3 ms·
> though maybe maybe should be, because in practice its a common fallacy That’s why it was. Ad hominem is based on what is being attacked not how. Attacking t
by Retric 3y ago
> though maybe maybe should be, because in practice its a common fallacy
That’s why it was. Ad hominem is based on what is being attacked not how.
Attacking the person not the argument is deeper than simply dismissing something because of their political party, race, or educational history. When you attack stylistic elements of an argument you’re attacking the person as someone who made an argument in that form.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> When you attack stylistic elements of an argument you’re attacking the person as someone who made an argument in that form No, you aren’t. “This argument is false because ofn the way it is presented” is fallacious, but it does not rely on the reader rearranging it into “This argument is wrong because anyone who would present an argument this way is a bad person whose arguments should be dismissed”. Its definitely a non sequitur, but calling it ad hominem is interpolating things that aren't there.
- Retric 3y agoNot that kind of person or attack. What in your mind separates mocking someone’s speech impediment with mocking a website’s font? A website isn’t literally a person, but what’s being attacked is the thing making the argument. It kind of break down because this isn’t directly equivalent to two people debating before the Roman senate, but western philosophy really didn’t care much about such superficial differences. I can’t think of the phrase but there is the platonic ideal of an argument and individual who voiced it. Something about after an argument has been spoken it, as in the argument, needs to be addressed directly not the person who said it. PS: Similar idea in a different context don’t judge a book by its cover. Not directly relevant, but I find it fascinating how often the idea of superficial as unimportant is used while people focus on it so much. Sort of a humanity has changed less than you might think in the last several thousand years kind of thing.