3 ms·
smithsonian on this discovery: > The tiny pup was likely a beloved pet, not an animal bred for hunting or herding uhh those aren't the only three possibilitie
by kragen 3y ago
smithsonian on this discovery:
> The tiny pup was likely a beloved pet, not an animal bred for hunting or herding
uhh those aren't the only three possibilities tho
wikipedia on the history of actual chihuahuas:
> In a letter written in 1520, Hernan Cortés wrote that the Aztecs raised and sold little dogs as food.
and in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xoloitzcuintle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xoloitzcuintle:
> Sixteenth-century Spanish accounts tell of large numbers of dogs being served at banquets.[5] Aztec merchant feasts could have 80–100 turkeys and 20–40 dogs served as food.[6]
how would you distinguish beloved pets from food animals? well, plausibly by quantity, or by the form of burial. perhaps the villa only had one or two lap dogs?
> The pint-sized pup is one of 15 small- to medium-sized dogs discovered at the villa.
uhh eww
- whythre 3y agoEww? Lots of nobles kept kennels.
- tokai 3y agoI think kragen is joking that with amount of dogs found one could just as well argue that the dogs were livestock and not pets.
- notjulianjaynes 3y agoThe illustration in the article looks a bit like a turnspit dog too. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turnspit_dog https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turnspit_dog
- TylerE 3y agoThat's fascinating, especially this bit at the end: The gene for chondrodysplasia in various short-legged breeds has been confirmed to trace back to a single ancestral mutation [presumably from Egypt, as the Egyptians since short legged dogs had been found in Egyptian households dating back thousands of years. Egypt was also thousands of years in advance of modern pet keeping by quasi-domesticating Ball Pythons.
- civilitty 3y ago> how would you distinguish beloved pets from food animals? well, plausibly by quantity, or by the form of burial. perhaps the villa only had one or two lap dogs? The context of the burial is always important. The bones from cooked animals would most often end up in huge quantities in a midden rather than buried alone or with their owners. Any objects found with the remains like a collar or harness are also useful details. The condition of the skeleton itself usually tells the story: pets are generally in the best shape. Beasts of burden have signs of repetitive stress while animals that were eaten most often have cut marks on their bones where tools were used to clean the carcass and prepare the meat. An animal like a dog might be prepared bone-in so the chemistry of the bones themselves can also indicate whether they were cooked or not.
- kragen 3y agoyeah, presumably the animal found wasn't cooked, but you don't eat livestock that died from illness unless you're starving
- KeplerBoy 3y agoRomans simply didn't eat dogs if there were other sources of food around. If they would have, chances are we still would do it today.
- kragen 3y agoit is true, as far as i know, that we have no records of the romans eating dogs but nothing about the romans is simple there are many foods the romans commonly ate (in rome, during at least some of its near-millennium of culinary change) that few or none of their modern descendants do. these include silphium, garum, liquamen, mallow leaves, marinated sow udders, peacock, flamingo, emmer, lamprey, lamprey semen, sea urchins, bitter vetch, dormice, azerole, open-arse, and raisin wine; most of these were considered delicacies, which is how we know about the romans eating them at all we do know that the romans did ritually sacrifice dogs in rome, and they claim that the oscans (another italic people) roasted dogs as part of a ritual sacrifice, so romans eating dogs, even in rome, seems plausible to me moreover, we're talking about an outlying province, 1400 km from the capital, with the potential for significantly different local customs — even if there were no oscans in the legions