3 ms·
Isn't some of the code that redhat distributes under GPLv3 or AGPL? Are the terms there stricter?
by m463 3y ago
Isn't some of the code that redhat distributes under GPLv3 or AGPL?
Are the terms there stricter?
- jzb 3y agoAGPL provisions kick in for services delivered over a network, basically the SaaS models. With RHEL some of the code may be under the AGPL (I haven't checked if any of the RHEL packages are actually AGPL), but it's not being offered as a service in a way that should trigger AGPL requirements AFAIK. GPLv3 doesn't contain any provisions that address this as far as I am aware. It was concerned with things like "Tivoization" and embedded software. None of the terms in those licenses require the things that everybody seems to want them to require: verbatim publishing of exact source code to everyone everywhere that allows "bug for bug" clones of RHEL and/or continuing a business relationship that forces Red Hat to convey the GPL rights for all RHEL releases no matter what a customer does with those rights.
- bragr 3y agoNot really in regards to this particular issue. GPLv3 has the same issue in that it only people who receive the binaries are entitled to the source, and 3rd parties technically have no right to demand the source. AGPL is a little broader, but if I don't allow anyone else access to my modified AGPL app, again technically no 3rd parties could demand the source from me. It'll be interesting to see if there is some new generation of licenses that require derivatives in source form to be publicly available, but enforcement seems almost impossible.
- quectophoton 3y ago> [...] licenses that require derivatives in source form to be publicly available Note, this fails the "desert island test" from Debian's Free Software Guidelines[1]. If someone wants their software to be accepted in the Debian package repositories, they should be aware that using this license might prevent them from doing so. I'm not opining on whether that's a good policy or a bad policy, only mentioning that that's a thing. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debian_Free_Software_Guidelines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debian_Free_Software_Guideline...
- pabs3 3y agoSuch licenses wouldn't meet the Open Source Definition either (as its a copy of the DFSG) and probably not the Free Software Definition either. https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html#fs-definition https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html#fs-definition