8 ms·
Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince answered this directly on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828702 Most r
by freedomben 3y ago
Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince answered this directly on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828702
Most relevant piece but the whole comment is worth a read:
> Archive.is’s authoritative DNS servers return bad results to 1.1.1.1 when we query them. I’ve proposed we just fix it on our end but our team, quite rightly, said that too would violate the integrity of DNS and the privacy and security promises we made to our users when we launched the service.
> The archive.is owner has explained that he returns bad results to us because we don’t pass along the EDNS subnet information. This information leaks information about a requester’s IP and, in turn, sacrifices the privacy of users.
Honestly it's that type of thing (the frankness, the presence on HN, willingness to participate, the principled stand on privacy) that got me into Cloudflare products. I now generate hundreds per month in revenue for them and that will likely be thousands in the next year or two. His time/effort on HN directly led to customer acquisition and revenue.
That said I do worry about the incentives Cloudflare has to their big customers. CF is a great tool for site owners, but like any tool has the potential to be a great evil (against the user) if the principles ever wane. It's already being used by a lot of sites to make life a living hell for people behind a VPN. As a site owner I absolutely get it: practically zero of my legitimate traffic comes from VPNs (our main demographic tend to skew older and much less technical than the average consumer), but all of the automated attacks against me do. Balancing freedom and rights is hard, but I deeply appreciate the thoughtfulness and principles that CF has displayed over the years.
- mschuster91 3y ago[flagged]
- afavour 3y ago> Given that Cloudflare is participating in the greatest threat to user freedom in history I’m sorry but hyperbole like that distracts from the point you’re making.
- mikecoles 3y agoAttestation lumped in with their MiTM attacks does make Cloudflare a large threat to user freedom.
- wizzwizz4 3y agoConsidering computer users, in the modern sense, have only been around for around 60 years, this is plausibly not hyperbole.
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoTrying to create a monopolistic cartel where only a select few corporations can make devices or browsers, as described in my other comment[1] is seen as evil by most countries out there[2]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36197401 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36197401 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_law
- mschuster91 3y agoGiven that Cloudflare has ~80% of the CDN marketshare and ~20% of the total web marketshare (a number that keeps on growing, simply because no one dares to prosecute bad actors and so site operators are all but forced to hide under the protection racket), their push for PAT will lead to users effectively being locked out of a lot of online services if they do not pass the Blessed Test aka have modified their device in any way that The Gods have not determined to be acceptable. It's bad enough on mobile - try banking apps, Netflix, Google Pay, Samsung's Watch companion app or pretty much any game on a rooted Android, you'll have to bytecode patch your way around. I do not want that crap on desktop as well. [1] https://kinsta.com/cloudflare-market-share/ https://kinsta.com/cloudflare-market-share/
- afavour 3y agoThis is kind of what I mean about hyperbole. > their push for PAT will lead to users effectively being locked out of a lot of online services if they do not pass the Blessed Test The blog post you linked to specifically explains that Cloudflare are using PATs to replace CAPTCHAs. Do you find yourself filling out Cloudflare CAPTCHAs on a regular basis when accessing 80% of web services? I personally do not, nor have I heard anyone complain about such a thing. If you're not filling out a CAPTCHA today you're not going to be required to provide a PAT tomorrow. Even if you _are_ required to provide a PAT to access a service your inability to do so means it'll fall back to what happens today: you fill out a CAPTCHA. I'm not saying this is amazing or even anything positive at all but I think it does a disservice to exaggerate the situation. It leads to people dismissing the issue out of hand.
- xcdzvyn 3y agoCould you elaborate on your concerns about PATs?
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoInsisting that a browser or device be attested by the manufacturer locks out smaller firms or indie developers from developing alternatives to said browsers or devices, as they would be in a catch-22 situation, where they'd be seen as illegitimate till they get a broader audience, and unless they attest their devices they can't get an audience. The same situation exists in other areas as well. Trying to bootstrap a search engine? Well tough luck, because what are you trying to do with a headless version of Chromium? This in turn creates a cartel where only few players can compete, and the members of said cartel can enter new markets without ever having to compete.
- eastdakota 3y agoIn this particular case we truncate EDNS to protect the privacy of users because we believe 1) privacy is a fundamental human right; and 2) the original sin of the Internet is that IP addresses are too closely tied to the identities of individuals and services. Truncating EDNS is trying to honor #1 and overcome #2. So is our work on protocols like Oblivious DNS. This work, frankly, upsets some of our customers or potential customers (like Archive.is). But it’s the right thing to do for the long term health of the Internet.
- nora-puchreiner 3y ago[flagged]
- sitzkrieg 3y agoagreed, came to point this out. or they monitor hn to go be the heroes of centralized internet yet again
- eastdakota 3y agoI wish we (and the rest of the world) were as organized as it’d take to support conspiracy theories. Easier explanation probably is that I just woke up about 90 minutes ago. HN is about #9 on the list of things I check every morning. Saw this post and thought: “Oh not this again!” Pinged our team to get latest status since I hadn’t thought about archive.is in several years. And then jumped into the comments. But your story is way more fun, makes us look way more organized, and, frankly, would give me hope that there are really smart people out there organizing and planning the chaos. So let’s go with yours.
- nora-puchreiner 3y agoBrands do creative marketing and do invest in it (especially after they stock fell on Q2 report). That is why they are brands. There is no "conspiracy" nor "chaos".
- 3y ago
- lopkeny12ko 3y agoThis is honestly such a tone-deaf answer. At the end of the day, users don't care about the purity of adherence to some far-down technical principles or details. As a product leader, you should task your team to solve real user problems and not spend literal years arguing about EDNS. Truly, just imagine the user story: "I can't access this website." "No worries! That is by design, because the protocol response returned to CF is illegal, and the server simply propagates the error back to you. It would be impure for CF to modify the response in-flight to fix this for you." "?? I do not care. I am talking to CF, why can't CF just fix the issue?"
- dogleash 3y agoAs creators, it’s our job to care about these things for the benefit of users BECAUSE they’re laypeople.
- deadalus 3y agoCloudflare banned 8chan without a legal requirement to do so. They banned it based on moral reasons.
- throw0101b 3y ago> Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince answered this directly on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828702 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19828702 Archive.is' explanation is quoted in a comment below: * https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36971650 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36971650
- johnklos 3y agoCloudflare is in the wrong here. They want to "protect" people from their own ISPs, from nefarious web and DNS servers that'll "sacrifice the privacy of users" by - you guessed it - doing exactly the same thing themselves. They've given very little reason to trust them, while giving plenty of reasons to think they might be evil (like protecting known spammers / scammers / phishers). If another company did what Cloudflare does and homogenized tons of requests behind them, you can bet Cloudflare's CAPTCHA systems would block them in a second. I have zero respect for Cloudflare's inability to answer criticisms about what they do, about their constant deflections from simple, straightforward questions, and the fact that they do to others what they would never accept anyone else doing to them. It's hypocrisy in the service of trying to become a monopoly by re-centralizing the Internet. Don't believe me? Go ahead and look for examples of Matthew Prince addressing concerns that much of the non-western world can't access Cloudflare fronted sites because of Cloudflare's "reasons". When you don't find any that have more than just vague platitudes and handwaving, imagine how you'd feel if you were one of those multiple billion people.
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoEDNS is OPTIONAL. archive.is is objectively in the wrong here.
- johnklos 3y agoEDNS is in part how using one IP address across the world can work without tons of latency for everyone who isn't geographically local. In other words, 1.1.1.1 would be a lot shittier, and the DNS answers they provide would be much less geographically appropriate, if they didn't make use of information about the source of a query. In other words, Cloudflare expects us to think they're so special that they should get to do what they explicitly don't want others doing. It's bullshit, particularly for all the people who are victims of Cloudflare's manipulations such as the default use of Cloudflare DNS servers for DNS-over-https on Firefox, which users were never asked about before it was enabled for them (at least in the US).
- tick_tock_tick 3y ago
- IggleSniggle 3y agoYour take is so on the money. I'm a staunch CF advocate, but so much rests on the trust they engender. Their power is a consequence in their presence as a trustable company working across the infrastructure of the Internet. There's so many pathways where the enforcers of good behavior eventually end up as the Pharaohs. I genuinely love Cloudflare while being simultaneously extremely wary of Cloudflare.
- Zuiii 3y agoIt's the opposite for me. Cloudflare presents me with so many infinite "Are you human" check boxes when using Tor that I decided to never pay a single cent to that company unless we found ourselves in a situation were there was no other choice. Thankfully, there almost always choice, with most vendors now offering very good alternatives. I work in government IT procurement.