4 ms·
All these claims of W8 being "unusable"... I don't understand the use of this word. Once in a blue moon, there comes an event that makes the Internet completel
by freehunter 15y ago
All these claims of W8 being "unusable"... I don't understand the use of this word.
Once in a blue moon, there comes an event that makes the Internet completely unbearable to me, no matter where I go. New, high profile product launches are typically this way. The outrage on the Internet when the iPod was announced, the iPhone, the iPad. When WP7 came out. A new update to Ubuntu. Any change in Google or Facebook. All labeled by the Internet as horrible failures. The last version is always the best (until you get used to the newest one).
There exists a set of loudmouths with nothing better to than rile up the hivemind, and rile they do. A potentially good product is dead before it even goes live, based on misconceptions, "viral" videos, and preconceived notions based on misreported facts and wild, irresponsible speculation. Imagine if the Internet culture was around when DOS was replaced by Windows.
Microsoft knows what they're doing. And if they don't, they'll figure it out pretty quick, or they'll die. Guess what? This is a beta "preview" release. No Windows has launched without a tutorial since at least Windows 95. If Windows 8 is a failure, it'll be because of wild, speculative bullshit, not because it's a bad product. Using a computer is not intuitive by itself. All your complaints would be equally valid going from Windows 8 to Windows 7.
- acqq 15y ago"Microsoft knows what they're doing." D-oh! And remember: under no circumstances mention Windows Vista.
- freehunter 15y agoSee, this is what I'm talking about. This is the bullshit hyperbole I mentioned. You claim Microsoft doesn't know what they're doing, yet they are wildly successful still. Windows Vista is a great example of a product that died for the exact reasons I described.
- acqq 15y agofreehunter: "If Windows 8 is a failure, it'll be because of wild, speculative bullshit, not because it's a bad product." acqq: "Vista" freehunter: "Windows Vista is a great example of a product that died for the exact reasons I described." I still don't see how you can be sure that "Windows 8" is not going to be the new Vista. You claimed that "complainers" make Microsoft's OS's fail, but the truth is -- Vista was bad OS not because of complainers but because of poor execution. The whole process of failed development is properly documented, all with the need to "start over" and "to release anything" fast after too much time went by. That MSFT can earn money because of lock-in and a lot of companies that are practically forced to subscribe is independent fact to the quality of the particular OS release. Or the quality of their UI decisions -- not once they had to "undo" some of their UI "improvements."
- freehunter 15y agoVista was not Microsoft's best OS, but it was (and is) nowhere near as unusable as people claim. A few big problems it suffered: its minimum requirements were not generally met by the hardware it was running on. This is partly Microsoft's fault (for authoring "Vista Capable" stickers to underpowered hardware) part the fault of the manufacturer (for making said hardware) and part the fault of the user or whoever was making the decision to purchase (for buying low quality hardware). Another issue was the sidebar, which hogged memory. Turning it off is enough to fix most systems which exceed the minimum spec. The last major issue was driver support (which was the downfall of ME as well). Manufacturers assumed that they could use the same (or very similar) drivers for Vista, which wasn't the case. Result: poor hardware performance. Vista had development problems, but it was released in a working state. All they did was cut a few features (which still haven't surfaced) at no true cost to the performance of the OS. Word got out online that Vista had a few problems, and since the Microsoft hate was reaching a peak (mainly because of Apple's advertising), it was the new punching bag. People followed the hate without listening to reasonable explanations. If you say W8 is the "new Vista", in your mind and in the minds of those who listen to you, this is already true no matter what Microsoft does. At this point, you're just spouting wild, speculative bullshit because it fits with what you want to think. Wait until the baby is born, don't condemn it to hell based on the ultrasound.
- acqq 15y agoWith Vista Microsoft implemented the "new look" with assumptions of "working acceptably" only with the most powerful graphics cards. Even Windows 8 doesn't misuse the graphics hardware like Vista did. There's nothing more needed to prove that your premise "MSFT knows what they are doing" is false. freehunter: "Wait until the baby is born, don't condemn it to hell based on the ultrasound" Ultrasound can actually precisely diagnose the foetuses that certainly won't be healthy. To be sure it will be healthy is the harder task. "Condemn to hell"? I don't think you help your arguments with such language. I certainly won't write in this thread anymore. Too flamy here.
- Piskvorrr 15y agoWell, they seem to know what they're doing: pushing a unified, one-size-fits-all interface (and I've tried to honestly use it, on a desktop, for a day; without a touch interface, it feels very clumsy). The trouble with one-size-fits-all is obvious: it never does. Note that the linked site is not only "riling up the hivemind," but also proposing solutions to the UX problems as present in the Consumer Preview (because there's nothing else publicly out there to base the suggestions on). That's constructive criticism if I ever saw any - and loyalty to the brand as well: that site doesn't say "eh wind0z3 iz teh suxxorz, hate hate," but "I like Windows, but these are the specific problems I see with Win8 as it's currently presented; this I propose to fix the issues".
- freehunter 15y agoThe solution in the article is "add a taskbar" or "bring the desktop back". That's not fixing Windows 8, that's completely ignoring it.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoTaskbars are very useful on mouse-driven interfaces. That's why they are so common.
- freehunter 15y agoIs it that? Or is it that taskbars are so common on mouse driven interfaces, and that is why they are useful? In other words, are they useful because they're inherently better, or are they useful because that's what you're used to?
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoDoes it matter?
- freehunter 15y agoI would argue yes. Why stick with a broken design? Just because you're used to it? What about people who aren't used to it? If there's a better way, why not strive for it?
- jinushaun 15y agoYour comment leads me to believe you have not used Windows 8. Metro, at least in the DP and CP releases, are very cumbersome with mouse and keyboard. These problems go beyond "unfinished features in beta". It's not glitchy animations and missing features. The whole paradigm is rotten.
- freehunter 15y agoI actually use Windows 8 at home in a virtual machine under Ubuntu 11.10, I have no problems with it. This is why I cannot understand the reaction of "unusable". Is the problem moving around the start screen? Use the scroll wheel. Is the problem swiping to log in? Press a key on your keyboard. Is the problem exiting Metro apps? Press the Windows key (which has had the same behavior for almost 20 years, bringing you back to the start menu). Windows 8 feel eminently usable with a mouse and a keyboard. When it comes to pouring water on the Internet rage machine, I feel like I should be paid by Microsoft. I'm not praising them, it just seems like facts and reason go out the window when it comes to how much vitriolic and vicious hatred people can pile on. It doesn't matter if your statement is true, it will become true as you keep repeating it. The only thing that is different is that it is different. It's no less usable than the tired "desktop" metaphor.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoI think a lot of people are forgetting that Windows 95 had to have this animation. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UxwAlqCCmk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UxwAlqCCmk And still there were a lot of people who eschewed the Start menu and used Program Manager for a long time. One can expect similar cues for the new OS.
- freehunter 15y agoI've long argued the correlation between DOS and Windows vs Windows 7 and Windows 8. It seems no one cares. No, this time will be different, this time people can't change their computing habits.
- bunderbunder 15y agoChanging your computing habits may not bee too hard; the problem is changing your computer hardware. Like in TFA, it's that Windows 8 has been so focused on providing a compelling interface for touchscreen users that it fails to provide a decent interface for keyboard&mouse users. The problem runs so deep that Win8 takes away much of what we've come up with in the course of decades' worth of experimentation with how to use a keyboard and mouse to interact with computers, and instead asks kb&m users to emulate touchscreen idioms such as swipe gestures. The problem isn't insurmountable - the fixes are actually quite small, as the blog that hosts TFA points out pretty often. In fact, I'd like to point out that there wasn't quite so much of this hubbub over Windows 8 developer preview. This is because developer preview had a decent (not necessarily great in Metro, but decent overall) interaction model for users of normal computers, which Microsoft subsequently removed for no apparent reason.
- freehunter 15y agoI would say it continues to build upon what Windows 7 (and even Windows 95) was doing. Instead of a desktop full of shortcuts and a start menu full of shortcuts, you now have a full screen start menu to replace all that. Like the desktop, the start screen scales to your screen resolution, allowing more icons when the resolution is higher. It lets you scroll around all your shortcuts and allows you to see relevant information about them without even opening them (replacing the sidebar, which was the cause of quite a few "Vista is slow!" complaints). You can use the Windows key to simultaneously perform the action of "open the start menu" and "show the desktop". I'm not sure I understand the point about mouse gestures. Mouse gestures have been around for a lot longer than Windows 8 (see, Opera browser). If you're specifically referring to the unlock screen, just press a key on your keyboard. This will likely be included in a tutorial for the release. If you mean mouse gestures to perform shortcut actions, Windows 8 has a pretty extensive keyboard shortcut list for power users. http://www.windows8news.com/2012/03/12/microsoft-release-windows-8-keyboard-shortcut-list/ http://www.windows8news.com/2012/03/12/microsoft-release-win...
- jimbobimbo 15y agoDev and consumer preview are out there for a reason - MS wants to hear a feedback. So here, you have it. It might be not a feedback they hoped for, but it is feedback nonetheless.
- freehunter 15y agoFeedback is one thing. "Scrap the whole concept" is unrealistic. Even the solutions presented in the article would rip the heart out of Metro (adding a task bar and a desktop).