3 ms·
Actually the text from your National Geographic link is the one that is more sloppy. The original meaning of the word "fossil", which is still used in various
by adrian_b 3y ago
Actually the text from your National Geographic link is the one that is more sloppy.
The original meaning of the word "fossil", which is still used in various contexts, means anything that is dug up from below the surface of the Earth.
During the last two centuries "fossil" became used more frequently with the restricted meaning of remains of ancient living beings.
"Fossilization" is any process that has ensured the preservation of such remains. The most frequent form of fossilization is mineralization, which is the transformation of the remains into a rock, but it is not the only kind of fossilization, especially for more recent remains, like fossil amber or the fossils from the La Brea Tar Pits. Some organic molecules have survived even billions of years without being converted into rocks.
Your quotation "to become a fossil, the bone has to become rock" is valid only in the most frequent cases, because sometimes a bone becomes a fossil without becoming a rock, e.g. when the animal has been enbalmed (e.g. by tar or resin) or frozen (like many mammoths).
You are right however that the article discussed here is annoyingly ambiguous, because it cannot be known whether the hardness and weight are attributes of the original bones or only of the mineralized bones that have been preserved.
In any case, the conclusions about the weight of the bones in the living animal were based on studies of the microscopic structure of the bones, not on how many people were needed to carry the fossils.
- eesmith 3y agoTo add another counter-example, "fossil air" is "A sample of air (for example in the bubbles trapped in an ice core) that preserves the composition of the environment at the time it was deposited." - https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803095830490 https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority...