5 ms·
> I'm surprised the prediction markets don't seem to be reacting. Where can we look at prediction markets on this? For those of us who aren't familiar. I'm ve
by crazygringo 3y ago
> I'm surprised the prediction markets don't seem to be reacting.
Where can we look at prediction markets on this? For those of us who aren't familiar.
I'm very curious -- because unlike sports scores or political elections, this seems like such a hard thing to define a prediction market around, because what is the exact threshold you're defining and what is the threshold of proof of that thing and on what date is that decided?
- staunton 3y agoMetaculus has some markets on LK-99, for example
- asdfman123 3y agoThose rules are defined in the actual bet. I think it was "three replications of room temperature superconductivity by X date" or something like that. I looked closely because I very much wanted to bet tens of thousands of dollars on "no", but I couldn't because I'm in the US. The two outcomes would be I'd make a lot of money or humanity would make the biggest breakthrough in generations.
- tshaddox 3y ago> I think it was "three replications of room temperature superconductivity by X date" or something like that. That doesn’t sound like a sufficient market resolution condition. Surely it would need to be something like “declared by specific Party X to be a room-temperature superconductor” where Party X is sufficiently trusted by all market participants.
- asdfman123 3y agoI was worried about that too before making the bet, but I realized I couldn't do it anyway and stopped worrying about it. You can find the whole resolution criteria here if you want: https://manifold.markets/QuantumObserver/will-the-lk99-room-temp-ambient-pre https://manifold.markets/QuantumObserver/will-the-lk99-room-...
- crazygringo 3y agoThanks. And wow, that's as fuzzy as I was afraid it would be: > ...Willing to adjust this criterion after receiving more info from relevant theorists/experimentalists... > ...I don't intend to require that replications be published in a peer-reviewed journal... However, I do intend to wait a few weeks/months to resolve so that any pre-print can be adequately investigated... > ...Since high Tc superconductivity is not my specific field of expertise, I'm willing to defer to a consensus of subject matter experts on whether a pre-print is convincing or not, and I am willing to contact some beyond the usual twitter personalities... In other words, if there's any kind of gray area in the results, it's going to be whatever this person decides, whenever they want to decide it. Definitely not something I would ever put money behind.
- asdfman123 3y agoYeah, I was definitely concerned about losing my money to a technicality.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HDThoreaun 3y agoManifold is a funny money market, polymarket is the only one with any semblance of volume in my experience. https://polymarket.com/event/is-the-room-temp-superconductor-real https://polymarket.com/event/is-the-room-temp-superconductor... resolution criteria also leaves a bit to be desired imo
- codethief 3y agoYesterday someone posted a couple links and I remember this one: https://manifold.markets/QuantumObserver/will-the-lk99-room-temp-ambient-pre https://manifold.markets/QuantumObserver/will-the-lk99-room-...