3 ms·
In the example plenty of people would give you $100 or even $10000 for the stamp. The person selling it and setting his price just didn't know it.
by coldtea 3y ago
In the example plenty of people would give you $100 or even $10000 for the stamp. The person selling it and setting his price just didn't know it.
- WalterBright 3y agoIt's value to you was still $1.
- coldtea 3y agoYou started the thread by asserting that "price is an indication of value" is correct. I gave an counter example where someone ignorant of a thing's value (a guy who doesn't know they're selling an ultra rare stamp) sets it price to $1, wherea the market would gladly have paid 1000x times that. You said, "It's value to you was $1". When told it's not relevant, you said "there's no utility in saying something's value is $100 when nobody will give you $10 for it" which is about a different kind of value altogether. While that's correct in itself, I pointed how that's not refuting my example, as my example covers exactly the reverse case: the situation where plenty would give you 10x or 1000x for what you sell at a price of $x. In other words, I gave an example where price is NOT an indication of value. That's what you had to refute. You then backtracked to saying again: "It's value to you was $1". In any case, value has specific meanings in economics, and neither of them is about "value to you [the seller]": "Economic value is the measurement of the benefit derived from a good or service to an individual or a company. Economic value can also be the maximum price or amount of money that someone is willing to pay for a good or service. As a result, economic value can be higher than market value".
- WalterBright 3y agoI.e. the value of something is different for different people.