2 ms·
There is no circumvention of the GPL going on, or any loophole in the license being exploited. It's basically "I'm only going to be your friend and provide you
by kazinator 3y ago
There is no circumvention of the GPL going on, or any loophole in the license being exploited.
It's basically "I'm only going to be your friend and provide you with free software with my cool and useful modifications if you don't redistribute it to your other friends. (Which you're allowed to do, but I just won't be your if I catch you doing that, and won't give you any more)."
There isn't anything the GPL can do about that, without becoming a crazy non-free license. It's entirely out of its scope.
The behavior doesn't step on any user rights, because:
1. It doesn't remove their rights to what they already have (software they have downloaded under the Subscription Agreement).
2. Users do not have a right to enter into or remain in a Subscription Agreement with Red Hat; there is no such right.
3. People have a right to refuse to redistribute something. If you have some GPLed program I want, and I ask for it, you can say no. If you say yes to giving me binaries, then you can't say no to giving the source (for just that specific version of those binaries and nothing more).
4. People have access to the original software; they can make their own distribution from scratch to compete with Red Hat.
There is no intent in the GPL whatsoever to prevent Red Hat's behavior; there is no wording that could even remotely have that interpretation.
The person who came up with the license probably disagrees with the behavior, but he didn't put anything in the license to prevent it and probably wouldn't find it a good idea to try to use a copyright license to try to do that.