2 ms·
freehunter: "If Windows 8 is a failure, it'll be because of wild, speculative bullshit, not because it's a bad product." acqq: "Vista" freehunter: "Windows Vi
by acqq 15y ago
freehunter: "If Windows 8 is a failure, it'll be because of wild, speculative bullshit, not because it's a bad product."
acqq: "Vista"
freehunter: "Windows Vista is a great example of a product that died for the exact reasons I described."
I still don't see how you can be sure that "Windows 8" is not going to be the new Vista. You claimed that "complainers" make Microsoft's OS's fail, but the truth is -- Vista was bad OS not because of complainers but because of poor execution. The whole process of failed development is properly documented, all with the need to "start over" and "to release anything" fast after too much time went by.
That MSFT can earn money because of lock-in and a lot of companies that are practically forced to subscribe is independent fact to the quality of the particular OS release. Or the quality of their UI decisions -- not once they had to "undo" some of their UI "improvements."
- freehunter 15y agoVista was not Microsoft's best OS, but it was (and is) nowhere near as unusable as people claim. A few big problems it suffered: its minimum requirements were not generally met by the hardware it was running on. This is partly Microsoft's fault (for authoring "Vista Capable" stickers to underpowered hardware) part the fault of the manufacturer (for making said hardware) and part the fault of the user or whoever was making the decision to purchase (for buying low quality hardware). Another issue was the sidebar, which hogged memory. Turning it off is enough to fix most systems which exceed the minimum spec. The last major issue was driver support (which was the downfall of ME as well). Manufacturers assumed that they could use the same (or very similar) drivers for Vista, which wasn't the case. Result: poor hardware performance. Vista had development problems, but it was released in a working state. All they did was cut a few features (which still haven't surfaced) at no true cost to the performance of the OS. Word got out online that Vista had a few problems, and since the Microsoft hate was reaching a peak (mainly because of Apple's advertising), it was the new punching bag. People followed the hate without listening to reasonable explanations. If you say W8 is the "new Vista", in your mind and in the minds of those who listen to you, this is already true no matter what Microsoft does. At this point, you're just spouting wild, speculative bullshit because it fits with what you want to think. Wait until the baby is born, don't condemn it to hell based on the ultrasound.
- acqq 15y agoWith Vista Microsoft implemented the "new look" with assumptions of "working acceptably" only with the most powerful graphics cards. Even Windows 8 doesn't misuse the graphics hardware like Vista did. There's nothing more needed to prove that your premise "MSFT knows what they are doing" is false. freehunter: "Wait until the baby is born, don't condemn it to hell based on the ultrasound" Ultrasound can actually precisely diagnose the foetuses that certainly won't be healthy. To be sure it will be healthy is the harder task. "Condemn to hell"? I don't think you help your arguments with such language. I certainly won't write in this thread anymore. Too flamy here.