3 ms·
There is far more than just 3 options and suggesting any specific option is again falsely limiting the discussion. (1) Government ownership, (2) ownership by a
by Retric 3y ago
There is far more than just 3 options and suggesting any specific option is again falsely limiting the discussion.
(1) Government ownership, (2) ownership by a single rich person, (3) ownership by a nonprofit, (4) ownership by the employees, (5) ownership by the readers…
However, suggesting just one additional options focuses excessive attention to that specific option. Mentioning how much Twitter has changed going from a public company to a private one owned by a single wealthy person is only barely related to the underlying argument here. Namely, that you need to consider many options and their individual tradeoffs not just 2 bad options.
- robertlagrant 3y ago(1) is state ownership; all the others are private. Those are the same two options I listed; you just mentioned some subcategories of private.
- Retric 3y agoYou didn’t set the categories, the original post was: “Imagine if — on top of that - we let the undeserving rich invest their wealth in things such as: - owning media” You can have private ownership without the owners automatically being rich. Further the owners could be rich without qualifying as undeserving rich by whatever metric the post’s author had in mind. That said, thanks for providing my point ;-)
- robertlagrant 3y ago> You didn’t set the categories This whole conversation has been about my "false dichotomy" of state and private ownership. E.g. from LeonB: > I mean of course — who should own media.. we have precisely two choices, and no possibility to imagine anything else! What you’ve put forward is known as a false dichotomy. That is a situation where you present two options as if they are the only options.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Retric 3y agoNo, you used the words “Private people” in direct response to someone complaining about ownership of the media by the wealthy. That’s not equivalent to all forms of non governmental ownership in that context. Charities are not owned by private people quite literally as they can’t liquidate assets etc. You can be convinced of Theft if you take assets from a charity you set up. If you want to now redefine your point as all forms of non government ownership then that’s simply a strawman arguemnt in terms of the person you where replying to.
- DrScientist 3y agoYou are focusing on the wrong thing. The danger in media control is not the public/private axis, but the monopoly/ plurality axis and the truth/falsehood axis.