4 ms·
This whole blog post is misunderstanding after misunderstanding it's almost hilarious. Starting off with the very first premise: that you need to install an ap
by vel0city 3y ago
This whole blog post is misunderstanding after misunderstanding it's almost hilarious.
Starting off with the very first premise: that you need to install an app. Libby is available as a web app, so that first big point the author is making just factually incorrect. They didn't need to install the app. So instantly the author here loses a massive amount of credibility to me.
Then, it's not like this whole "deep search" and "notify me" tag is hard to find, and no you don't need to make.it yourself, and no you don't need to study the help articles to understand how it works. The only part I might say is tricky is you need to click the filter button to get to the advanced search settings where there's a big button that says "deep search" and explains what that means. Then for results not in your library there's a dedicated notify me tag button which when tapped explains how it works. I didn't have to go to the help area at all to get a detailed explanation of how stuff worked, and I got to it with obviously interactable UI elements.
- resolutebat 3y agoYou are thoroughly missing the point, although, to be fair, the author obfuscates it with the rant about shitty UI. The actual enshittification here is that readers used to be able to tell libraries what they wanted for free, and now this data is apparently an Advantage Plus(tm) premium feature that libraries need to pay for, so OverDrive can make more money.
- vel0city 3y agoYeah but I can't really trust the rest of their deep analysis when they didn't even know the extremely basic fact libbyapp.com exists. Like, if they're missing that extremely basic thing, how can I trust they're not also missing big parts of the rest of the story? If I write a blog post with deep analysis about NASA but start off with a rant about how they faked the moon landing and the moon is made of cheese you probably wouldn't trust the rest of my writing right?
- mcdonje 3y agoThey missed one thing that's mostly irrelevant to their point, so I can't trust anything they say, even when they back it up with expert commentary!
- vel0city 3y agoHow can I trust they even bothered to actually track down real experts when they didn't bother figuring out basic facts? And they act like Overdrive was free while Libby is charging, but Overdrive wasn't free before. There's no actual breakdown of the total costs of these two platforms, just some vague trust us its more expensive. Which I can't really trust a blog post of rumors without hard facts when the things I can check as hard facts are downright wrong!
- shkkmo 3y agoPerhaps if you re-read the article you'd catch more of the facts. Overdrive and Libby are two apps from the same company. That company, Overdrive, has a monopoly and makes money charging libraries money to provide a service to that library's patrons for free.
- vel0city 3y agoYour comment isn't sharing anything I didn't already know. The author is asking me to trust them about their research they did about some pricing change related to moving towards the Libby platform. They mention new subscriptions for libraries without actually sharing any of the actual pricing. Overdrive is going away, so whatever they were paying for Overdrive will go to $0. These numbers are entirely made up and not in line with whatever they were paying, just showing an example of how this whole argument of a new subscription doesn't necessarily mean things are radically more expensive. So say Overdrive cost the library $100. Now there's this new platform Libby, which while in development and not feature-complete with Overdrive was just tacked on free or whatever. Now the Overdrive platform is being deprecated and will cease soon, so they announce the pricing structures for Libby, $75. Oh no, what used to be $100 is now $175, what an increase! Oh wait, we forgot, Overdrive is going away, so in the end the costs are actually only $75. When the author can't track down the full story that Libby is available as a website it really reduces the trust I have that they actually figured out what the pricing models are as Overdrive goes away and Libby replaces it. I question if the author and their sources were even fully aware that Overdrive is fully going away soon, as that was only announced a few months ago. They never once actually shared "This was what the costs were with Overdrive, here is what the costs will be when its just Libby." Maybe the overall costs are going up! I don't know either way. I definitely don't have deep insights on exactly how the pricing models worked in the past nor in the future as I have never worked for a library. It wouldn't surprise me that costs would go up in a period with somewhat high inflation. It would almost be news if the price didn't go up. In the end though, I can't really trust someone who didn't bother researching the first basic and easily verifiable facts they bring up in their writing. Once again, if someone writes a post talking about specifics about NASA but starts off talking about how the moon landing was faked, would you trust the rest of their "trust me" writing?
- beej71 3y agoMost people feel this way, but I think it's a mistake. There's always something to learn, even if a basic thing is missed.
- vel0city 3y agoSo if I write an article about astrophysics but start off with the idea that we're all on a flat earth on the back of a giant turtle you'll continue trusting the rest of the document? The whole round earth thing is just a basic thing I missed!
- beej71 3y agoI don't really trust anything to start so it's not that. But so many people say "I stopped reading at X", which means they're betting they will not be improved by anything at all that follows in the article. Flat Earthers aren't wrong about everything, after all.
- BeetleB 3y agoI see that Overdrive is taking away a nice feature. What the author is missing is the comparison with physical books, which never had this feature. You want to recommend the library get a book? You fill out the form they have. That process still works regardless of the format. Overdrive gave them something better than what they ever had, and then took it away. The libraries aren't left off worse than before. Personally, I always search using the library catalog's web site, so this whole article is about a feature I never saw. I would encourage everyone search that way instead of directly on Overdrive. I haven't looked up the numbers recently, but after a spike in ebook usage several years ago, the percentage dropped and I suspect continues to do so. Most people are over the hype and have returned to physical book usage.
- vel0city 3y ago> Overdrive gave them something better than what they ever had, and then took it away But the feature still exists, so this is just untrue.
- paulclinger 3y ago> What the author is missing is the comparison with physical books, which never had this feature. You want to recommend the library get a book? You fill out the form they have. That process still works regardless of the format. It doesn't. I used to be able to submit a request for printed and digital books, but my library stopped accepting those requests for digital books and (just as I commented elsewhere in this thread) now refers me to the Notify Me feature and Overdrive catalog (and if it's not in the catalog, I can't request it do be added).
- vel0city 3y ago> and if it's not in the catalog, I can't request it do be added If its not in the catalog requesting it from the library isn't really doing anything for you but give you false hope of it appearing. Wouldn't you rather know your request isn't going to be fruitful ahead of time instead of thinking your request is doing something when its just going straight into the bin? And, can you really blame the library from not wanting to have to maintain two lists of digital requests, especially since those digital requests will probably be delivered through Libby and requesting through Libby will actually notify you when its available, and let you know if its an actually requestable title? Imagine going to a restaurant where they didn't have a menu you just asked the server for food and maybe eventually they'll show up sometime with food for you without ever telling you if they could even serve that dish. Somehow you'd prefer this model!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thebooktocome 3y agoWhere did they say one has to install the app? They use the web interface exclusively and the feature that went missing was a web interface feature. . . > “For about a decade now, OverDrive has provided users with digital library access two ways: through its website (individual library portals hosted on overdrive.com) and its mobile apps (OverDrive and Libby). I’ve always gone the web route myself — at first because it was the only option, before the app was built; later deliberately avoiding the app in order to reduce the amount of surveillance data collected.” As for the feature itself, your comment seems to boil down to “Dark pattern UI changes are ineffective” but we know that’s not true; if they were unprofitable, companies wouldn’t constantly exploit them.
- vel0city 3y ago> ...or its mobile app Libby. Libby isn't just a mobile app > ...through its website (individual library portals hosted on overdrive.com) and its mobile apps (OverDrive and Libby). I’ve always gone the web route myself — at first because it was the only option, before the app was built; later deliberately avoiding the app in order to reduce the amount of surveillance data collected. Once again stating Overdrive is the website and Libby is only an app, while missing Libby is also a website. > Okay, so at the very least, OverDrive is trying to force people away from the web and into their proprietary app Here they're directly stating the functionality they're looking for is only in the app, which as stated Libby is available as a website so this is factually incorrect. > Disgruntled, I downloaded Libby and tried to figure out how to “add a ‘Notify Me’ tag”. If they knew Libby was a website and they hated the idea of installing the app, why would they disgruntly download the app? > you must first run a search, and then activate the “deep search” filter tag (!?!) in the search interface. Because that is intuitive and makes total sense. I mean, kind of? Huh, I couldn't find it from the basic search, let me press the advanced search button, oh hey there's a description of what deep search is right in the advanced search filter area, neat. And as an actual user of the feature that discovered it entirely organically, I don't see how it's a dark pattern at all on the client side.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]