3 ms·
Assuming centaur-dominance in the economy rather than pure-AI dominance, I can easily believe that we can work just as hard to produce 16x as much stuff — that'
by ben_w 3y ago
Assuming centaur-dominance in the economy rather than pure-AI dominance, I can easily believe that we can work just as hard to produce 16x as much stuff — that's the income disparity between normal Americans and the recent job posting for $900k in Netflix, implying normal people can be motivated by it, implying there's stuff to care about buying with it.
Steps up from that are plausible, but less certain. Do we all want personal pleasure yachts? Flights on a Dragon capsule or a Starship?
-
But there are too many paths the future might yet take for me to be confident of anything much.
If the AI are always narrow, but can be made superhuman for any given skill in 6 months, that has one set of issues; if they are fully human-like general but we never make them more than IQ 85 (plus access to whatever narrow AI exist by then that actual humans also use), that's a different set of issues; and that's just off the top of my head.
- glimshe 3y agoThe 900K salary isn't related to "producing more stuff", but is instead a way to acquire a very rare skill that would unblock their development (in their mind, obviously). It's basically trying to ensure they get this person away from whatever place or job they happen to be currently working in. If AI was able to empower many people with this skill, they wouldn't be paying anywhere near 900K by simple offer/demand.
- ben_w 3y agoThat's separate to my reason to use it as an example. So, I'm a very unusual person in that I can't be bothered to spend more than about €12k/year. The idea of owning most stuff just doesn't motivate me. I earn significantly more than €12k, because I think the immigration office wants me to, but I'm not motivated by it myself. If everyone was like me, most advanced economies would just collapse as everyone went down to 5-20 hours per week. The observation that the economies have not collapsed, demonstrates that most people do actually want to acquire stuff. The observation of a job offer for $900k strongly implies that there are people who are motivated to acquire $900k (less taxes) worth of stuff each year. From that it follows that at least some people will be motivated to work just as much as they currently do, in order to earn about 16x as much money, in order to spend it on 16x as much stuff. (16x is here an observation, not an upper limit).
- quonn 3y agoI think you‘re missing a few things: 1. Not everything is stuff. You can book a flight for 5000 Euros to the other end of the world. 2. Not all prices are the best. You might overpay significantly for said flight in order to not have to think about finding a cheaper one. Same for everything else, such as grocery shopping. 3. Housing. It‘s easy to imagine someone buying a house for 5 million. Depending on the location this may not even buy an _extremely_ fancy house. If you don‘t like debt and want to pay it down in 10 years then 900k (and what really remains of that? 400k?) might be useful. Even if you don‘t care about „stuff“. Maybe all you care about is not having to care about it.
- ben_w 3y agoNone of those matter, IMO. A flight ticket itself may be ephemeral, but the plane and the fuel are not. Overpaying for convenience becomes oversupply for convenience, which at the scale of "everyone gets it" requires massive overproduction. Houses will indeed always have a "location location location" premium; but the dynamics of this also changes if everyone has far more economic power — $900k is currently enough to commute by private plane, opening up many small places that are currently too out-of-the-way to get such attention, though I don't have any idea if that can actually scale given airport capacities and densities.
- xbmcuser 3y agoProduce 10x what exactly? Earth at current consumption level is not sustainable. where the fuck do you have the resources to produce 10x
- ben_w 3y agoWhich bits are and aren't sustainable depends mostly on tech. 10x solar power and we get meet all current electricity demand in a climate friendly way; 10x lithium etc. mining and we can roll out electric vehicles much faster; 10x bioreactors makes… well, very little difference to ethical eco-meat, but mainly because it's still new and the kinks have yet to be worked out, but the principal still applies. (Unfortunately, my point would still stand even if higher production only sped up disaster; the tragedy of the commons is because everyone is motivated to consume more than is sustainable given the size of the group).
- satvikpendem 3y agoWhy is it not sustainable? Are you talking about fossil fuel usage? Because that can be solved if we had the technology to solve it, via carbon capture, geoengineering, etc, via the help of AI even. The Earth is a massive planet relative to human scales, there are more abundant resources in it than we can use in a thousand lifetimes.
- raincole 3y agoIn theory the more productive we are the higher "upper bound of sustainability" is. Cheap energy can be used to recycle garbages from the ocean, recapture carbon from the atmosphere, etc. We just choose not to.
- PeterisP 3y agoFor a few decades already growth of consumption/GDP has been decoupled from growth of energy and resource usage. Roughly speaking, we consume more by consuming "better" things rather than "larger" things. A $1000 iPhone is much "more consumption" than a 1990s cell phone plus portable CD player plus a calculator, but takes less resources than those things. Even more so when consumption of digital entertainment replaces live entertainment.