4 ms·
This article demonstrates a very common mistake: People think health insurance covers health bills. It doesn't. It covers unexpected health bills, which is a v
by ars 15y ago
This article demonstrates a very common mistake: People think health insurance covers health bills.
It doesn't. It covers unexpected health bills, which is a very different thing.
Any type of situation that is expected to happen can not be covered by insurance, it needs to be covered by savings instead.
However many people want insurance premiums to be a type of forced savings plan, which is why there is such a huge argument in the US about health insurance.
Those opposed to government regulation want to handle the savings on their own. Those who like government regulation want it to force people to save for health care costs.
- jberryman 15y ago> It doesn't. It covers unexpected health bills, which is a very different thing. I see conservatives (not trying to label you) make this argument a lot, and I think it is a mischaracterization of 1) what most people mean by health insurance, and 2) what health insurance and health plans are really about: pooling risk and creating groups that can negotiate for lower prices. Re. 1: just skim the wikipedia article for health insurance (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance); the distinction between health plans vs. what you mean by "health insurance" all gets rather confused.
- tptacek 15y agoThe conservative objection to single payer health insurance is that single payer may be a terrible way to achieve cost negotiation. In a system of guaranteed issue private insurance, people could tune their exposure to risk by selecting plans with greater or lower deductibles, and then use HSAs to set up a rolling facility for paying their day-to-day coverage costs. The fundamentals of the system we're moving towards in the US is actually a conservative plan from the '90s: an exchange-based market for private health insurance coupled with guaranteed issue and a mandate for coverage. That plan was itself a response to the original liberal vision of universal health insurance: nationwide government-run single payer insurance.
- anonymoushn 15y agoI came here to say just this. In the United States, though, we use "Insurance" to refer to a very expensive form of prepaid health plan. We keep costs up by making laws that prevent employees from knowing how much their prepaid health plan costs. Just in case people might want to react to the high costs by not purchasing a plan, in the near future everyone in the U.S. will be required by law to purchase a prepaid health plan.
- yuhong 15y agoThey did limit the profit of the health care providers which happened to reduced lobbying.
- yuhong 15y agoSorry, health insurance providers.
- tptacek 15y agoIt's the nature of the social contract that we give up certain freedoms to gain the benefits of society; that's what contracts do: they bind us. It's not hard to make a list of "freedoms" we're mostly happy that people give up: the "freedom" to drive 100mph through school zones, the "freedom" to sell patent medicines with Pfizer branding on it, the "freedom" to set tire fires on our lawns. Those "freedoms" are respectively outweighed by the cost of collisions, of medical fraud, and of toxic and repulsive clouds of smoke. When societies adopt single-payer health care systems, they're expressing a judgement that the "freedom" to take individual control over how to finance health care at the lowest possible price is outweighed by the cost to society of the uncertainty of health care costs. And, setting aside principle for a moment, your health & well being is in fact one of the most important uncertainties in your life. You could be hit by a bus tomorrow, or stricken with a disease that outstrips your ability to pay for care. With the exception of a tiny, tiny fraction of people in society, nobody can truly provide an assurance of their ability to provide for their own care. So, to bring the principle back into the picture: if you're ideologically opposed to single-payer or socialized or mandated health insurance, it would seem that you must also support the idea that people who can't pay for their care must be denied care. There's a wide variety of pragmatic objections to single-payer insurance, many of which are probably valid. But if we're going to bring "freedom" and "choice" into the picture --- ideology, in other words --- we should be clear about what the tradeoffs are.
- onemoreact 15y agoIn the US the insurance companies also negotiate the costs with various heath care providers. It's possible to pay 6,000$ / year in premiums, never hit your deductible so the insurance company does not pay anything out of pocket and still save money.
- bunderbunder 15y agoLast time I saw a hard figure on it, which was admittedly a long time ago, was while I was working at an immediate care clinic. Uninsured folks were getting billed roughly 170% what insured folks were thanks to these negotiated rates.
- tptacek 15y agoAs someone who has paid out-of-pocket for an MRI (it needed to get done ASAP for logistical reasons and there was a bookkeeping screwup with my insurance): the markup for out-of-coverage services can be way way more than 170%.
- anarchotroll 15y agoThat's cause most of the people are insured and there is no pressure for lowering rates for the uninsured.
- tptacek 15y agoVirtually everyone is insured as a side effect of being an employee at a company that provides access to a group health insurance plan as a benefit. This has the side effect of coupling people's jobs to their health insurance, which drastically reduces labor mobility.
- bunderbunder 15y ago83% is certainly a large majority, but it is not "virtually everyone".
- tptacek 15y agoWithout sparking off a huge thread on free markets versus socialized medicine, the idea behind single payer health insurance is that nobody has to worry about "expected health bills", because everyone shares a giant risk pool in which uniformly low premiums end cover everyone by shifting expenses from people who do get sick to the (larger) pool of people who don't. Part of the philosophical idea behind single payer is that people have minimal control over financially devastating illness and injury, and one thing society can do that individuals can't is allow everyone to share the risk, transforming a small probability of an untenable expense into a certain probability of a manageable expense. You're right, and usefully so, to point out that private health insurance is treated like a utility instead of an insurance plan; knowing that also allows consumers to select high-deductible plans, and to take advantage of HSAs for tax-advantaged funding of the health care bills they do expect. But single-payer insurance can handle both problems (routine billing and catastrophic coverage) coherently.
- anarchotroll 15y agoIndividuals can opt into an insurance plan. That's sharing risk. What "society" (government) can do is force everyone to share THE SAME risks single-payer insurance == monopoly
- tptacek 15y agoPart of the notion that suggests people should be forced into sharing those risks is that nobody can rationally rule out future unbounded medical expenses; you can't predict the future, and virtually nobody has enough money to cover every plausible medical expense they might face. So the freedom we're really talking about is --- notionally --- the freedom to make what basically must be an irresponsible choice. It's true; single payer systems do create a monopoly for health care funding; that monopoly takes its place alongside the monopoly for military force, for air traffic control, for fire prevention, for oceanic weather surveillance, &c.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- joedev 15y agoI agree. You hear the phrase "I don't have healthcare" too often used when what the person really means is "I don't have insurance." If you live in a developed country, believe me, you have health care. Not to be pedantic but I will stand on a soapbox for a moment: I'd also point out that we all have the ability to care for our health. Health care is a daily activity which requires no insurance, and often no cost.
- crag 15y ago"Any type of situation that is expected to happen can not be covered by insurance, it needs to be covered by savings instead." Yeah right. Until you run out of money. Then what? In your world, you die. Good for everyone, until it's you or someone you care about. Then, like everyone else, you off running to the SS office to apply for (Medicare) disability. The whole point of insurance is to protect against risk. Else why have it at all?
- anonymoushn 15y agoInsurance is for unexpected events. Paying for expected events using insurance is not a worthwhile thing to do because you must pay for the cost of care plus the cost of running the insurance company, which is more expensive than just paying for the cost of care. So, if someone is worried about running out of money due to foreseeable medical expenses, buying insurance to cover those foreseeable medical expenses will cause him or her to run out of money earlier.