4 ms·
Lawmakers propose 'speed limiters' for repeat offenders in New York
- chpatrick 3y agoThat seems dangerous in an emergency situation and technically complicated to implement. They should fine people proportionately to their wealth instead like in Germany.
- networkchad 3y ago[dead]
- stop50 3y agoWrong country. The fines are abdolute, not relative. There are fines that are relative to your daily income, but not traffic code violations.
- woodruffw 3y agoI agree that it’s technically complicated, but I don’t understand what you mean by dangerous in an emergency situation: nobody besides emergency services should really be speeding on NYC streets to begin with, and this seems strictly more accommodating than just taking these drivers’ licenses away (which is well precedented).
- steanne 3y agonot everyone who is rushed to the emergency room arrives in an ambulance.
- edgyquant 3y agoSpeeding in a normal car means you may get pulled over and that will increase the time getting there.
- bluGill 3y agoIf it is really an emergency you should have already called 911. Maybe the dispatcher says drive as fast as you can cause we cannot get an ambulance to you - but in that case you stay on the phone. The dispatcher talking to you is also on radio with police and the flashing lights are your escort as the dispatcher will tell you. But the above is something that I doubt will actually happen - ambulances are generally close.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoRoads are engineered for a particular speed and flow of traffic. If you exceed the design limits of the road, you may feel very unsafe and be quite inclined to slow down again. This applies even to large, wide, noticeable emergency vehicles. Residential streets often participate in noticeable "traffic calming" measures, like roundabouts, speed humps, wasp waist narrowing, landscaping and trees, signage, etc. Most of the time when I see emergency vehicles plowing down the street, they are pretty much going at the limit, but they look faster, because all the traffic signals favor them, and all the other motorists have pulled out of the way. But a fire truck has still gotta slow down or stop at a busy intersection or just a turn. Pedestrians are a thing. And scooters, and cyclists wearing headphones...
- bluGill 3y agoThat depends on the emergency and the road. In Manhattan you cannot go as fast as the rural highways - but the only places you would go are also pretty close. In rural areas when seconds count the correct hospital may be hours away (rural hospitals cannot solve all problems), and those emergency personal will drive much faster than the road design (which is also designed much faster than Manhattan) if that is what it takes to get there.
- woodruffw 3y agoThe US has no concept of “speeding in an emergency” for ordinary drivers. It’s illegal regardless: we allow emergency services to speed because they’re (nominally) qualified to. And note: we’re talking about a city with extraordinary EMS and urgent care density. I don’t buy the argument that we need to allow repeat offenders on the road regardless, but especially not in NYC.
- f1shy 3y agoI think this applies in most of the civilized world. Even Ambulance and Firefighters have to prove they were in a mission that required the speed. It is not a card to do whatever you want with the vehicle
- bluGill 3y agoIf you need to go faster than the legal speed limit you need proper sirens and flashing lights, along with more training than most drivers have. Call 911 and they will get someone to you.
- f1shy 3y agoGermany the fines do not depend on income. Are fixed. AFAIK this is in Switzerland, for local citizens.
- jaclaz 3y agoFinland does that, example: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/06/finnish-businessman-hit-with-121000-speeding-fine https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/06/finnish-busine...
- tokai 3y agoSeems like a lot of effort to keep asocial drivers on the road. Why not just take their drivers license? Then move on to prison time if they keep driving.
- pjc50 3y ago> six speeding tickets and red-light camera violations, or four speed camera or red-light violations, in a year That does sound like people who are completely oblivious to the law.
- analog31 3y agoMaybe they have courtesy cards from the police. https://www.vice.com/en/article/v7gxa4/pba-card-police-courtesy-cards https://www.vice.com/en/article/v7gxa4/pba-card-police-court...
- zeteo 3y agoOr 11 points, which is basically going 25 mph over twice in 18 months.
- tokai 3y ago25mph over is bonkers. Doing that twice in a one and a half year should definitely have heavy consequences.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zeteo 3y agoYou're probably thinking 50 in a 25 zone, which is indeed crazy. But 80 on a 55 stretch in the middle of nowhere is not at all unusual in a lot of places.
- i_am_jl 3y ago>But 80 on a 55 stretch in the middle of nowhere is not at all unusual in a lot of places. Or anywhere on the NY Thruway.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoFor six tickets in a year?! Just take away their license.
- ethanbond 3y agoAnd their car/whatever car they were driving. A lot of these types of people are fine driving without licenses, but if they’re without a car and no one will loan them one, that might work.
- lostapathy 3y agoIf they have that much disregard for the law, do you think losing their license will keep them off the road? Doubtful.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoThen put them in jail for driving without a license.
- lostapathy 3y agoIs it that simple, though? Taking someone who's already crime-prone then sending them off to graduate school for criminals rarely leaves society with a better person when they get out. I'm not saying, at all, that we should let them run amok. But at the same time, the US has a ridiculous incarceration rate as it is, and it's not like we've created a utopia by doing that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoThat weirdly enough doesn't work in the USA. As someone from Belgium or Germany how they feel about driving without a valid license and they'll look at you like you asked them to calculate i^2=-1. Same thing with no insurance. Yet here in the USA (in most states) we can buy a car off the lot with paper/no plates and have a grace period to register it. You have a grace period on your insurance on which they need to cover the new vehicle at the old terms. That already gives some leeway. And stretching leeway is much easier than actually getting leeway to begin with.
- throw__away7391 3y agoI’m on board. And while we are on the subject how about restricting the horn from working inside city limits. I have had the idea for a while that your car horn could be programmed to just get quieter and quieter the more you use it, perhaps gradually shifting pitch to sound a bit silly as well.
- aitchnyu 3y agoOne manufacturer released a report of horn usage time in various countries. If its already integrated into the electronics, it should play back the same sound into cabin if its overused, also stopping music and AC. Yes I hate carmakers heaping features, but horn use of fellow Indians are infuriating.
- dmalvarado 3y agoI often wish vehicles were equipped with a regular horn and a "polite" horn. As in "don't mean to be a bother, but the light is green now. Whenever you're done checking your phone is fine."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoI would like a polite horn so I can use it ironically. I love these e-Scooters with their twee little mechanical bicycle bell that sometimes works. I induced some heavy duty road rage in a motorcyclist by ringing his bell.
- AlgorithmicTime 3y ago[dead]
- logicalmonster 3y agoNot a huge fan of this. The really dangerous drivers in New York aren't dangerous because they're speeding. They're really dangerous because they weave in and out of tightly packed traffic trying to find a minuscule gap to wedge themselves into to try and go around everybody. If anything, being unable to go fast is going to psychologically compel impatient people to take even more risks to make up for time they'll be perceiving themselves as losing due to being limited in speed. Additionally, limiting their car's speed is going to make this process even more dangerous for bystanders because they're not going to have the power available to actually perform these maneuvers. If you want to focus on public safety, figure out a way to get slow-pokes out of the passing lane who camp there next to a truck for an hour and clump up traffic, and get cops to focus on drivers who wildly weave from lane to lane with no signals.
- mannykannot 3y agoThese are indeed significant problems, but on urban streets, speed, in itself, is a significant risk multiplier.
- woodruffw 3y agoThis is NYC; ideally all of the drivers would be “slow-pokes” on city streets. I don’t think we even have passing lanes in the city, besides highways.
- i_am_jl 3y agoThis whole thread is peak "NYC forgets that NY State exists"
- woodruffw 3y agoIn my defense, it’s very easy to. Then again: the law in question has bounds that are reasonable across the entire state. You shouldn’t speed; if you think the limit is too low, petition to get it raised. I wouldn’t object particularly if this bill was stapled to a limit increase on I-87.
- _yb2s 3y agoThis is not technically possible… vehicles differ enough that it would require a one off engineered solution for each individual vehicle. Especially older mechanically injected diesels or carburetor gasoline engines which have no electronic engine controls- a a speed limiting device would need to mechanically intercept the throttle linkage, which is designed and attached differently on every vehicle. Moreover, GPS technology and mapping metadata aren’t accurate enough to reliably tell which road a car is on, or what the speed limit actually is. I use google maps to show the speed limit while I’m driving and it’s frequently wrong. Imagine if they are on a freeway but it pegs them as being on a parallel frontage road with a speed limit 45mph lower? That would be a major hazard.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoBut, There Oughta Be A Law!!1
- lnsru 3y agoThen these vehicles will be banned as not compatible to the new law.
- _yb2s 3y agoYou can’t ban older grandfathered in vehicles in the USA. It’s even still legal to drive ancient vehicles without turn signals or tail lights as long as the vehicle was sold new like that. Even in California, the best they’ve been able to do is a voluntary buyback program to get old high emissions vehicles off the roads.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoLet's laser focus on one single thing, and let's solve it by enshrining into the law that the aftermarket auto device industry gets a cut for every incident. Perhaps NY can land a sponsorship from Ford, and mandate which make and model of vehicle the "offender" must purchase, you know, for compatibility. /s
- exabrial 3y agoSolution looking for a problem…. Or maybe solution looking for a kickback from a lawmaker.
- ForgottenPwd 3y agoThere is already a point system to take away their license. Why not enforce the existing regulation? Also, the US system of traffic fines is a joke. A $250 fine for someone making minimum wage is going to hurt a huge amount, but that same fine is going to be meaningless to someone making $100,000/yr. Fines should be based on a percentage of gross yearly income.
- woliveirajr 3y ago> ensuring they could not exceed the speed limit by more than five miles per hour I'm just afraid that this measure can have some impact when the person really needs to overspeed. Like some medical condition in the middle of the night. Not everybody lives near some hospital, nor ambulances can cover the whole city.
- _fat_santa 3y agoA feature like this would be extremely dangerous in "striped yellow" lanes (where you can pass into on-coming traffic). When you're passing like that, the speed limit goes out the window and your main goal is to get back into your lane before any on-coming cars come. Limiting speed would cause head on collisions because drivers wouldn't be able to pass.
- btbuildem 3y agoAs an urban driver, cyclist and pedestrian, issues around this have been on my mind for a while. This is the best I've come up with (and mind you, some of my suggestions are brutal): - Absolute speed isn't as important as relative speed; if the "speed limit" on a highway is 60 but everyone habitually goes 80, the one person insisting on obeying the speed limit is creating a dangerous situation - Nothing but physical limitations will deter the types of offenders mentioned in the article. They'll repeatedly drive drunk, they'll drive with their licence and insurance revoked, they'll drive drunk again after serving a prison term. - Focusing on speeding is ineffectual; there are many more ways in which drivers are dangerous - the main being distraction and aggression. Speeding is just a symptom. - In the past few years, drivers seem to have become increasingly callous, selfish and borderline sociopathic. It's not a good trend for persons piloting lethal weapons. Drivers feel far, far too safe and act like they're above consequences. So, solutions? - Physical infrastructure -- nothing controls the flow of vehicles better than physical conditions - Remove 80% of stop signs, replace with yield signs. People act more carefully when there's uncertainty - Build more roundabouts, replacing intersections where traffic volume allows. Roundabouts reduce the number and severity of collisions and resulting injuries. - At problematic light-controlled intersections, install physical barriers. Bollards that go up when the lights turn red, or equivalent sturdy, ruthless barriers that will turn a speeding red-light runner into soup and destroy their vehicle. There's no arguing with physics. - Use primarily one-way streets in residential settings. - Narrowing of lanes near intersections in residential neighbourhoods: a road can have two lanes of parking and two lanes of travel, but at an intersection it narrows to a choke point, forcing traffic to slow. The choke point is formed out of pedestrian islands, which create extra room for pedestrians and make them more visible - Raised crosswalks: akin to a speed bump but longer and flat-topped, raise the road surface instead of lowering the sidewalk where pedestrians cross the roadway. Vulnerable road users are the priority, express that in concrete terms