2 ms·
> That doesn’t make the correct usage in this context wrong Well, it does if I'm being a bit snarky, and not using that snark as a way of dismissing a claim. I
by robertlagrant 3y ago
> That doesn’t make the correct usage in this context wrong
Well, it does if I'm being a bit snarky, and not using that snark as a way of dismissing a claim. I'm saying there is no justification for the claim, and that it's taken far more words to claim the thing than it would be to supply a simple disproving example.
> or more importantly prevent what you said from both being a logical fallacy
No, something being not ad hominem doesn't prevent it from being a logical fallacy, but that's not how reason works. You disprove. You don't say, "Well this criticism failed but that doesn't prove it's valid!"
> I personally would have apologized a while ago, but you do you.
But... this is also rude. More so than a little bit of snark.
Start again. What are you trying to achieve here?
- Retric 3y ago> Well, it does if I'm being a bit snarky… No, being snarky in no way changes what’s going on. > a simple disproving example Which I provided an hour ago and you haven’t responded, thus disproving your argument here with an example. > is also rude. If you acknowledge you’ve been rude then apology is appropriate. Simply ignoring rudeness is poor manors as otherwise people can’t improve. Instead proper manors is to bring up the mistake and offer a minor correction. In person subtle body language is useful, but in text the only option is to be more explicit though still indirect. Thus what I said was quite literally the opposite of being rude.
- robertlagrant 3y agoI'm not ignoring what you said; I just didn't see it. This is an internet forum, not a live conversation. If you assume that proves something...I don't know. Not much point interacting with someone whose imagination exceeds their grasp on reality.
- LeonB 3y agoThanks for trying, @retric. You were very patient.