5 ms·
I suppose you are too young to remember "picking winners", Harold Wilson, British Leyland, Red Robbo... Or more directly, Grundy and their NewBrain vs Acorn...
by gaius 15y ago
I suppose you are too young to remember "picking winners", Harold Wilson, British Leyland, Red Robbo... Or more directly, Grundy and their NewBrain vs Acorn... Historically, government meddling in industry in the UK has been a disaster.
- adaml_623 15y agoSerious question. Was it a disaster or did they just pick the losing team? Sometimes the government picking a loser can still cause a market to expand.
- gaius 15y agoWell, they picked one winner - Leyland - and force-merged them with all the losers, in the hope that Leyland's magic would somehow infuse them. Instead, it destroyed them all. Some of the brands, like Jaguar, Daimler, Land Rover, etc live on. But not as British companies.
- maratd 15y ago> Was it a disaster or did they just pick the losing team. The government always picks the losing team. The winning team doesn't want anything to do with the government.
- GFischer 15y agoWhat went wrong with Leyland? It's a very respected trademark here in Uruguay, we still have some Leyland buses in operation here, including 1949 Leyland Olympics (!!!) It's even on Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leyland-MCW_Olympic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leyland-MCW_Olympic "The Olympic was popular in Montevideo, with 240 entering service in the 1950s and 1960s. 50 of these were new to the Montevideo local authority, most of which passed to major independent and the other customer CUTCSA on privatisation. Some of the 240 were still in use as late as 2001 including a 1951 EL40 in use as a driver trainer." Edit: kind-of-answered simultaneously here http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3698064 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3698064 while I was writing the question :) "they picked one winner - Leyland - and force-merged them with all the losers"
- arethuza 15y agoBL was responsible for some of the most ghastly cars ever created, including: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morris_Marina http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morris_Marina http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin_Allegro http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin_Allegro
- calibraxis 15y agoThe US government picked winners like Intel, saving the US semiconductor industry through protectionist policies. (http://www.forbes.com/2003/10/10/1010grovepinnacor.html http://www.forbes.com/2003/10/10/1010grovepinnacor.html) In fact, the US technology industry was developed through enormous subsidy, from transistors to the internet. Economist Ha-Joon Chang discusses that's how powerful nations develop. The entrepreneurial Japanese government's first forays into the auto industry were failures, but of course they kept at it, learning from failure. That's the nature of investment, as any HN reader should know.
- Symmetry 15y agoJapan's record isn't that good - MITI tried to strangle both Japanese auto exports and the semiconductor industry in their cradle because they didn't conform to Japan's development plan.
- astrodust 15y agoSony's initial plan was rice cookers.
- arethuza 15y agoMy experience of government "investment" (both UK and EU) in the technology sector is that is has been the most frightful waste of money imaginable. It's not down to lack of money - but the way it has been spent.
- astrodust 15y agoYou have to remember how many failures it takes to have a big success. For every Intel there's a wasteland of shoulda-been companies that are dead and forgotten, with billions invested having gone up in smoke. Of course, when it's private venture capital that's behind this, people don't seem to complain as much.
- arethuza 15y agoHonestly, I've been in a couple of startups (including one that got a lot of funding from VCs and going public) and I've never seen anything like the inefficiency that was normal in the public sector projects that I worked on. Not that I'm against public funding of research - I'm absolutely not. But my experiences of public sector research funding on "large" projects completely put me off working in that sector (so much so that I left academia to co-found a start-up).
- teamonkey 15y agoI'm not quite sure why the government's choices back then would have any bearing on their choices 30 years later? It's not the same people. It's not even the same generation.