6 ms·
Can focusing on class instead of race solve our country’s equity issues?
- alexnewman 3y agoCan we move beyond class and focus on how an individuals vision for the future can never provide what humans truely want… a collective vision for the future which preserves freedom and human dignity.
- balderdash 3y agoThat sounds nice, but effectively impractical
- alexnewman 3y agoWhy is it impractical? Seemed like America for a whole
- local_issues 3y agoYou are describing neoliberalism, the economic system which has lead to the most prosperity in human history.
- alexnewman 3y agoI thank you are thinking of the promise of liberalism. Neoliberalism is too new to suggest it lead to the prosperity in history, and it’s hard to point to the society that embraced it that did well especially well with it. However classical liberalism was rooted in g-d. I think modern thinking is rooted in marxist religion
- dragonwriter 3y agoNeoliberalism is a late 20th Century reactionary response in economic ideology against the continued progressive development of the modern mixed economy which generally replaced more pure capitalism from the mid-20th century. It is neither in itself an economic system, nor is it particularly responsible for prosperity (its responsible mainly for austerity).
- pseudocomposer 3y agoCorrelation is not causation.
- ashinybrowncoat 3y agoSo throw a couple extra bones to the poors and maybe the race thing will solve itself? Why tax the fucking rich? Academics and politicians need to change the message to simply that: tax the rich. You can't fix one extreme without addressing the opposite extreme, in this case. Tax the rich and less tax for the poor (everyone else).
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"Tax the rich and less tax for the poor" I could be wrong, but don't the poor pay very little tax anyways?
- prepend 3y agoYes and no. The “poor” may very little to no income tax. But the poor pay sales tax on almost everything they buy and that’s a flat 7-12% and so is really regressive. Although this is skipped for items paid for with government food assistance (eg, SNAP). And if you’re working poor (ie making $20k/year) you’re paying 7.5% in payroll taxes to cover social security and Medicare. This is also flat and so regressive. You certainly pay less percentage and less absolute taxes than the rich, but it’s still something. The challenge is that it’s hard to reduce these taxes any lower. Unless you want to change social security to a straight income redistribution program and not the pretend pension it is now and do something like the first $50k isn’t taxed and 10x the taxes on people from 50-200k (currently only 0-168k is taxed but almost half of people only make 50k so taking off the bottom drastically reduces tax revenue). Or you could remove sales tax on people who make less than $20k but that’s hard to monitor properly and rebates don’t help much with day to day needs. Tl:dr; the poor pay taxes, but not that much.
- hollerith 3y ago>the poor pay sales tax on almost everything they buy . . . Although this is skipped for items paid for with government food assistance (eg, SNAP). That is technically correct, but misleading, because even when it is not paid for by government food assistance, the sale of food is not taxed--at least, it is not in any of the 4 US states I've lived in.
- balderdash 3y agoThis is obviously a step in the right direction, but not a solution. However, I think Americans would be well served by reflecting on their their thoughts and feelings on the subject of race and introducing class to the conversation. It’s my experience that many Americans simply use race as a proxy for class, often incorrectly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gentleman11 3y agoI’ve been saying this for years, but it’s gradually become almost racist to imply that it isn’t racism that’s the biggest problem. People hate the lower class. Hate. Look at public policy, how people react to their presence, etc. Essential workers were basically human sacrifices. And you know who is poor and struggling? A population of former slaves in a country that hates poor people and doesn’t believe in helping them. Or a population that you deny legal rights to so that you can have cheap labor. Or even white trash, I mean, dress like a poor person and watch as staff follow you around while you shop. But yeah, racial groups like African Americans and Mexicans are poor for a reason and yeah people hate poor people
- LargeTomato 3y agoIt is absolutely considered racist to advocate for focusing on class instead of race. Try saying that in any group of millennial liberals and you will get an earful. It's very disappointing and politically unsavvy.
- shaunxcode 3y agoBecause it is reductive and unhelpful. What is happening now is called triage. Of course helping all of the wounded is the goal but you tend to those bleeding out before those suffering from slivers. To stand up in the ER and exclaim “but we are all suffering! We should all be helped at the same time!” is simply counter productive at best. It is absolutely important to spend time imagining solutions that could help change the system itself to prevent future suffering but to offer them to people directly engaged in immediate disaster response is not productive. To put this in nerd terms don’t be the guy who suggests switching to Haskell/pure FP as a solution to the problem you are debugging in a production legacy OO system that needs to be fixed immediately. Like logically and long term you are probably right but what was the point beside making you feel smug? Also: intersectionality.
- gedy 3y ago> helping all of the wounded is the goal but you tend to those bleeding out before those suffering from slivers. I think this shows your biases. As an example, at my previous company, I was the only one who had grown up on welfare, was a high school dropout, lived near a superfund site, etc. However, I’m an older, straight, white male, and the millennials I worked with were all from much more privileged economic backgrounds. But somehow it was okay by the company for them to make public statements such as “we need to quit hiring so many straight, white males", but bringing up class was inappropriate?
- water9 3y agoYes, but the real people that don’t want us to solve the race issues are the ones that keep pointing out our race base differences whenever they get the opportunity. That doesn’t mean I condone silent complicity in the act of hate, but rather seek to promote vocal Complicity in the spirit of unity. In today’s day and age, it’s pretty clear that red and blue is a bigger differentiator than white and black
- goodbyesf 3y agoNo. We are fundamentally a racist society, not a classist society. It was all blacks who were deemd 3/5th of a person. Not poor blacks. It was all native americans who were exterminated, not the poor natives. Our immigration bans throughout history have been along racial lines - Chinese Exlusion Act, Asian Exclusion Act, etc. Not poor chinese or asian exclusion act. Wealthy and poor jews were discriminated against by colleges around the country. So on and so forth. When's the last time you asked yourself 'What class person X belongs to.'? We think in terms of race and to a lesser extent religion. Besides, it's not an either-or situation. Why can't we address both racial and class issues?