3 ms·
>how much of the education market has been taken over by Chromebooks. Why is this even a ting wherever this is(US?)? Mandating school kids use a platform owne
by FirmwareBurner 3y ago
>how much of the education market has been taken over by Chromebooks.
Why is this even a ting wherever this is(US?)? Mandating school kids use a platform owned by Google, a corporation specialized in advertising and data harvesting, feels like letting McDonalds's and Coca-Cola be in charge of the school cafeteria and educating kids about a balanced diet.
Am I taking crazy pills, or am I missing something and I misunderstood the situation?
- rrdharan 3y agoIf you want kids to have laptops - which is really the questionable thing to begin with - then Chromebooks are safer and easier to secure against the typical kinds of threats a school cares about than Windows PCs and cheaper than Macs. I think a bigger question is why kids need laptops at all..
- yeahmaybe333 3y agoIt's pretty much this way anyway, the largest shareholders of CC and Mc Donalds are also the largest shareholders of largest outsource catering providers.
- 1MachineElf 3y ago>a corporation specialized in advertising and data harvesting You could be describing Microsoft in 2023, e.g. Chromium-based Edge, Windows 11 start menu ads, Xbox Live background services being integral to Windows even on government/corporate computers, the unholy marriage of Bing & OpenAI, Windows Live ID, outlook.com, every corporation being cool with putting their data into Azure/Office 365, etc.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoHow does whataboutism make an argument for the existing issue?
- moritzwarhier 3y agoIn this case I find the argument relevant. Why? In my country (and I assume it's similar in others), Microsoft has and traditionally always had schools, hospitals and governments, pretty much the whole public sector in tight grip. There is a lengthy history behind that which includes numerous reasons. Parent comment was making the comparison because GP pointed out the absurdity of forcing kids into Google ecosystem and exposing them to data harvesting. When the original story was about MS and they behave in similar or the same ways, I believe that it's very relevant. Two wrongs don't make one right though: students at a public school, their data as well as their mindshare, should not mandatorily be sold to the highest/lowest bidder.
- wmf 3y agoGoogle, Microsoft, and Apple are all evil in their own ways. Chrome OS is significantly more reliable than Windows, macOS, or desktop Linux and Chromebooks tend to be cheap (although Windows craptops are catching up).
- justinclift 3y ago> Chrome OS is significantly more reliable ... Only for the first 2-3 years, at which point it expires and the kids need a new laptop.
- bzzzt 3y agoSome Chromebooks go far in the 2030's with update support so it's not a given anymore.
- thehappypm 3y agoBecause they're the best tool for the job. It's not like we're replacing healthy lunches with Coke. It's either Chromebooks, or expensive, clunky, virus-prone, impossible-to-administer Windows PCs.
- vbezhenar 3y agoWhy not OpenBSD? Free, secure and great to learn UNIX.
- anotherhue 3y agoThere's more important topics on the curriculum than 1970s OS design. Clear speech, thought, language skills, comprehension, critical thinking, mathematics, geography, history -- you know, life's syscalls.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago> Clear speech, thought, language skills, comprehension, critical thinking, mathematics, geography, history Aren't books and a bottom of the barrel PC with internet access all you need to learn those? Why a Chromebook? NUC PCs are cheaper and it's easier to replace the mouse and keyboard that kids break.
- anotherhue 3y agoBecause any second spent farting around with the machine instead of using it to learn about the topic at hand steals from the topic. Because teachers aren't sysadmins, because even if they were they aren't going to admin 30 different laptops that the students have installed god-knows-what on. This solution has to be military grade in reliability and simplicity and unless/until someone develops a hardware certification programme, a meaningful long-term-support plan, a remote administration solution, a security focused browser and a hosted identity system, all in a package that costs ~$200 new then it's going to be CrOS. Don't forget the marketing spend needed even if you did tick the above boxes. No one is complaining that their text-books are not turing complete, just stop viewing these devices as general purpose machines and view them as the child-focused-appliances that they are. Like Teslas.
- whyagaintango 3y agoIt is also popular in some parts of Scandinavia. Why you ask? As a school teacher I can see - for ages no proper trained IT staff in schools - I know better linux, rpi than them. Heck they read IT news from cnet.com - managing+ security in local servers is very difficult - money for space - google edu is/was almost free - HIPAA equivalent rules - though everyone will talk and tell linux, libreoffice - the polishing and consistency of chromeos is great (for cheap $150 laptop) - ideally linux foundation or some one should have made a 'school appliance' but ...
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>- for ages no proper trained IT staff in schools Excuse me but how the hell is this a problem in Scandinavia? Don't you guys have the best schools in the world? Even in Eastern Europe 20 years ago we had sys-admins in schools, and we were told that Scandinavian schools do it so much bater because they fund them the way the US funds its military.
- whyagaintango 3y agoSchools are ok. IT not ok. There is a mishmash of I hate/love google mantra. Some want to do local but most no have the skillset to run servers ZFS etc. Either some idiot in administration then does outsourcing to remote MSP that support Windows.
- rvense 3y agoThe startup I work for sells to education customers in Scandinavia. It is my impression that schools are either "Microsoft schools" or "Google schools" (these are the terms used). The Danish data protection agency made some ruling against Google that ought to have meant, if the existing rules had been followed, that kids weren't allowed to use Chromebooks, but the schools said they couldn't teach kids without them, so the rules weren't followed. Yes, it's great.
- tapoxi 3y agoBecause schools need cheap laptops that are easy to centrally manage by a single platform. Google also has a Workspace for Education suite that includes all the Google Docs stuff and teacher tools (Google Classroom). They also have a no ads or data collected policy. It's very enticing. There's no real competition. The closest is Microsoft but Windows machines are much more expensive to manage and have worse performance on low-end hardware. Let's imagine what HN wants - a Linux laptop running Firefox and LibreOffice. You're not going to get fleet management features, collaborative document editing, or built-in classroom management tools. Kids are still going to Google to search for things (and use ChatGPT).
- sliken 3y agoNo mandate. However chromebooks when they came out were a HUGE improvement over low end windows laptops. They are crazy durable, include instructions for when you pour soda into the keyboard, are durable enough to be thrown, leave a mark on the ceiling, and still survive. They run well even on old hardware, 4GB ram is plenty. They also don't get viruses, don't require any local expertise, don't require backups, don't require any software licenses, no virus scanning, and have minimal requirements from central IT. If a student manages to kill one you can literally just hand them another and say login. So the savings in hardware costs, reduced support costs, and the "it just works" design is pretty attractive to school districts. Who'd have thought a $180 laptop could be durable, useful, no crapware/malware/ransomware, and last a decade? Sure it would be nice if it didn't depend on google, but nobody else was stepping up. My kid has had three over the last decade, the last we paid $50 to keep when she graduated. It's still being used years later.