4 ms·
No. It can't. And pretending it can is a problem. Solar is nice. It'd be FAN-GODDAMN-TASTIC if we could use solar power as the backbone of our power generatio
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
No. It can't.
And pretending it can is a problem.
Solar is nice. It'd be FAN-GODDAMN-TASTIC if we could use solar power as the backbone of our power generation. But we can't, it's just not feasible.
Solar today is half of a power plant. Much like wind Solar generates power when its convenient to its own schedule, not ours, and sometimes that means it generates zero power.
This. Is. A. Problem.
It is, in fact, the problem of solar and wind power. Today we can use solar and wind serendipitously. They run on top of base power and when they provide power they allow us to keep gas powered generators offline. That's nice, but it's an edge solution, and we're already nearing the limits of that strategy. In order to replace base load power we need something that provides power reliably when it's convenient for humans. For solar or wind that means we need to invest in vast power storage plants. Things that do not currently exist even in designs. Things that are likely to be about as expensive to build and maintain as solar plants themselves will be.
We do not have the technology to move to solar or wind power as a base load power source. And it seems likely that if we did have that technology it would put the full cost of those power sources at higher than even fission power plants.
We can no more move to solar or wind power for the majority of our power needs than we could move to Thorium reactors, or fusion power.
- stcredzero 15y agoToday we can use solar and wind serendipitously. They run on top of base power and when they provide power they allow us to keep gas powered generators offline. Solar thermal+thermal storage could be used in climates closer to the equator. The US ran an experimental setup with 8 hours endurance after sundown. In the case of cooling equipment, solar coincides well with demand. You are most certainly right that solar won't cover all our baseload power needs. We don't need to cover it all. We just need to whittle down the unsustainable and environmentally unfriendly parts as much as we can. Subsidizing winners isn't something the government should be in the business of doing. However, penalizing losers is precisely what we have a government for, and CO2 emitting power is a losing proposition for the future.