3 ms·
>Neither is true. If—and given the history of such episodes, that’s a big if—journals end up retracting the three papers Tessier-Lavigne has said he has agreed
by gruez 3y ago
>Neither is true. If—and given the history of such episodes, that’s a big if—journals end up retracting the three papers Tessier-Lavigne has said he has agreed to retract (two in Science and one in Cell), the number will represent less than a tenth of a percent of the retractions we expect to see this year. We at Retraction Watch, which tracks retracted papers, estimate that figure to be about 5,000—a tiny fraction of how many retractions should happen but don’t. And the careers of most researchers whose names are on the retractions that do happen haven’t suffered a scratch. The ones whose papers haven’t been retracted have even fewer worries.
I don't get it. They're just declaring that there should be 5000 retractions, and because only a tiny fraction of that actually ends up being retracted, that science doesn't correct itself? Where did this number come from? Is it just a list of studies with sus numbers? I feel like the authors (founders of retraction watch) is doing a massive disservice to their cause by casually skipping over this.
- xorbax 3y agoNo. They say that 5000 retractions happened and it's unlikely to be the total number. There are informational internet hyperlinks you can follow, and a list of references.