7 ms·
Bark beetles are eating through Germany’s Harz forest
- hirundo 3y agoThey're also a big problem here in New Mexico. I live on a heavily wooded lot of mixed pinyon and juniper. About half of my pinyon have died, and I've spent much of my free time in the last two years removing them. But the surrounding lots and the adjacent vast public lands have scary amounts of dead fuel on the ground. I'm preparing for a major fire as if it's inevitable and imminent, rather than just another risk. My previous home insurance company doubled my rates so I moved to another ... which my agent tells me, has already withdrawn insurance underwriting from much of the area. The pinyon that are left tend to be the ones that grow closely with the juniper, which is somehow protective. Removing dead trees seems to slow down the disease in nearby trees, so it acts like a spreading infection. I'm told that the bark beetles are usually controlled by die-offs in winter cold snaps, and we just haven't had the necessary cold snaps in recent winters.
- jzelinskie 3y agoI recently visited Harz and subsequently Saxon Switzerland (which is in Germany and Czechia, not Switzerland) and both had issues with these beetles. I was just a tourist, so I'd love to hear a local chime in for any corrections. I was initially shocked that a country could log their own national parks, but eventually came to understand the situation. They log to avoid the beetles spreading, but also because the trees the beetles have infested become risks of starting fires. A fire had occurred on the Czech side of Saxon not too long before I visited. Harz looks specifically bad until you get near the summit (Brocken) because they've explicitly decided to naturally re-forest the park. This reforestation policy isn't new though; it's been applied since miners over-extracted the mountain and destroyed much of the park around the dig-sites, the park brought in new species, and then ultimately decided those new species weren't going to restore their old habitat.
- flohofwoe 3y agoYes it's definitely noticeable in my home region (Ore Mountains near the Czech border). Not as large scale as in the photos of that article, more like isolated spots. The forst is definitely getting thinner, at first caused by the massive damage from storms like Kyrill, and then the dry summers in recent years. Same long-term strategy as in the Harz mountains though: natural reforestation, which should eventually lead to a more robust forest (maybe at the cost of profitability).
- flohofwoe 3y agoIt's interesting to note that these are not natural forests, but essentially man-made tree plantations, reforested since the 18th century after the natural forests had been eliminated in the centuries before mainly because of ore mining. Same story further to the south-east in the Ore Mountains. Getting rid of the spruce tree mono culture and letting a mixed forest regrow will be a good thing even if it will take a century or more (that's at least what the strategy seems to be in Ore Mountains).
- davidw 3y agoI wonder how many genuinely "old growth" forests are left in Europe and where they are. This lists a few without much detail https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_old-growth_forests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_old-growth_forests
- flohofwoe 3y agoApparently parts of Ruegen island are "old forest" and some patches here in there in nature reserves, but I guess one could argue that even the old Slavic and Germanic tribes already "cultivated" their forests.
- dbrgn 3y agoThe Swiss National Park was mostly untouched since 1914: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_National_Park https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_National_Park However, that probably does not qualify as old growth. The list you linked to does not list any forest in Switzerland.
- kiney 3y agoIn germany there is basically none left. But there are forests that have been planted centuries ago and are relatively undisturbed since then
- dahwolf 3y agoHere you go: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bia%C5%82owie%C5%BCa_Forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bia%C5%82owie%C5%BCa_Forest
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mistrial9 3y agorelated event in California https://www.fs.usda.gov/detailfull/r5/home/?cid=FSEPRD613875&width=full https://www.fs.usda.gov/detailfull/r5/home/?cid=FSEPRD613875...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- remote_phone 3y agoIt seems like signing up for globalization means having to accept consequences like this. You can’t bemoan when invasive species affects local ecosystems when you also allow unabated global transport with absolutely no security or inspection for diseases or insects etc. You can’t be lazy with inspection and then be shocked when an extremely global eceonomy introduces Bark Beetles and decimate your trees. Either accept this outcome or spend more money at entry points or stop globalization with countries that don’t inspect their exports to avoid the situation completely.
- flohofwoe 3y agoThe bark beetle is not an invasive species in Central Europe though. The main reason is climate change (the last decade was increasingly hotter, drier and 'stormier') combined with a man-made tree mono culture (which goes back a few hundred years).
- leptons 3y agoThe same thing happened in California also due to climate change. The beetles here thrived far more than they used to due to shorter/warmer winters with less/no snow in the mountains, and beetle population exploded and they killed probably a million or more trees. Up in the mountains in California you can't drive anywhere without seeing thousands of dead trees all around you - and it's everywhere in the mountains here, probably millions of trees dead - I obviously don't know an exact count, but it's quite a lot.
- Xylakant 3y agoThere are two bits of information that the article omits. Large chunks of the Harz forest are a nature reserve and only limited action will be taken, for example planting seedlings. Pesticides won’t be used in those zones - the only action that will be taken is a safety corridor around those zones. The spruce forests that grow there are not the original forest - they were planted to get access to cheap lumber for mining operations, sometimes on terrain unsuitable to spruce. Most of them were planted after WW2. Here‘s an article that goes into a little more detail (in german, from the nature park administration) https://www.nationalpark-harz.de/de/der-nationalpark-harz/waldentwicklung/ https://www.nationalpark-harz.de/de/der-nationalpark-harz/wa...
- __jonas 3y agoAn interesting case study about this is the Bavarian Forest National Park. In the 80s, several major storms caused a huge amount of trees to die, and there was a decision made to not intervene in the forest ecosystem and leave the dead trees instead of removing them. Then in the 90s because of this and other reasons that created a favorable environment for the bark beetles, there was a massive spread of them and large parts of the forest died. The national park management continued the policy of not intervening in the forest ecosystem, which was met by pretty heavy criticism from parts of the population. However it seems to have worked out in the end, as the forest is now starting to regenerate. There is a decent summary on the German Wikipedia page here: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nationalpark_Bayerischer_Wald#Der_Borkenk%C3%A4fer_im_Nationalpark https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nationalpark_Bayerischer_Wald#...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blakesterz 3y agoSimilar situation here in NY, the ash trees are pretty much wiped out: https://www.dec.ny.gov/animals/7253.html https://www.dec.ny.gov/animals/7253.html These were some of the most common trees around until this damn bugs got here. The emerald ash borer (EAB) (Agrilus planipennis) is an invasive beetle from Asia that infests and kills North American ash species (Fraxinus sp.) including green, white, black and blue ash. All of New York's native ash trees are susceptible to EAB.
- unboxingelf 3y agoSimilar on the west coast in Oregon - bark beetles decimating douglas fir and pine.
- hedora 3y agoThey're also rampant around the SF bay area; they mostly leave the native trees alone, but I'm staring at a massive dead pine tree that was healthy a few years ago. The damage in the article looks different though. Our beetles seem to focus on a ring of bark near the ground, so they don't have to eat nearly as much to kill the tree.
- mattpallissard 3y agoSame thing happened where I'm from, Illinois, a decade ago or so. They were basically all wiped out. However the past few times I've visited I've actually noticed both young ash trees and old "dead" trees that had been cut down to the stump with new growth. It makes me wonder if there'll be new a balance struck where there will be ash trees, and there will be ash borer, just fewer of each.
- egberts1 3y agoTime to mass-release woodpeckers.
- exabrial 3y agoTake a lesson from the American Rockies, where forests are being decimated by a similar beetle blight: issue prescribed fires, institute managed but aggressive proactive logging on public lands, institute maintenance of fire roads, and spring cleanup of deadfall... _now_. Unfortunately, 'environmentalists' thumbed their nose to a lot of these practices and the result was half of Rocky Mountain National Park burning down.
- mistrial9 3y agotragic opportunism to throw partisanship in with the upset "do something now" is fine to say but the Devil is in the details, as they say. Actions have re-actions and ripple effects. Wise management is what got "us" here today ? humble yourself then work with all your might, seems appropriate now
- swarfield 3y agoJust because we messed it up in the past doesn't mean we didn't learn from it and can't adapt our strategies in the future as new data comes in. Changing nothing is the most harmful strategy right now.
- swarfield 3y agoThis really pissed me off. Half of the trees in RMNP were/are dead standing since the Park Service had put out all natural fires for a century and did not allow logging of the dead wood. We hit the point where the fuel situation is so bad that fires are no longer controllable, and the fires burn so much hotter that it permanently scars the land by burning seeds that usually would make it through just fine.
- jansan 3y agoI remember that when I was in school good parts of the Harz mountains were destroyed by the Bark Beetle, but at that time it was acid rain that made matters worse. It was a poster example of the Waldsterben (dying of forests) at that time. This phenomenon has been politically abused at least since the 80s.
- flohofwoe 3y agoThe classic 1980's "Waldsterben" meme photo was a strip of dead forest along the Czech border near the Fichtelberg though, this was most likely caused by dirty coal power station emissions from across the border, at times the air would reek of cat piss which we used to call "Bohemian Air".. or maybe better translated as "Bohemian Wind" :)
- jansan 3y agoThat acid rain certainly had an effect in some regions, but people at that time were very fast to attribute every single dying tree to that cause, just like today they do it with climate change. However, Bark Beetles don't need any helpers like acid rain or climate change, they can destroy a forest perfectly by themselves if they are in the right mood.
- flohofwoe 3y agoI agree that the topic was 'exploited' mainly by the Green Party in the 80s, but in the area I grew up (south east Germany near the Czech border) the forest is definitely in a much worse state now than at any time during the last 40 years, even including the heavy environmental pollution caused by the GDR industry. Since the last 5 years or so there's so many grey, brown and empty patches in the forests that it's getting downright scary.
- jansan 3y agoSo what do locals think is the reason for this? The past few summers have been exceptionally dry and hot here (north of your place), but is this the only reason? If so, let's hope natures uses this cooler and rather wet year to recover a bit. Btw, Inidentially my teenage son just came back from "Boofen" there :)
- myshpa 3y agoWe make it too easy for the bugs: a) Monocultures of trees originally grown in higher altitudes with high water demands make it easy for the bark beetles to thrive (esp. in this warming climate). b) Additionally, these monocultures usually lack multiple levels of vegetation, allowing wind to pass through (it should go over) and further drying the land, harming the trees and creating a favorable environment for the beetles. c) We've deforested the countryside so that only small forest areas remain, with large clearings, enabling the wind in again. Thanks to this the forests are losing their ability to hold water and produce new rains, worsening the drought conditions. d) The removal of dead wood and litter further exacerbates the drying and destroys biodiversity, making the conditions even more suitable for the bark beetles to infest. e) Furthermore, we tend to prioritize the felling of the strongest and biggest trees, with deep roots, weakening the overall resilience of the forest. f) Instead of letting the trees mature with deep roots, we cut down the plantations when they're only 40 years old (youngsters). g) The spruce and pine monocultures are the most susceptible to destruction by beetles, and when they're felled and sold as round wood abroad, the cycle continues with the replanting of the same type of forest.
- crickey 3y agoIts not really an issue, or only problem for humans. Bugs will kill the trees, consume the dead wood and fertilize the soil. Bio diversity will come back
- myshpa 3y agoNo, the dead wood will get sold, the land will be cleared (they have special machinery now which destroys even large stumps that makes forest ground look like a crop field), burn or take away the dead wood and leave only the bare land. Then they'll plant the same monoculture again. It may be different in (some) reservations, but this is the common approach.
- crickey 3y agoWell that just sounds like bad farming. If you cant at least think 1 generation ahead then the state must intervene
- Octokiddie 3y ago> But the tiny insects have been causing outsized devastation to the forests in recent years, with officials grappling to get the pests under control before the spruce population is entirely decimated. Two-thirds of the spruce in the region have already been destroyed, said Alexander Ahrenhold from the Lower Saxony state forestry office, and as human-caused climate change makes the region drier and the trees more favorable homes for the beetles’ larvae, forest conservationists are preparing for the worst. It seems this is not exactly new: > Around 1800, large swathes of the Harz were deforested. The less resistant spruce monoculture, that arose as a consequence of the mining industry in the Upper Harz, was largely destroyed by a bark beetle outbreak and a storm of hurricane proportions in November 1800. This largest known bark beetle infestation in the Harz was known as the Große Wurmtrocknis, and destroyed about 30,000 hectares (74,000 acres) of spruce forest and lasted about for 20 years. The woods were largely reforested with spruce. Continuous problems with bark beetle and storms were the negative side effects of mining in the Harz Mountains. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harz > In the longer term, mixing other tree species into the forest could be a solution, Ahrenhold said. “It makes sense to plant other conifers that can cope better with these conditions, especially on south-facing slopes and on very dry soil,” he said. The AP article fails to mention the massive amount of deforestation and animal depopulation that's occurred for centuries now, but which is well-documented in the Wikipedia article. This gives the misleading impression that what's happening now is somehow unprecedented. The issue, it seems, is that trying to "manage" the land doesn't work. It may even be more the root of the problem than the solution.
- myshpa 3y ago> The problem, it seems, is trying to "manage" the land, which has not worked in the past and seems unlikely to work in the future. Money, as always.
- nathias 3y agoIt isn't just in Germany, its getting warmer around Alps and the conditions for pines are deteriorating... our whole forest of pines was destroyed by bark beetles a few years ago, now it is regrowing as a mixed forrest because pines just aren't viable anymore.
- Borg3 3y ago10B ppl, we can make it! lulz... I wonder when people will wake up and stop following that stupid never ending economy growth pattern. Its just impossible.. Nothing in nature grows for ever.. ok.. except blackholes but thats special case... We either can have 200M happy ppl living decent lives or 10B poor ppl, struggling for basic things.
- low_common 3y agoSo what are you gonna do about it?
- Vecr 3y agoBlack holes don't actually grow forever, at least if you accept hawking radiation and the heat death of the universe. Eventually the evaporation due to hawking radiation will outpace the inflow of matter and light, causing the black hole to shrink until it is gone.
- myshpa 3y ago> stupid never ending economy growth pattern. Its just impossible Agree with degrowth, exponential growth in a finite environment is not physically possible. > 200M happy ppl living decent lives or 10B poor ppl We can feed 10B people just fine ... with plant based diets. But don't worry, if we don't stop fossil fuels and animal ag pronto, we'll get to 200M or less soon enough. Not so sure about "happy" though. https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/917471 https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/917471 Feeding 10 billion people by 2050 within planetary limits may be achievable
- gunapologist99 3y ago> Michael Müller, the Chair of Forest Protection at the Technical University in Dresden, said there are “very strict requirements for the use of pesticides” which can be very effective in getting rid of the bugs, although the chemicals are sometimes frowned upon for their potentially harmful environmental side effects. but an actually harmful side effect is that the forest is now (more than) half dead. if you're going to try to "manage" a forest (as if that's really possible), you should actually manage it. Otherwise, let it grow on its own with the widest variety of trees that would normally be there.
- lhoff 3y agoThe later is whats happening now. They let the nature do its thing. The bugs are only part of the problem. They are so widespread because it’s gotten to dry there which makes the trees vulnerable.
- acyou 3y agoI would attribute bark beetle issues to rising winter temperatures. As others have stated, monocultures are nothing new and haven't been much of an issue in temperate climates for centuries. Low winter temperatures (frosts) for extended periods of time are what keep bark beetle in check. Germany has been missing those for some time, hence the bark beetle issue. Aside from that, Deutscher Wald looks great, which is nothing new. Pinecones are stacked in neat piles, underbrush cleared, trees are in tidy rows.
- myshpa 3y ago> Deutscher Wald looks great, which is nothing new. Pinecones are stacked in neat piles, underbrush cleared, trees are in tidy rows Oh yes, of course, that's precisely how nature intended it to be! Neat and orderly, just like a perfectly manicured garden ;)
- m0llusk 3y agoIf you listen carefully to an infected tree, for example with a stethoscope applied directly to the trunk, then you can hear the mandible chatter generated by thousands of tiny mouths feeding.
- chr1 3y agoTo fix issues like this we need more work on gene drive. Targeting doublesex gene in insects has a very promising results in different species from mosquitos https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-24790-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-24790-6 to fruit-flies https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2301525120 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2301525120. So it can be used to eliminate the most harmful pest species.
- wodenokoto 3y agoThat is weird. If you visit the Harz National park it will say the opposite: Harz was a commercial forest, turned national park. The beetle is a danger for the monoculture required by the former commercial forest. By letting the beetle kill off the mono culture, more varied vegetation, trees and nature will spruce up from the decaying dead trees. These varied and original species are resistant to the beetle and the problem will solve it self. In some areas they man has planted indigenous plants to help speed up the process.
- amai 3y agoMore Biodiversity => more resilience. Everybody agrees to that. More diversity at the workplace? Everybody finds excuses why that is not a good idea.