5 ms·

It's interesting how this site gets around the ``rel="noreferrer"`` added to the link from HN. The banner uses a :visited CSS attribute to selectively show/hide

It's interesting how this site gets around the ``rel="noreferrer"`` added to the link from HN. The banner uses a :visited CSS attribute to selectively show/hide the banner client side if your browser has been to the URL https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36971867 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36971867. With how many other browser history privacy leaks have been released lately using :visited hacks, I wonder how long it will be until browser vendors disable :visited support across domains entirely.

fotta 3y ago
I’m not seeing the banner when coming from the comments on iOS Safari. Maybe it just doesn’t show on mobile though.
- cosmojg 3y ago
  Nah, I'm getting it on mobile via Firefox. Sounds like a Safari thing.
  - iakov 3y ago
    Can confirm - no banner on Safari. So petty and ineffective at the same time!
  - doodlesdev 3y ago
    Also on Firefox on Android but not getting the banner. edit: Enabling JavaScript makes it show up. What a fucking ridiculous banner that is too, thankfully I don't have a macbook so I don't need to use this.
    - hot_gril 3y ago
      I'm confused, does the banner block the page normally? Firefox on Mac here with default settings aside from uBO extension, opened in separate (non-private) tab with cmd-click. Banner was at the bottom and didn't block anything. I didn't even notice it until I read the comments here.
      - doodlesdev 3y ago
        For me it did block the full screen.
twiss 3y ago
There is indeed a proposal to partition :visited links: https://github.com/kyraseevers/Partitioning-visited-links-history https://github.com/kyraseevers/Partitioning-visited-links-hi...
cbarrick 3y ago
Interesting that it only checks for the comments page. If you (like me) read the article before coming to the comments, then you'll not see the banner. That feels like a typical user flow, which should make the banner fairly ineffective. I feel for the developer, even if I am annoyed by the banner. It sucks to know that folks on HN have been so mean, when on a technical level, Asahi is a great project.
- twiss 3y ago
  I typically open both the article and comments in tabs, and then read the article first (promise! :)), but I did see the banner.
throwawaylpsa1 3y ago
You can get around the banner with this uBlock custom rule: asahilinux.org##[aria-hidden="true"]
CaptainFever 3y ago
I find it creepy that websites have a way to access my browser history. Luckily it seems like iOS Safari isn’t vulnerable, as is Tor (which I guess solves it by being in permanent private browsing mode?)

fotta 3y ago

I’m not seeing the banner when coming from the comments on iOS Safari. Maybe it just doesn’t show on mobile though.

cosmojg 3y ago
Nah, I'm getting it on mobile via Firefox. Sounds like a Safari thing.
- iakov 3y ago
  Can confirm - no banner on Safari. So petty and ineffective at the same time!
- doodlesdev 3y ago
  Also on Firefox on Android but not getting the banner. edit: Enabling JavaScript makes it show up. What a fucking ridiculous banner that is too, thankfully I don't have a macbook so I don't need to use this.
  - hot_gril 3y ago
    I'm confused, does the banner block the page normally? Firefox on Mac here with default settings aside from uBO extension, opened in separate (non-private) tab with cmd-click. Banner was at the bottom and didn't block anything. I didn't even notice it until I read the comments here.
    - doodlesdev 3y ago
      For me it did block the full screen.

twiss 3y ago

There is indeed a proposal to partition :visited links: https://github.com/kyraseevers/Partitioning-visited-links-history https://github.com/kyraseevers/Partitioning-visited-links-hi...

cbarrick 3y ago

Interesting that it only checks for the comments page. If you (like me) read the article before coming to the comments, then you'll not see the banner. That feels like a typical user flow, which should make the banner fairly ineffective. I feel for the developer, even if I am annoyed by the banner. It sucks to know that folks on HN have been so mean, when on a technical level, Asahi is a great project.

twiss 3y ago
I typically open both the article and comments in tabs, and then read the article first (promise! :)), but I did see the banner.

throwawaylpsa1 3y ago

You can get around the banner with this uBlock custom rule: asahilinux.org##[aria-hidden="true"]

CaptainFever 3y ago

I find it creepy that websites have a way to access my browser history. Luckily it seems like iOS Safari isn’t vulnerable, as is Tor (which I guess solves it by being in permanent private browsing mode?)