to build housing and it's pretty hard to secure financing for a housing project which you plan to sell/rent below cost. It's combined code compliance, materials, labor, and financing. If it costs $300 to build a square foot just in the labor and materials then it comes up at $150K for a tiny 500 sqf 1br and you'd need to rent that for more than $2000 per month to break even on the commercial loan you took. Throw in maintenance, lapses in occupancy and some profit and you are looking at close to $3K for a 500 sqf 1br. Unless it's on Manhattan or on an ocean beach somewhere, it's going to be very hard to find tenants. It appears that America had ran up its credit card to the limit. Mass produced goods from China are still cheap but the hoses are just expensive, can't ship those in containers from Shenzhen. Playing with zoning is rearranging chairs on the deck of Titanic, it's not going to lower the cost of construction. And yes, adding more housing would lower the price but the problem is that adding housing is held up by the cost mostly and the developers only want to build in very limited prestigious areas where they hope to get tenants/buyers willing to pay their cost. It's not sustainable.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> You can build high rise apartments in any big city and multi-family anywhere. You can't build them except in the places they already are. Converting existing high density housing to even higher density housing is prohibitively expensive. What you need to do is go to the edge of the high density area where it meets the low density area and convert the low density housing to high density. But that area is only zoned for low density, so you can't. > The reason prices on housing go up is that it costs a lot to build housing and it's pretty hard to secure financing for a housing project which you plan to sell/rent below cost. Who is requiring them to sell below cost? Just build more housing at the market rate as long as the market rate is above your construction costs. If you want a lower market rate, find a way to lower construction costs. > If it costs $300 to build a square foot But what causes that?
- UncleEntity 3y ago> ...why couldn't you just make single family dwellings illegal in high demand areas? Because this isn't how things work in civil society. They can't just decree that all single family homes in San Jose are now illegal and you have to vacate by the end of the month.
- th0ma5 3y agoI guess you remind me of imminent domain, and the also other legal and not so legal ways people manipulate property values like cash for houses signs.
- readthenotes1 3y ago"why couldn't you just make single family dwellings illegal in high demand areas? And have the state in charge of housing? " Because I've seen Soviet era housing and War on Poverty projects. Challenge my assumptions? I think the burden is on you to show that somehow next time will be different
- breakyerself 3y agoLandlords are the reason housing is unaffordable, but in a world without landlords if homeownership is out of reach for a segment of the population there should be public housing to accommodate that need.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Landlords are the reason housing is unaffordable Zoning laws are the reason housing is unaffordable. Landlords lobby for zoning laws, but if you have the political power to prohibit renting then presumably you have the political power to reform zoning. Moreover, you should do that anyway, because if all you do is prohibit renting without allowing new housing to be built, you're going to have a bad time. > if homeownership is out of reach for a segment of the population there should be public housing to accommodate that need. So if you make 110% of the median income but don't have a downpayment yet the government pays for your housing? Do you get free housing forever as long as you spend everything you make and never save anything up? What if you have plenty of money but you know you're not going to be somewhere for more than two years and don't want to buy property there?
- sharts 3y agoIn the end it’s really supply/demand. Perhaps there need to be quotas on how much population can be in the city at any given time. Added benefit would be less traffic, congestion, and waiting in lines for anything
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoRestricting demand is inhumane. Increase supply.
- Duwensatzaj 3y agoWrong. Housing is unaffordable because demand outstrips supply. Economic illiterates who blame “greed” making public policy tend to make it even worse.
- monkaiju 3y agoFor the landloard to make money your rent is higher than what it takes to 'own' the land, usually in the form of a mortgage. Otherwise its almost always a second (or third) plot that is outrightly owned by the landlord, which means they dont need it and itd be better for you to just be able to buy it. Also the even better answer is public housing.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> For the landloard to make money your rent is higher than what it takes to 'own' the land, usually in the form of a mortgage. The landlord can make money by investing capital and then getting a return equivalent to the interest you'd pay to the bank to borrow that amount of money. > Otherwise its almost always a second (or third) plot that is outrightly owned by the landlord, which means they dont need it and itd be better for you to just be able to buy it. But you can buy it. You just go to the owner and buy it from them. What are you supposed to do if you can't afford that right now?