5 ms·
But most of those R&D costs are for getting "FDA" approval. I don't see why India (or anyone, really) should pay for lining the pockets of the USA's inefficient
by tripzilch 15y ago
But most of those R&D costs are for getting "FDA" approval. I don't see why India (or anyone, really) should pay for lining the pockets of the USA's inefficient and corrupt bureaucratic machinery.
Or I could be wrong and those $12B really goes into equipment and lab workers wages, but you won't blame me for finding it real hard to believe until I see at least a rough breakdown of how those costs are summed up.
From the article: "Bayer tried to justify its high price by making claims of high R&D costs, but refused to provide any details".
That either means they don't know themselves, or it means that the larger part of the budget got "lost" in requesting approval forms paper pushing greasing cogs and lobbying politicians.
- leonth 15y agoI am not terribly familiar with the process, but I assure you it includes: early computational simulations of the prospective molecules; testing on lab animals; testing on healthy people; testing on small (a few hundred) number of patients; large scale (a few thousand) multi-centre trials across the whole world (if you want to sell it to the whole world, that is). This process takes quite a number of years. Now imagine how many labs, hospitals, scientists, doctors, statisticians, patients (oh they do get compensation), and auxiliary clerical workers need to be paid for the whole process.
- betterth 15y agoThe majority of the money goes into Phase III clinical trials. Don't bash the FDA - they're the most evidence based, scientifically minded regulatory body in our government. Preclinical and Phase I - II trials aren't too expensive, in the order of millions of dollars. But also remember, for every ~10,000 candidates that enter preclinical trials, about 1-2 will actually pass FDA approval. The billion number isn't just for one drug, it's also for the 10,000 failures that you had to weed through to find that one drug. Phase I is safety trials in healthy humans (young males generally). Phase II starts using it in the target population (the sick) and begins looking at dosing requirements and preliminary efficacy data. But the big one, Phase III, that's the big group, expensive, efficacy trial. This is the trial that has to prove, beyond a shadow of a doubt scientifically, that the drug does what they say it does. A good Phase III trial can cost in the hundreds of millions of dollars easy. I've heard of $250,000,000 Phase III trials before. If "the most rigorous evidence requirement in the world" is your example of "inefficient and corrupt", than I guess we'll just disagree. But the FDA is the most strict drug regulatory body in the world, and the amount of evidence for efficacy that they require from the industry is truly impressive and truly does warrant the billions price tag.
- Produce 15y ago>But the FDA is the most strict drug regulatory body in the world, and the amount of evidence for efficacy that they require from the industry is truly impressive and truly does warrant the billions price tag. Funny how there are so many SSRI's on the market. Funny how this model results in the conclusion that it's a good idea to give kids amphetamines when they are known neurotoxins. Funny how medical marijuana is taking such a long time to break through into the mainstream. Politics play a huge role in business and tend to turn it into a theater of the absurd.
- driverdan 15y ago> Funny how there are so many SSRI's on the market. Why? What's wrong with SSRIs? > Funny how this model results in the conclusion that it's a good idea to give kids amphetamines when they are known neurotoxins. Giving amphetamines to children is certainly debatable but amphetamines are not neurotoxic. Methamphetamines are neurotoxic, especially in recreational doses, but non-methylated amphetamines are not. > Funny how medical marijuana is taking such a long time to break through into the mainstream. Entirely different issue.
- betterth 15y agoFunny thing about meth is that it's not that dangerous -- it's almost identical to adderral. The methyl group (meth-amphetamine vs amphetamine) really only improves the ability of the drug to cross the blood-brain barrier. It's basically a form of adderal with a slightly stronger bioavailability curve. The reason why meth is a public health issue while addy arguably is not is mainly because requiring a Doctor rx, using an exact dosage with no refills, combined with the purity and safety of GMP-produced drugs, eliminates most of the issues behind meth. I was shocked when I found how just how similar meth and adderall truly are.
- dlytle 15y agoAs an Adderall user, I can back this up. The symptoms of use are very similar to meth. Ever seen that "meth jingle" ad? The whole "pulling hairs out of your face, cleaning everything, etc" pitch is spot on to Adderall side effects. The difference is that Adderall side effects are dramatically more mild due to (as betterth said) a properly calibrated and reliable dose. Also, with Adderall, you can't afford to just take more to offset withdrawal symptoms, because you only have so much. The temptation to take another as it wears off is pretty substantial, especially for long-time users.
- SystemOut 15y agoDon't you think that the drug companies would have found cheaper ways to develop drugs since they've realized that people will still pay them? That would lead to even higher profits. It's insanely difficult to bring a new drug to market. Imagine all of the crazy combinations of people that take them and if you miss one small group that has an adverse reaction you could be talking 1000s of people that are lining up to sue you out of existence or if you're in another company the regulatory body doing it for them. People around the world benefit immensely from our "inefficient and corrupt bureaucratic machinery" because they get safe drugs. Also, from the article, "Bayer tried to justify its high price by making claims of high R&D costs, but refused to provide any details". This is just plain rhetoric plain and simple. You see politicians do this everyday because there is no real way to refute it.