4 ms·
Immune cells fighting cancer get exhausted within hours of encountering tumors
- dillydogg 3y agoI'm an immunologist and I honestly can't stand tumor immunology. I'm glad there are people studying it of course, but it seems impossible to actually perform a reasonable experiment. Tumor immunologists are so obsessed with the tumor microenvironment and tumor resident immune cells and all of these other cell types that are totally messed up in cancer. We don't even know how these cells work when they are operating perfectly! I wish there was more funding for immunology outside of the context of cancer, but I find it reasonable that this isn't the case.
- dillydogg 3y agoOh, to add, I think this is pretty interesting given my aversion to tumor immunology. I've seen trends in the field about changing the definition of what an exhausted cell is. I haven't read the primary research but they allude to using sequencing based approaches which are cool/more sophisticated compared to previous surface marker ones.
- darkclouds 3y ago> We don't even know how these cells work when they are operating perfectly! And this makes me think, will lab grown meat essentially be eating different types of animal cancers. I dont think you have the right tools, the upgraded/improved tools, like xrays and fMRI all generate new insights and from those insights come new theories. Which means superstitious miracles still happen because science cant explain it.
- tomohelix 3y agoWell both cancer and lab meats are infinitely dividing so in some sense they are similar. But from what I know, lab meat are made so that they can't support their own growth. They need specific media and nutrients and they are designed to not spontaneously mutate to leech these nutrients from other tissues, e.g. can form blood vessels. But, like they said, life find a way. BUT, the chances of eating lab meat and got cancer is probably lower than say, eating fried foods gives you cancer. So not an issue IMO. Breathing gives you cancer too
- darkclouds 3y agoWell the HeLa (Henrietta Lacks) cells are maintained in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium (DMEM) and RPMI 1640 to pick a few media, but I've yet to be able to find out the media to grow lab meat. Anyone know? I'm sure its a business confidential media so I doubt it will be public knowledge which means I wont know if its got enough nutrition compared to traditionally organic grown meat or not. But sure its not aggressive at leeching nutrients from surrounding tissue like cancer.
- tomohelix 3y agoJust some rich media. But it is trivial to engineer the cells so that they require one or two special chemicals to survive. They can make it something exotic but harmless so that no way you can find anything close in the human body and still no concern about toxicity. In short, a dead switch to the cells once they are taken out of the special media to grow them.
- darkclouds 3y ago> and still no concern about toxicity The medical experts are still pushing folic acid and folates, and yet it becomes formaldehyde in the body, and formaldehyde was found in tobacco and thought to be one of the causes of lung cancer, and many mothers know the dangers of consuming too much folic acid during pregnancy, like impaired fetal growth, asthma and autism. So can we really trust the experts including govts and the WHO? But folic acid can keep anthrax at bay, so are smokers managing inhaled anthrax spores? In my opinion, one of the reasons why covid was released on the planet was to stimulate interest and growth for the PCR tests. Its useful for detecting pathogens in the body. They have been using PCR tests in the US to detect drug resistant nematodes (worms) in dogs for at least a decade now, and yet here in the UK, there appears to be nothing of the sort, according to Defra. Surprising how some first world countries appear so backwards in some areas. Not saying there are no pcr testing machines in the UK, just that there is no data for drug resistant nematodes in canines. The UK govt handling of the infected blood scandal is another example of poor management. Rather than use a US test, they did nothing until a UK test was developed, allowing people to die from crack pot theories dreamt up by doctors. So if you cant detect a pathogen, cancer or senescent cell in the body, how can it be treated? Thats seems to be the crux of science. I'm surprised they don't inject mercury into cancer tumours because mercury induces mitochondrial dysfunction and cancer cells do have mitochondria. But I dont want to sound too Trump-ist, even though its used in dental fillings and is particularly useful at killing syphilis. And when looking at cancer leeching nutrients from surrounding tissue, how is that any different to bacteria? They also need nutrients which they take from the body and they can still kill people, as can the benzene ring, a known carcinogen, found in antibiotics, suggesting heavy antibiotic use can cause or contribute to cancer and yet are also used in medicine. I find the history of cancer treatment in the US interesting, nicotinic acid aka sunburn effect vitamin B3 was the first chemo drug, dont know what the thinking was for using it, maybe it was the dna rebinding effect it has, or maybe the prostaglandin stimulation that was thought to be useful. But in the absence of explanations, I'm not inspired by the medical profession. https://www2.mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk/folate-and-formaldehyde-from-vitamin-to-genotoxin-to-dna-building-block https://www2.mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk/folate-and-formaldehyde-from-...
- yieldcrv 3y agoIt makes me wonder if there is an additional cell state or ailment that will only present itself after more cancers are suppressed more reliably. Like the cancer state is more than just an error, its a protection mechanism. Since cancer treatments never address the root cause of whats turning cells cancerous, only mitigating the presence and affects of how many cancerous ones there are. Right now, the additional state happens in too few survivors for anyone to notice. Like maybe the additional state its just as rare to further progress, and cancer often results in death. There doesn't have to be a meaning, I just wonder if there is and if it could change the approach to improve protecting the host and ensuring survival.
- im3w1l 3y agoThe cause is that DNA mutations makes the cells go "feral", and turn into a new mono-cellular species that invades the body. DNA can be damaged in several ways, by UV rays or mutagenic chemicals, but it can also happen during cell-division. Any type of damage, even micro damage, the body sustains means that cells have to start dividing to repair it. But cells also continuously divide to replace old ones even without damage. So all in all, it's just a matter of time until you get unlucky, something goes wrong and you have a cancer.
- yieldcrv 3y agoyes, but that’s not my observation unless it was intended to point out why its not worth speculating further.
- qbxk 3y agothe root cause is your immune system losing the war. there are always new cancers appearing in your body, most of them get caught and stopped by the system designed to do so.
- byteCoder 3y agoFrom my personal experience with advanced melanoma under a trial at NIH almost 12 years ago, Dr. Steven Rosenberg and his research team: 1. Surgically resected a tumor and removed the tumor attacking T cells in a lab, 2. expanded them in a lab to 130 billion, 3. returned them to me after making me immunosuppressed, and 4. kick started my new immune system with high-dose IL-2. Within three months, my tumors were essentially gone. I’ve been cancer-free since. It seems to me that the body doesn’t have enough of the right T cells to fight the mutated, cancerous cells.
- Confiks 3y agoWas your case publicized? [1] looks quite similar but is a case from two years earlier. Similar procedure? [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000649712031048X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000649712...
- byteCoder 3y agoThe protocol in linked study appears to be similar to the melanoma therapy I underwent at NIH, except for the CAR-T part. The study I was part of was published in a few papers, including: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6295669/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6295669/
- tomohelix 3y agoThat is why CAR-T and personalized medicine are some hot topics right now. Essentially, the best medicine and treatment we have often just expand or aid our own body capacity to fight back. Cancer is especially problematic because our body often refuses to fight it. Training an elite team of cellular terminators is the next step when the local forces are just not adequate anymore. But it is still so expensive.
- sufiyan 3y agoIs there some way to induce a cytokine storm of sorts so that this weakening is essentially reduced