3 ms·
The world doesn't end for a while. But the things that will end it are causing problems now. If this climate change were natural, I'd be sad at how much it wil
by jfengel 3y ago
The world doesn't end for a while. But the things that will end it are causing problems now.
If this climate change were natural, I'd be sad at how much it will cost to save what can be saved, and how much will be lost. But I myself won't live to see the worst of it.
What makes me angry today is that the same climate denialists are applying equally motivated reasoning to make a lot of people's lives worse right now. Climate denialism is a conspiracy theory, and they see conspiracies everywhere. American national discourse is non-existent because every issue is immediately shut down with "if you want it, it must be part of your attempt at world domination." The reasoning is appalling, but they've been trained on climate change (among others) to accept just outright stupidity.
And I'm at a complete loss for what to do. Everything I believe in stems from being able to make a solid case and have it be accepted by at least a majority. If that fails the alternatives are awful.
- mistermann 3y agoAs a conspiracy theorist myself: one thing you could do is try to raise the quality of your own thinking to meet the level of your self-perception of it.
- saiya-jin 3y agoThings will have to get worse, so folks will see direct impact on their lives, not just some reports in news. That's crossing the line even dimmer part of population will react to, since it will be sort of survival instinct. Probably not valid for Alaska. But yeah we 'lost' in past few years non-trivial part of population and the correction is nowhere in sight. Discussion doesn't seem to be possible, facts on one side and bad emotions on the other are missing each other pretty badly.
- avgcorrection 3y agoPlease. Rational people like researchers for the petroleum industry have known about this for many decades and yet (because of their employment) worked against the truth. Meanwhile rational people who believe it and are telling the truth have no radical solutions, only bike-to-work platitudes. I don't care about conspiracy theory losers. They're not powerful enough to put the blame on. At least not the majority of it.
- finite_depth 3y ago[dead]
- dsego 3y ago> direct impact on their lives Even then, they will just say it's always been like this, that's what young people born in 2000s are saying now.
- mrpopo 3y agoThings have already gone worse for many groups of people. Economically: fishermen, businesses near low-altitude ski stations, mediterranean farmers (Spain, Italy, Greece, Maghreb). Quality of life-wise: Iran, Northern African countries now have to live with 45-50C temperatures every summer. Disasters-wise: increased intensity of floods in South-East Asia, China, Taiwan, South Korea during rainy season, ... The list goes on. The thing is, QOL improvements based on economic growth often counter-balance these in the short term. But growth is slowing down and warming is speeding up.
- jeffbee 3y ago> Northern African countries now have to live with 45-50C temperatures every summer 20 dead bodies were brought into the morgue in Phoenix AZ every day last week. They have a backlog of over 300 unexplained deaths from July alone. You don't have to go as far as Africa to find unlivable conditions.
- gottorf 3y agoTo bring a counterbalancing perspective, in Europe at least, there are an order (or two, depending on the country) of magnitude more deaths from cold than from heat[0]. I'd imagine the US, being a primarily northern latitude country, has a similar story. As for the Phoenix numbers, I assume you're referencing this situation[1]; as of a week ago, Maricopa County had 24 confirmed heat-associated death year-to-date, with another 249 deaths under investigation. Maricopa County has four and a half million people, over 60% of Arizona's population; even if all 249 deaths under investigation end up being heat-related, that's still way fewer than deaths from diabetes, suicide, or drug overdoses[2] (reasonably assuming that the causes of death in Maricopa County are proportional to that of the state of Arizona as a whole). That is to say; "unlivable" is a stretch. [0]: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanplh/article/PIIS2542-5196(23)00023-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanplh/article/PIIS2542-5... [1]: https://abcnews.go.com/US/arizona-maricopa-county-phoenix-medical-examiner-capacity-heat/story?id=101739924 https://abcnews.go.com/US/arizona-maricopa-county-phoenix-me... [2]: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/states/arizona/arizona.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/pressroom/states/arizona/arizona.ht...
- finite_depth 3y ago[dead]
- iinnPP 3y agoMaybe your argument isn't good enough? I can certainly tell something (this can be anything and I won't clarify) is wrong and that it is overwhelmingly likely related to the climate. I also have as low of a carbon footprint as I can (it is near zero and my main focuses have been reduce followed by reuse and finally recycle(but only stuff I know gets recycled). With that said. I don't trust the article nor do I enjoy reading it. It makes odd claims, and comes from a place running articles that I have a real problem with. Things that reach into my childhood and that would probably (very high) mean my death had I been born a bit later. You can disagree, but I am oft correct to a point where my hope that you are correct is sincere. One thing of note is the term conspiracy theory. There is nothing wrong with observing a situation and coming to the conclusion that something isn't right. It is natural and more important than I think people are willing to admit. The conspiracy portion of the term is quite simple to achieve given almost everything involves at least one other person. A news network doing an interview with a person being a great example. Or there is this article where a writer/editor/business are in a conspiracy. The other requirement being a theory. Theories got us where we are today, often with others involved. If you truly want to use your words to fight climate change, go talk to those with an alternative theory and present your facts to win them over. All you are doing now (and this is fine, I am not critisizing you here) is complaining to already converted people. Lastly, and this will be the first time I have made this public, I think we should shift the goal posts as a society. No more stopping climate change. Let's change it to controlling the climate. The climate will change without us here and targeting THAT also targets climate change. The key difference is what it means to the person. One goal makes you a bad person because you like to enjoy a long drive. The other goal makes you a good person because you are fighting the world for the sake of your fellow humans. It goes without saying that we need to reach both goals anyway at some point. Best start early.
- vixen99 3y agoMany people agree with you. Here's a question though. If you observe what they do as against what they say, it's clear that governments in major economies do not share your and their concern and indeed it's difficult to see what can be done if they did. Example: just recently we've seen the British Prime Minister sign off a new raft of offshore oil and gas licenses. This is probably not unrelated to the dramatic decrease in average living standards in the UK thanks to energy policies. UK Climate protesters seem to have had a negative impact on the public especially since Britain's contribution to global warming is estimated to be around 1% - for a population of around 67 million. Reduce industrial activity? Look at the Mauna Loa CO2 levels from 2020 to 2023 which do not appear to deviate from their regular increase of around 2.3 or so ppm. So even a 'devastating' industrial economic shutdown had no perceptible effect on the relentless increase. Certainly one contributor to recent warming is the 10% increase in water vapour in the atmosphere brought about by the January 2023 under-sea earthquake off Japan. It's estimated to have projected trillions of gallons of water into the sky thus causing a substantial heating effect. https://www.aier.org/article/the-devastating-economic-impact-of-covid-19-shutdowns https://www.aier.org/article/the-devastating-economic-impact.... https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-02-16/tongan-volcano-impact-australian-weather/101978886 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-02-16/tongan-volcano-impact... https://www.npr.org/2022/08/03/1115378385/tonga-volcano-stratosphere-water-warming https://www.npr.org/2022/08/03/1115378385/tonga-volcano-stra...
- palata 3y ago> But I myself won't live to see the worst of it. It may all collapse earlier than you think. We seem to observe year after year that it is changing faster than what our models conservatively predicted. We're not talking about a hundred years, we're talking about decades. If we don't change society in a major way in the next 2 decades, we're pretty much done. Most people alive today will live to see how bad it gets (and many of them won't survive it if we keep on doing nothing).
- avgcorrection 3y agoOn the individual level there are always options.