3 ms·
Quoting+updating myself from http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2855835 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2855835 .Go read the discussion if you find it inte
by beagle3 15y ago
Quoting+updating myself from http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2855835 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2855835 .Go read the discussion if you find it interesting, the discussion touches on the feasibility, flaws, objections, etc.
Intellectual "Property Tax".
Have everyone declare the value of their intellectual "property" (patents, copyrights, trademarks, designs) - each and every item, for that year, on their tax return, and have them pay 1% of the value as "IP tax".
The declared amount is what one pays for a compulsory license (through an escrow - i.e., if I want to use it, I can just do that by putting money in an escrow account set up for that "property" item, and be immune from lawsuit) or if successfully sued, and up to 3 times that for willful infringement, _per year_ -- and no more. But of course, property owner can always negotiate a lower payment. This can apply equally to any kind of IP, including music (which already has a compulsory licensing arrangement), videos and patents (which do not).
All of a sudden, everyone has an incentive to state a reasonable value for their patent. Copyright catalogs that are not being published (old music recordings, old books, old movies) would be assigned 0 value by copyright holder, in order to avoid tax - which would mean anyone can freely make a copy. If they believe -- at the end of the year -- that someone is making a profit at their expense, they can set the value as high as they want at the end of that year, pay the tax, and sue the profiteer.
The important points are:
- People keep forgetting that patents are an offensive measure. The only right they give you is to sue others for infringement. They do not give you a "clear to operate" approval. If you can't afford to sue later ($200K-$500K to even consider a patent lawsuit in the US these days), the patent has negative value for you (because it does cost $10K-$50K to maintain over the life of the patent, but you won't be able to fend of infringement in court should it happen).
- It ties patent maintenance cost to patent value; the current system has essentially fixed (and relatively low for bigcorp/trollcorp) costs for potentially infinite value in the case of a successful lawsuit. e.g. -- you can only find legos from the lego company, and magsafe adapters from Apple, because they won't license it to anyone for a reasonable price, which is the same as an infinite price as far as others are concerned.
- There ARE nontrivial costs to maintaining the IP system -- courts, police, customs and border protection, etc. These are mostly paid for by the tax base, but enjoyed disproportionately by patent owners who declare huge values at no additional cost.
- Many people I've mentioned this idea to compare it to some (unspecified) ideal system, or to a no-patent-law-at-all situation, and obviously find problems. It is important to note that it is not worse for the individual investor (they already need huge resources to successfully sue), or the legitimate patent. It hurts patent trolls by introducing cost-of-carry for their "property". It also forces patent bullies to actually care about patents rather than collect as many as possible (If IBM assigns $1M value to each one of their 30,000 patents, that would cost $300M/year to maintain. They won't).
- It puts older and newer patents on equal footage. Any major reform that does not address existing patents becomes unreasonably complicated or is useless from the get go.
- If patents last 20 years, this amounts to 20% tax over the lifetime of the patent -- comparable to capital gains tax in most jurisdictions (which is what you would pay if you sold it on day one for that some). If the value drops to zero down the line, e.g. because of better technology - you've only paid in proportion to the value you believed you extracted from it.
- Finally, you could give tax credit for existing filing / maintenance fees - which would mean that under the current fee structure, every patent in the US would be considered worth ~$100K/year for the purpose of lawsuits.
- kd5bjo 15y agoIt definitely has some good points, but there are a few issues to consider: * Compulsory licensing for trademarks doesn't make sense; their purpose is to ensure that the consumer knows who manufactured the product. If you can't exercise control over the people that use your trademark, it's useless. * Patent litigation is too expensive for small firms and too cheap for large ones; figuring out how to fix this would be a big win. That can be done by adjusting the actual cost, the outcome probability, or the judgement amount. Time until judgement is also a big factor. * This system doesn't address the problem of submarine patents, that are kept hidden for years until a lot of firms are unknowingly infringing, and then get sued for large damages. It needs to address how a company knows whether or not it needs to license a patent for its technology. Perhaps holding a patent on a technology should give you "clear to operate" approval, and existing patent holders must review and challenge patent applications before they're granted.
- beagle3 15y agoExcellent points. > Compulsory licensing for trademarks doesn't make sense; their purpose is to ensure that the consumer knows who manufactured the product. If you can't exercise control over the people that use your trademark, it's useless. Perhaps it is wrong to bundle trademarks with the rest of them. The consumer protection angle is what makes them different than the copyright and patent monopolies. Trademarks are sometimes used defensively - only Google Inc can lay claim to be the device you use to "google stuff". However, they are sometimes used offensively - e.g. Cisco vs. Apple on the iPhone trademark, and the still ongoing Apple vs. Chinese-company-whose-name-I-don't-know iPad trademark. The "use it or lose it" status of trademarks makes the current situation a little better than patents, but still, offensive use of Trademark should cost the user in proportion to their benefit. A really crazy idea: "compulsory hostile trademark takeover" - you'd be able to take over anyone's trademark for 100x the value they assign to it (And on which they pay 1% tax or whatever). e.g. I can register a trademark 'iJoke' for $75, but if I want to keep it, I need to say how much it is worth to me on my tax return and pay 1%. Let's say I declare $1M. Then I need to pay $10K in tax, and Apple can forcibly take it away for $100M (paid in advance, in escrow) and waiting 12 months for me to lose my trademark rights (although they gain shared trademark right away). A non-government "eminent domain", if you will. Might also work well against domain squatters. Same underlying idea: make cost-of-carry proportional to value. > Patent litigation is too expensive for small firms and too cheap for large ones; figuring out how to fix this would be a big win. That can be done by adjusting the actual cost, the outcome probability, or the judgement amount. Time until judgement is also a big factor. I agree, although I have no specific suggestion about how to adjust that. In Finland, traffic tickets are a percentage of your yearly income, with a minimum but no maximum. So a speeding ticket isn't cheap even for big earners - a $60K ticket happens a few times a year. (They are still cheap to people who already have a fortune but not come, though). Perhaps there's someway to make that depend on value too -- e.g., there is a progressive tax on income to be able to sue; e.g. when you sue someone, you pay 0.01% of your yearly income for every day in court, whether you win or lose. So 2.5% if you spend every workday in court suing people. Obviously, court services are more valuable to you if you have more income. > This system doesn't address the problem of submarine patents, that are kept hidden for years until a lot of firms are unknowingly infringing, and then get sued for large damages. It needs to address how a company knows whether or not it needs to license a patent for its technology. Perhaps holding a patent on a technology should give you "clear to operate" approval, and existing patent holders must review and challenge patent applications before they're granted. On the contrary. Now you'd actually have an incentive to do a patent search, and lock down low fees by private agreements so that they cannot be inflated later the way submarine patents are used today. Although it might help to codify this somehow; e.g., if you hold a patent, declare value $1M (paying $10K/year to maintain). I offer you $10M upfront for 5 years license (Twice what you declare it is worth). You decline. I document my offer, and use it anyway, paying only the compulsory $1M/year for the first year. On the 2nd year, you declare it worth $10M (in an attempt to extract more money from me). I'll have to pay up or stop using it. But you can get in trouble with the tax authorities for (allegedly) reporting a much lower value. Basic ideas: 1. Tie cost-of-property-carry to real world value 2. Use tax authorities to coerce everyone into estimating values sensibly and defensibly.