4 ms·
Or only burning coal at night. Once solar is significantly cheaper than coal and demand pricing kicks in, a lot of time-shifting of energy use could occur. Ri
by saalweachter 15y ago
Or only burning coal at night.
Once solar is significantly cheaper than coal and demand pricing kicks in, a lot of time-shifting of energy use could occur. Right now, night-time electricity is cheaper because demand is lower at night, but if the supply of daylight electricity increases dramatically, any activity which currently benefits from cheap nighttime electricity could be shifted back to the daylight hours.
Data centers currently consume something like 2% of electricity -- it is probably possible to shift at least some of that to bright, sunny days. It may stop being cost-effective to run night shifts at factories, especially if your manufacturing process is energy-intensive. We might end up charging our electric cars at our offices during the day instead of over night at our homes. It'd be pretty silly to fill a battery with solar electricity during the day just to transfer it to another battery at night.
Even without batteries, solar energy could still pick up a lot of our current nighttime energy usage because a lot of our nighttime energy usage doesn't actually have to be at night.
- rmc 15y agoI'm now thinking of amazon EC2's 'spot instances' where you launch an instance, do some computation then shut down, but only if the price per hour is less than some choosen point. (Basically a stock market for computation). If solar took off, i can see a correlation between price per hour and sunny days, as more machines are turned on when it's cheaper to run, hence increasing supply, and decreasing price. :P
- count 15y agoThis already happens, both at the energy generation level (power companies broker energy futures (excess supply/demand) between each other - see Enron for more) and at the energy consumer level (big businesses like refineries and foundries and the like pay less for electricity pulled in off-peak hours).
- polshaw 15y agoTo be clear-- the reason energy is cheap at night is not JUST because it is used less-- it is also because there are certain continuous energy sources. Nuclear power, geothermal, tidal, wave and wind power are all producing energy round the clock and if you don't harvest it, it's lost. We are not heading towards a world where we have a single power source (solar), and most of our power uses cannot be rescheduled. As fossil fuels are one of the few sources which can be turned on and off at our choosing, I would expect they will function to fill in temporary gaps between supply and demand once renewables capacity is large enough to take the average load. I don't see these gaps occurring predominantly at night.
- icebraining 15y agoYou can still store extra energy to buffer those gaps. Where I live, pumped-storage hydroelectricity has probably a great future. Thermal storage seems to reasonably efficient too, although I'm not quite sure how much of what I've seen is a little "too enthusiastic".
- dctoedt 15y ago> ... Nuclear power, geothermal, tidal, wave and wind power are all producing energy round the clock and if you don't harvest it, it's lost. This isn't true of nuclear power plants; the fission rate, and thus the heat generation rate, can be throttled up and down as needed. In pressurized water reactors this happens automatically as the throttle is opened and closed, thus increasing or decreasing output from the "steam side" of the heat-exchange boilers, a.k.a. steam generators [1]. (In a prior life I was a Navy nuclear engineering officer.) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressurized_water_reactor#Control http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pressurized_water_reactor#Contr...
- tsotha 15y agoThat's true, but does this make the fuel last longer, and anyway what are fuel costs as a percentage of total operational costs? My impression is it doesn't make sense to operate a nuclear reactor at less than full power.
- dctoedt 15y ago> does this make the fuel last longer Yes. Heat is generated by fission of fissile material such as uranium. Fuel rods have X amount of fissile material in them. Higher power -> faster depletion of the fissile material. > what are fuel costs as a percentage of total operational costs? Around 30%, according to the Nuclear Energy Institute. This compares with 80% for coal, natural gas, and oil.[2] > My impression is it doesn't make sense to operate a nuclear reactor at less than full power I would think that'd be true of almost any machinery, but that's almost a tautology: You design your machinery for an optimized balance of performance versus wear-and-tear, then try to operate at (what you call) "full power" as much as you can, so as to reap maximum value from your investment. In any event, the original comment was that excess power is inevitably generated by nuclear plants (at least during some time periods) and therefore must be dumped somehow. That's not the case; nuclear plants can be throttled up and down as needed. [2] http://www.nei.org/resourcesandstats/nuclear_statistics/costs/ http://www.nei.org/resourcesandstats/nuclear_statistics/cost...
- jpitz 15y ago> Or only burning coal at night. Coal power is a base load technology. Spin up time for a coal plant is too long for it to work well for night time use only. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load_power_plant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_load_power_plant
- ippisl 15y agoGE recently announced a faster natural gas based generator. 61% efficiency and can ramp up supply at 50mega-watts per minute. http://www.fastcoexist.com/1678064/ges-jet-engine-inspired-fossil-fuel-power-plant-is-made-to-work-with-renewables http://www.fastcoexist.com/1678064/ges-jet-engine-inspired-f... So there can be a decent enough complement to cheap solar power.
- tsotha 15y agoThat's true for pulverized coal, but gassified coal could be used like natural gas.
- danielharan 15y agoData centers most assuredly do not use 2% of electricity. That's a made up stat by fossil fuel industry lobbyists and repeated by server vendors.